Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Palestine: Boats break siege of Gaza

The latest news on the two boats attempting to sail to the Gaza Strip as an act of solidarity is that they have reached Gaza, despite earlier warnings that they might not be permitted to do so. Bloggers have reacted to the action with both excitement and concern.

Before the news was announced, pro-Palestinian UK blogger bruised earth feared the worst:

This will fly under the radar of most news reporting this weekend (as Obama’s selection of Joe Biden as his Vice-Presidential running mate will doubtless scoop up all media attention), but this is a very important story to note for those concerned about Gaza, and more importantly free protest and demonstration. According to Al Jazeera, Israel’s Foreign Minister Aviv Shiron has issued threats to two vessels from the ‘Free Gaza’ Protest Group, who are attempting to land in Gaza to deliver balloons and hearing aids. Let me repeat that threatening cargo – balloons (for children) and hearing aids (for the hard of hearing). There are rumours the Israeli Navy may even fire upon the ships as they enter the Gaza coast in the next few hours. Forget about this VP-selection news vortex you are about to enter, and keep your eyes on the Gaza coast – it’s important.

Palestinian blogger Laila El-Haddad, who blogs at Raising Yousuf and Nour, has a personal connection to the action:

Many of you have by now likely heard of the Free Gaza movement, whose two boats full of 46 civilian activists (including my uncle, a UK based engineer) from 14 countries are attempting to break the siege on Gaza by sailing to its shores from Cyprus. Among the passengers are Jeff Halper, founder of Israel Committee Against House Demolitions, an 81-year-old Catholic nun, the sister-in-law of Mideast envoy and former British Prime Minister Tony Blair, and an 84 year old Holocaust survivor. They are meant to arrive today, and everyone is waiting anxiously to see whether they will make it or not. Their journey has been fraught with technical difficulties, rough sea conditions, and electronic piracy-scrambled radio signals and jammed phones.
But despite it all, it appears they are making it into the Gaza harbor!! … Meanwhile, in Gaza, tens of thousands of Palestinians are waiting on shore to celebrate the much anticipated and daring arrival. My mother and Aunt were on board Palestinian vessels on the Gaza side that went out to greet the international vessels; apparently they had to turn back to Gaza shore after hearing Israeli naval warning shots. I have been unable to make contact with them since this morning, but we all anxiously to hear if this attempt to break the siege will succeed and what the next stage of this heroic saga will be.

However, some activists have concerns about the Free Gaza action. Marcy Newman, a pro-Palestinian US activist who blogs at Body on the Line, disagrees with what the activists on the boats are trying to do:

In spite of the good intentions of many of the activists organizing this boat, I have serious problems with it on a number of levels. 1st, it seemed to me that the organizers didn’t necessarily want to get into Gaza. Rather, it seemed as though they intended to create an action that would necessitate that they not get in merely to call attention to the fact that this siege exists. … (M)y 2nd problem with the boat (is that) it isn’t bringing supplies into Gaza, a place where people are in desperate need (such an understatement) for everything and anything from anesthesia to bread. 3rd, the boat is asking people to raise all this money to support the boat itself in lieu of using the money to support the people of Gaza by building community gardens that would feed people, for instance; and the money is not just being raised for the boat, as people who go on it are required to pay their passage to Cyprus and then pay a fee of at least $1,000 to the boat. 4th, I was told that the people invited or selected to go on the boat, once in Cyprus, would be further whittled down based on unknown criteria. 5th, couldn’t that money be used for something better–like for the people of Gaza?…6th, these activists are only staying for a few days, it seems, or at least most of them so I expect there will not be any real solidarity or political, or humanitarian work done (or at least this remains to be seen). 7th, this ship has Israelis on it. I’m sure they are Israelis who consider themselves anti-Zionist, but that is not the point. I’m sure some of these people do good work, but the point is: they are Israelis. The people organizing such an action should know better than to arrange for such an action that becomes one that is about normalization. … (I)f Israelis care about the situation then they should work within their own society to end this occupation and bring about the right of return for Palestinian refugees.

German blogger Karin, at Munich – and a little bit of everything, also disagrees with the premise of the action, and gives her ‘two cents‘:

I was against this trip from start…Before elaborating I want to set one thing straight … I have been an activist myself…been to Gaza five times, love the Gazans…would do EVERYTHING in my power to help in order to give them the life they deserve which naturally puts as condition to lift this INHUMAN SIEGE as well as, if we talk about this issue already, the ENTIRE OCCUPATION!
(It) is all a wonderful idea. Yet the way it is done is wrong. Hamas is the legally elected ruling party in the Gaza strip but, if one likes it or not, agrees to it or rejects it, is considered a terrorist group by Israel as well as European countries and the United States. … The group sailing to Gaza has received an official invitation of Hamas… so what do you think will happen?…Another point I want to stress is money! It was reported they collected $300 000 (or was it more?) for to buy the boats and everything involved. Picture how much GOOD this money could have done had it been given to for instance to UNRWA which is allowed to bring in goods! How about antibiotics? Urgently needed anesthetics?

Arab-American blog KABOBfest reports that the boats have landed:

Its 6:10 in Palestine and the USS Liberty and Free Gaza have just docked in Gaza City’s port. Apart from when Palestinians knocked down the border wall in Rafah this past January, this is the first time the siege on Gaza has been broken.

8 comments

  • Bitin Dawg

    Let this not be the last trip. Next time take in food and medicine. BitinDawg@BellSouth.Net

  • CSW

    There is no such nation as “Palestine.” Palestinians are represented by terrorists, not diplomats. Gazans occupy land that Israel gave them, requesting nothing in return but peace. Instead, Israel gets rockets and suicide bombers – attacks not against the military, but against innocent civilians. Those who launch the rocket attacks against innocent Israeli women and children, then hide behind their own civilians, increasing collateral damage when Israel returns fire. Like cowards, they would rather their own people die than stand out in the open and fight Israel’s military. And this deserves what in return? Respect? Right of return? In 1948, Israel begged Arabs to stay as free and equal citizens. Many did and have happy, fulfilling lives today as Israeli citizens. It’s not Israel’s fault that others fled and live in squalor. Israel desires peace. Palestinians desire the destruction of Israel and all Jews dead. Finally, it is not an “occupation.” Jews lived in the land called Israel almost two thousand years before the Muslim religion was created. Romans called Jews “Philistines.” Thus, Jews have a longer and more significant ownership of the land called Israel. After the Holocaust, there must be one safe place in the world for Jews. It might as well be their first, best homeland – the land that Jews occupied centuries before there were Muslims and Palestinians.

  • Robby

    I think the siege on Gaza should be solved; too many innocent civilians are suffering. HAMAS should do all it can to end it. And I believe they could almost immediately by meeting the three conditions: recognize Israel, denounce violence vs. Israel, and honor previous agreements between Israel and the Palestinians.

    The boats floating to Gaza seem like nothing more then a publicity stunt that accomplished very little. Israel chose to do nothing, and the world’s press seems bored with it. Also the amount of supplies will do little to help.

    We can only speculate, but I wonder if Egypt had actually been able to close Aqaba back in 1967, would they have allowed a couple of ships with Israeli flags thru if theyn knew it was carrying humanitarian aid? And I wonder if the Arab public would have supported letting the ships thru?

  • Joe Cortina

    I am one of only a handful of Americans that have been on the ‘inside’ in Gaza with the intelligence community several years ago. and I have seen my share of horrors violence an death but the cowardice and cruelty of the IDF was unparralled. Defenseless children were shot like animals-homes destroyed crops ruined and worse. I have witnessed evil – but nothing like the sadistic cold-blooded mentality of the IDF. I have traveled over the world – was a Special Operations airborne commander before most of the readers here were born and i need no advice about i ‘ “just don’t understand the situation” Intel analysis IS my forte’ and I understand EXACTLY what the situation is. I have also spent time in IsraHELL and will NEVER forget the things I saw. I agree perhaps the boats should take much neded medical essentails- but more importantly -the witnesses need to tell the world what they saw there. The Israelis and in my Jew occupied country they have hidden the truth of their crimes for a long time. When the free world finally learns this – there will be literally – HELL TO PAY. One day the Jews will pick on somebody that can fight back instead of children women and sick elderly civilians. American Jews have made a morally rotted corpse out of MY beloved America and for that i can NEVER forgive them for this mega-crime. My heart is with the Palestinians and those brave souls who are fighting for freedom. I pray for the day when Zionism is dead and the WORLD may celebrate the death of the devil on earth.

  • CSW

    So, exploding yourself on a bus, in a restaurant, a movie theatre, night club or near children waiting in line is not the deliberate murder of innocent women and children? If you think that you “saw hell,” then what does it look like just after a suicide bomber’s detonation? That too is hell. That too is “cold-blooded murder” of innocents.

    The IDF is not perfect. But, they do not deliberately target innocent women and children. If such an accident happens, the offending soldiers are punished severely, according Israeli laws.

    The height of cowardice is to strap on explosives and detonate them next to innocent women and children. That is deliberate genocide. Have you ever heard of a Jewish suicide bomber?

    Zionsim will never die and Israel is here to stay. Almost every Jew in the world would die to protect our homeland. Jews lived in the place called Israel many, many centuries before the creation of the Muslim religion. It is the Jewish homeland. Jews never left Israel, although many were murdered and many more taken into slavery. But, it is, and will always be, the Jewish homeland.

    When Israel was created, the nascent government begged the Arab population to remain as free and equal citizens. Those who remained now live good lives as Israeli citizens, with jobs, homes and a rewarding lifestyle. It’s too bad that those who fled live in squalor, but that is not Israel’s problem or cause.

    Israel offered peace twice (Oslo and Camp David), but Arafat did not want it. Israel gave the Gaza back and in return got rocket attacks, snipers and suicide bombers. Israel backed away from Lebanon and in return got Hezbollah kidnappings, rockets and an invasion. So, which side wants peace and which side wants war?

    I am for a two-state solution. But this cannot occur until the enemies of Israel agree to allow Israel to exist. The current charters of Hamas and Hezbollah call for Israel’s extermination. Which side wants peace? How can Israel negotiate when Hamas and Hezbollah desire nothing short of Israel’s destruction? Should Israel negotiate for half of its population to be destroyed? This is the root of the problem. Until Palestinians agree to allow Israel to exist, there can be no peace.

  • Doug P.

    Atten CSW: You are a prevaricator.

  • Rachel Page

    I hope a time will come when all of this will end. I wish for peace. How to reduce debt in San Antonio

  • Karen Patrick

    Gazan (Muslims, Christians, Jewish and all people from Gaza combined)
    have proven to have a fighting spirit which is really and truly
    unrivaled and second to none!

    Karen

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site