A portion of Trinidad and Tobago's artistic community is up in arms about the demolition of Beryl McBurnie‘s house, a property that was shortlisted by the National Trust — the organisation charged with safeguarding the country's heritage sites — to be considered for protected status. The house was bulldozed to the ground on September 16.
Affectionately called by her stage name, “La Belle Rosette”, McBurnie, who died in 2000, was one of the pioneers of Caribbean dance and the founder of The Little Carib Theatre, which she used to promote the arts and culture of both Trinidad and Tobago and the wider Caribbean region.
While The Little Carib Theatre is widely recognised as McBurnie's legacy, the razing of her home has left a bitter taste in the mouths of many netizens accustomed to seeing historically significant landmarks in the state destroyed.
Nearly two years ago, Greyfriar's Presbyterian Church in Port of Spain was demolished by the site's new owner.
Cultural activist Rubadiri Victor was the first to break the news on Facebook:
They bulldozed to the ground the home of Beryl Mc Bernie […] the Mother of Caribbean Dance, the co-creator of Best Village, the preserver of our Folk traditions, the first choreographer of our Independence Festival, the founder of the Little Carib Theatre, the godmother of literally thousands of performers, companies, and performances here and in the diaspora. Her house. They bulldozed it. With things in it.
We cannot be serious as a people. Cannot. We must confess now that the whole Independence thing, the flag, the anthem, everything, was just a big joke. A flam ting [a local term for ‘show off’] and we’re ready to move on now to Mc Donald’s, the Union Jack, Trump, the Star Spangled, whatever Reality Show boat-ride that comes along. Anything! But this Civilisation called Trinidad and Tobagp [sic]? We flunking dat exam. Cause we aint serious as big people, as Independent people, as heirs to one of the richest cultural traditions on planet Earth. WE CANNOT BE SERIOUS!!!
He went on to explain:
The tragedy in Beryl’s Home is this. This was a facility that could have been earning millions of dollars. […] A proposal was drafted by the Artists’ Coalition of T&T (ACTT) [which Victor himself heads] to turn the abandoned house into an Adaptive-Use Heritage Site which would have featured: an interactive Beryl Mc Bernie and Caribbean Dance multi-media Museum; an office for the Beryl Mc Bernie Trust; a working artist studio and small dance studio; and living quarters and working space for Residencies for top international dance practitioners. The Site would have been a pilgrimage point for students and nationals locally and for curious international tourists. Now that dream is no more […]
Of course the contempt didn’t begin today. The house lay abandoned and overgrown for years whilst billions of dollars were being spent on fireworks, champagne, and box-drains… […] Upon her death the lack of any active Heritage legislation and the possession of completely zero National Cultural Policy or National Heroes Policy (which would have had protocols for the treatment of the homes and Legacy items of National Heroes) meant that everything she left behind was ripe for ruin.
Journalist and blogger Vernon O'Reilly Ramesar was so disillusioned by the demolition that he ranted:
You know what? This place deserves to die a painful death. […] No respect for a woman who basically created T&T dance culture? This is a new level of disgusting in a landscape that has far too many examples of disgusting.
In reality, McBurnie's legacy has not been disregarded; it is being looked after by the board of The Little Carib Theatre, and any items of worth or cultural significance were removed from her residence years ago.
The theatre space is in operation and has been recently renovated, but it is no secret that fundraising for the arts in Trinidad and Tobago can be an uphill battle. Thus, the board took the decision to sell McBurnie's residence, reportedly to fund more pressing projects.
According to the property's new owner Dexter John, who organised the demolition, the house had been listed for sale a while ago.
While he understands that the artistic community may be upset over the action, he told the TV6 News that any blame lies with the board of the Little Carib.
But journalist Franka Phillip made the argument that responsibility for the demolition was, in fact, collective:
There's lots of outrage over the demolition of Beryl McBurnie's home on Panka St, St James. But what's the point of outrage now if you didn't actually give any thought to the deterioration of this historical building over the years? How many people actually listened to and supported those who pushed the cause? People talk about what ‘the government’ doing and they're right but more importantly what are we doing to help preserve our treasures?
On Twitter, netizens shared their disappointment at the loss of the home.
I remember cleaning Ms Beryl McBurnie's house as a little boy going to St. Agnes Primary School. Sad to see the house demolished.
— Jayvon Sparta George (@JayvonGeorge) September 16, 2016
I sure Beryl McBurnie rolling her in grave at that stupidness that went on.
— RkSeabrun (@ReginaKSeabrun) June 27, 2016
However, Rudylynn Roberts, an architect who specialises in restoration, noted that “Beryl McBurnie's legacy is actually the establishment of The Little Carib Theatre and her memory will always be kept alive there.”
While she was saddened at the news of the demolition, and suggested that the site could still be acknowledged as her home — via a plaque of some sort, for instance — she noted that even casual observation showed serious structural issues and that the building itself, though eclectic, had no real architectural merit.
In a telephone interview with Global Voices, writer Rhoda Bharath called it “convenient outrage”, saying, “It is a masquerade of us being civic-minded when we are really not.”
While experts and laypeople alike continue to debate the architectural and heritage merits of McBurnie's now-destroyed home, some good may yet come out of the episode.
Rubadiri Victor, President of the Artist Coalition of Trinidad and Tobago (ACTT), promised to launch “a major Heritage initiative that we hope will galvanise the public around the idea of preserving and honouring T&T’s incomparable heroic Legacy and creating an industry out of it that can employ many– from the roots to the branches.”
Whether the public will rally behind Victor's initiative remains to be seen.