Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

Egypt's jailed blogger Alaa Abdelfatah brings up second nationality for the first time as patience runs dry

The prominent blogger Alaa Abd El Fattah had spent the majority of the past decade behind bars. Image used under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.5 Generic license.

Alaa Abd El Fattah, Egypt's prominent blogger who began a hunger strike more than two weeks ago to protest his imprisonment, is demanding, for the first time following years, in prison that he be granted rights as both a British and Egyptian citizen.

Flagging his British nationality for the first time as his morale dropped and hope of release grew dimmer, Alaa's sister, Mona Seif, wrote in a Facebook post on Saturday, April 16:

His demands:

As an Egyptian citizen: to assign a judge to investigate the complaints he has already submitted, which document the violations he has been subjected to since the day he was abducted on September 29, 2019.

As a British citizen: for the British Consulate to be allowed to visit him in prison.
And to enable him to communicate with our lawyers in the U.K so that they can take all possible legal measures regarding not only the violations he has been subjected to, but all the crimes against humanity he has witnessed during his imprisonment.

Alaa, whose imprisonment by each of the country's recent rulers speaks at length of the country's long record of political oppression and injustice, began a hunger strike on April 2, to express rejection of his harsh prison conditions and the politically-driven sentences that robbed him of years spent with his son and family.

He has British citizenship through his mother, Laila Soueif, a mathematics professor at Cairo University who was born in London while her own mother was completing her PhD studies.

Alaa was an integral voice in the years preceding 2011's revolution that led to political shifts that eventually saw the ouster of long term president Hosni Mubarak in what could now be regarded as the only partial achievement of Egypt's Arab Spring. He refuses to succumb to a bogus trial by the emergency state security court that denied him the basic right to defend himself, sentencing him in December to two years in prison over charges of spreading false news. His two-year pretrial detention is not counted as part of the sentence.

The author of recently-published book “You Have Not Yet Been Defeated” is being held in solitary confinement, deprived of books and the right to exercise. Refusing to be defeated despite a previous five-year sentence which he had completed only months before he was taken in again to ultimately be served the current sentence, Alaa has had episodes in which his deteriorating  mental health has raised concerns after mentioning committing suicide to his lawyer during a visit.

According to a calculation by Mada Masr, an independent news website, Alaa has spent only 185 days out of prison since the Egyptian uprising took off on 25 January 2011.

The son of two distinguished human rights defenders, and the brother of two other brave activists, Alaa joined on the first day of Muslims’ holy month of fasting other detained liberal activists who started a hunger strike against the inhumane prison conditions they're locked up in.

Announcing the beginning of his hunger strike, Alaa's sister Mona wrote on Facebook on April 5:

مساء الخير

النهاردة في زيارة علاء Alaa Abd El Fattah عرفت منه انه دخل اضراب مفتوح عن الطعام من أول يوم رمضان، السبت 2 أبريل 2022
علاء بيفكر في القرار ده بقاله حبة لكنه حسم القرار وبدأ الاضراب رسمي
علاء غضبان جدا، بس النهاردة الغضب كان مختلف جدا عن الفترة السوداء اللي دخلناها من سبتمبر اللي فات. علاء غضبان بس مش واخد قرار طائش، هو واخد قرار فكر فيه وحاسبه ومقرر يخوض المعركة دي حتى لو احنا – أسرته- ماقدرناش نعمل حاجة تساعده فيها.
انطباعي ان المرة دي غير أي مرة أخذ قرار بالاضراب عن الطعام، يمكن المرة دي أقرب لوقت اضرابه بالتزامن مع تدهور ووفاة بابا.
اللي باحاول أقوله ان احساسي ان المرة دي مختلفة، علاء مش شايف جدوى تحمله الأوضاع البشعة اللي هو فيها، وحرمانه من مساحة امان يقدر يشوف فيها خالد، واختزال كل عقله وأفكاره ومشاعره وأحلامه وتحويله لجسد مقفول عليه في زنزانة مع اثنين زملاء ومطلوب منه يحافظ على سلامته الجسدية فقط لأجل غير معلوم.
أنا كنت رايحة وقلقانة ان علاء يبقى قرر فعلا يضرب عن الطعام خاصة مع أنباء موجة اضراب أصدقاءنا المعتقلين -ودومة بالأساس- في سجن المزرعة بطرة، وكنت محضرة أسباب لمحاولة اقناعه ب “الصبر” حبة وقت.
بس غير انه علاء بدأ الاضراب بالفعل خلاص، لكن الحقيقة ان اللي شوفته النهاردة خلاني أقر بأن قراره مفهوم جدا حتى لو مؤلم جدا جدا.
اللي شوفته بني ادم غضبان بس على حق قرر يخوض معركته بنفسه وبجسمه قدام سلطة بتحاول بكل الطرق الملتوية تقضي عليه. شوفت أخويا بينفض عنه الحالة اللي كانت مسيطرة عليها بقاله شهور وقرر يقاوم
وفي سجن شديد الحراسة 2، في زنزانة بلا تريض ولا كتب وبحكم 5 سنين من محكمة أمن دولة طوارئ مافيهوش نقض والمحكمة ما أقامتش حتى مراسم محاكمة ومرافعة، وكل ده بعد ما هو بالفعل قضى حكم 5 سنين سابق .. في وسط كل ده الطريقة الوحيدة المتاحة له للمقاومة هي دي: اضرابه عن الطعام بشكل كلي
واحنا أسرته وحبايبه مش بايدنا غير اننا نحاول بكل الطرق ندعمه في معركته، خاصة وانه على حق وصبر أكثر من سنتين قدام تخاذل مستمر من كل الجهات والمسؤولين.
علاء طلب مننا اجراءات وخطوات كتيرة بنراجعها مع المحامين وبننسقها مع بعض في العائلة وهنشارككم بكل التحديثات. وهنقدم بلاغات طبعا بخصوص اضرابه.
رجاءنا الوحيد انكم تساعدونا في وسط شهر قد كدة زحمة بالاجتماعيات والأنشطة، وكوكب قد كدة غرقان في كوارث وأخبار سياسية مختلفة .. تساعدونا نوصل صوت علاء وكل المعتقلين المضربين عن الطعام وما ننساهمش ولا نعتاد اللي هم فيه
*الصورة المرفقة عشان تفكرنا هو صبر على ايه وقد ايه

Good evening,
In today's visit to Alaa Abd El Fattah I learned from him that he began a hunger strike with the start of Ramadan, or April 2 2022. He's been thinking of this decision for a while but made up his mind and began the strike officially.
Alaa is very angry, but today's rage is very different from the dark period we entered in September. Alaa is angry but his decision is not reckless. He took a calculated decision and is determined to fight this battle even if we – his family – can't do anything to help him.
My impression is that this is different from any time he decided to go on hunger strike. This [time] is probably similar to when he staged a hunger strike when [our] dad's health deteriorated and passed away.
What I'm trying to say is that this time is different. Alaa sees no point in enduring the terrible conditions he's in, and being deprived of a safe space where he can see Khalid (his son), and reducing his mind, his thoughts, his feelings and dreams, and turning him into a body that is locked up in a cell with two others and is expected to preserve his physical wellness for an unknown period of time.
I went to the visit worried that Alaa decided the hunger strike especially amidst reports that a number of our imprisoned friends – especially [Ahmed] Douma – have begun hunger strikes in Tora Farm Prisons, and I had prepared a list of reasons to use to convince him to be a “bit more” patient.
However, aside from the fact that he began the hunger strike indeed, what I saw today got me convinced that his decision is very understandable even if very very painful.
What I saw is a rightfully angry human being who decided to fight his battle himself and with his body, in the face of an authority that is using all twisted means to terminate him. I saw my brother shake off the state he was in for months and decided to resist.
In high-security prison 2, in a cell without exercising or books, and with a 5-year verdict from the Emergency State Security Court, with no appeal, and the court did not even hold a trial and pleading ceremony, and all this after him already serving a previous 5-year sentence..
In the midst of all this, the only available way for him to resist is this: complete and full hunger strike
We, his family and his loved ones, can do nothing but try in every way to support him in his battle, especially since he is right and has been patient for more than two years in the face of being constantly let down by all sides and officials. Alaa requested us to pursue many procedures and steps that we review with lawyers and coordinate with each other in the family, and we will share with you all the updates. Of course, we will provide updates about his strike.
What we ask of you is, in the middle of a month, and amidst so many social events and activities, and a planet that is so mired in disasters and various political news, to help us convey the voice of Alaa and all the detainees on hunger strike so not to forget them or get desensitized to what they are in.

Start the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site