Australian government ‘mute’ on more ambitious plan to address climate crisis · Global Voices
Kevin Rennie

School climate rally Brisbane March 2019 – Photo courtesy Flickr user School Strike 4 Climate Attribution 2.0 Generic (CC BY 2.0)
The Australian government continues to face mounting pressure, both locally and internationally, after its disappointing stance on tackling climate change at U.S. President Joe Biden’s Leaders Summit on Climate on 22 April, with Sydney failing to increase its modest target of 26-28 percent below 2005 levels by 2030, under the 2016 Paris agreement.
The Australian non-government Climate Council was among the first to condemn Prime Minister Scott Morrison’s contribution to the summit:
…Australia stands on its own as being particularly out of step.
Alone among more than a hundred nations, Australia has no target for reaching net zero emissions.
This was no surprise for many Australians. A few days before the online meeting, Morrison attacked those wanting stronger action. He was clearly aiming his remarks at so-called ‘greenies’, a grossly simplified image of Australians in urban areas who have environmental concerns, in contrast to members of rural and mining communities. His remarks were seen to be intentionally divisive, and fired up his critics on social media:
Morrison takes aim at inner city ‘cafes, dinner parties and wine bars’ in climate change co… Stop trying to divide and rule @ScottMorrisonMP . We are all in this together . We need to look after all workers and all future generations https://t.co/Yj5YDhTPJN
— ?Sally Lawry (@SallyLawry) April 20, 2021
“We’re not going to achieve net zero in the cafes, dinner parties & wine bars of our inner cities” Morrison said at a formal dinner with wine at an inner city hotel ??‍♂️
We're not going to fix it with spin, no targets, vague technology promises & no plan!https://t.co/2yqxIbxEDQ
— Mike Cannon-Brookes ??‍?? (@mcannonbrookes) April 20, 2021
The Biden administration and other nations have made it clear that countries such as Australia will be held to account for inaction.
Morrison’s summit presentation had an unfortunate start as his microphone was on mute. Many commentators saw this glitch as fitting. At The Conversation, environmental academics, Lesley Hughes Professor and Will Steffen, found his contribution very ‘depressing’:
…sadly for Australians, the summit revealed the clear contrast in climate policy leadership between Morrison and his international peers.
Australian economics professor John Quiggin also took up this theme:
In place of the approaches adopted elsewhere, the Morrison government is betting heavily on alternatives that have failed previous tests, such as carbon capture and storage. And it’s blatantly ignoring internationally proven technology, such as electric vehicles.
The government could have followed the lead of our international peers and backed Australia’s clean energy sector to create jobs and stimulate the post-pandemic economy. Instead, it’s sending the nation on a fool’s errand.
Morrison’s speech was mocked by many on social media. Marque Lawyers tweeted:
Not sure what this is but it’s magnificent. pic.twitter.com/Z7apJwg75F
— marquelawyers (@marquelawyers) April 23, 2021
Climate change policy has been politically controversial since the mid-2000s. Many observers believe that even the current goal is unlikely to be met without further action. Climate Action Tracker is among them:
According to our analysis, Australia will need to implement additional policies to reach its 2030 target, even with the expected emissions reductions resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic.
Any hopes of more expenditure were dashed in the latest Morrison government Federal budget announced on 11 May 2021. There was little extra funding for renewable energy or electric vehicles, or general environmental programs. It contained few green programs to aid economic recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic.
The government is committed to a gas-fired recovery and handouts to fossil fuel emitters. In fact, funding for a new gas-fired plant has been announced just a day after the International Energy Agency recommended that there be no new investment in coal or gas projects.
Australian superannuation funds have called on the business community and consumers to push for stronger action:
Australian super funds to vote against company directors not tackling climate crisis [There is great power in advocacy – this can be done with votes at the ballot box, with votes at board & shareholder meetings – and every day via the products we purchase] https://t.co/il5viPd9hT
— kimchandlermcdonald (@kimchandler) April 26, 2021
Prominent finance commentator Alan Kohler found villains apart from the Prime Minister:
It’s not entirely Scott Morrison’s fault that he managed to look like a dissembling idiot at President Joe Biden’s leader’s summit on climate change last week.
…Those people who actually know what’s going on have allowed themselves to be intimidated by Rupert and Lachlan Murdoch and their bullies, who in turn have been collaborators in the crime of the century.
That the fossil fuel industry managed to turn global warming into a political issue – Left saying it’s happening, Right saying it’s not – might have been tactically brilliant, but it was also a vast global crime.
Some of the youth of Australia are not prepared to remain silent and are taking direct action. The Australian Youth Climate Coalition AYCC sent a clear message outside parliament house on budget night:
Tonight we sent a clear message for our Government to #FundOurFutureNotGas by investing in climate solutions & our communities. But @JoshFrydenberg & @ScottMorrisonMP have put their fossil fuel mates first #auspol #Budget2021 pic.twitter.com/kSYZRwNRSH
— AYCC (@AYCC) May 11, 2021
School student activists School Strike 4 Climate (SS4C) are at the forefront of action by young people. They have organised a day of protest across the nation for Friday 21 May 2021:
Together we are powerful. See you on #May21. pic.twitter.com/oSTAbv9ml2
— School Strike 4 Climate Australia (@StrikeClimate) May 16, 2021
There are many other voices in the ongoing campaign to bring about a change in government policy. Public policy think tank, the Australia Institute, held a webinar, which included Nigel Topping, UN High Level Climate Action Champion:
Australia stands *alone* in not having a significant climate plan
- UN High Level Climate Action Champion from UK @topnigel on @TheAusInstitute webinar yesterday
Quick read below in @GuardianAus
Watch full webinar here https://t.co/e6jy29WPuO#auspol https://t.co/8eL0TsKe9g
— Richie Merzian (@RichieMerzian) May 14, 2021
Many people hope that the government will take more ambitious targets to the November 2021 United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP26) in Glasgow. U.K. Prime Minster Boris Johnson is one of them:
Boris Johnson and Scott Morrison have spoken on the phone.
Here’s the Downing Street version of the conversation… #auspol @7NewsAustralia pic.twitter.com/rbjPhAQGZD
— Hugh Whitfeld (@hughwhitfeld) May 14, 2021
The message couldn't be clearer:
‘The Prime Minister emphasised the importance of all countries setting ambitious targets to cut carbon emissions, and encouraged Australia to commit to reaching Net Zero by 2050 which will deliver clean jobs and economic growth.’