Japan's Removal from South Korea's Winter Olympics Map Revives Old Disputes Between the Two Neighbors
A television image taken from the PyeongChang Organizing Committee website. Caption (top-right): “Why was Japan omitted from a map on the official PyeongChang 2018 Olympic website? Japanese government protests.” Screencap from ANN official YouTube channel.
The omission of Japan from a map on the official web page of the upcoming 2018 Winter Olympics in PyeongChang, South Korea has provoked outrage in Japan, and exposed deep resentment against its neighbor.
On Wednesday, September 27, 2017, the Japan Sports Agency, which supports Japan's Olympic athlete program, reportedly noticed a map uploaded by the PyeongChang 2018 Winter Olympics organizing committee had omitted the Japanese archipelago. It already lodged a complaint via the South Korean Embassy in Tokyo, according to the Associated Press.
Since the February 2018 Winter Olympics will be held in neighboring South Korea, Japan's omission from the map was quite noticeable.
While the Pyeongchang organizing committee reportedly explained the omission of Japan on the map was a “simple mistake” caused by changes in image files when organizers updated the Olympic website in February, the gaffe went viral in Japan, resulting in television coverage and a hashtag on Twitter, #PyeongChang2018HomePage (‘#平昌五輪HP’).
There was also a highly visible protest by the Japanese Cabinet itself which officially rebuked the PyeongChang Olympic organizing committee.
菅義偉官房長官「極めて不適切だ」 #平昌五輪 ＨＰで日本列島ない世界地図掲載 #平昌五輪HPhttps://t.co/JJSH6TgB4p pic.twitter.com/PM7mpXZuDu
— 産経ニュース (@Sankei_news) September 27, 2017
Suga Yoshihide, Chief Cabinet Secretary in the Japanese government: omission “extremely inappropriate.” Official
#PyeongChang2018 home page publishes map that omits Japan. #PyeongChang2018HomePage.
While the map was quickly fixed, it did not stop online resentments from seething on social media. Manuronald, a member of the online blogging site Naver Matome, collected some of the tweets in a post that has been viewed nearly 250,000 times. Most of the comments Manuronald collected expressed deep cynicism on whether the omission of Japan was merely a simple mistake.
平昌五輪のサイトの世界地図に日本がないって言うから見たらさらっと修正されてて草 pic.twitter.com/q3rTEN71lf
— すぺーす@noesis勢 (@wisdomandtalent) September 27, 2017
After people noticed Japan wasn't on the map on the PyeongChang Olympic website they fixed it, lolololol
Other tweets suggested that Japan simply refrain from participating in the Winter Games in February 2018.
一生懸命に練習をしてきた選手には本当に申し訳ないけど、こうなると公平なジャッジは期待できないし、日本の選手を侮辱すらするようなことが容易に想像できるので、日本は不参加が良いと思う。#平昌五輪#平昌五輪HP#平昌オリンピック#韓国 https://t.co/YKjRqY9QDd
— ハデス (@hades_Ichiro) September 27, 2017
While it would be totally unfair to the athletes who have trained so hard (for the Olympics), if this sort of thing happens it's unlikely the judges are going to be impartial. It's pretty easy to imagine ways in which Japanese athletes could be slighted (at the Games), so I think it would be better if Japan just do not participate.
One Twitter user suggested that the ongoing tensions on the Korean Peninsula as the North Korean regime tests ballistic missiles and nuclear devices may end up affecting the games anyway.
戦争が起きたり人が死ぬことは全く望まないが、北朝鮮軍の越境などで平昌五輪が中止になったらいいのに、と思う。五輪に備えて頑張ってきた選手のために翌年に別の国で「ポスト五輪」特別に開催したらいい。僕は韓国人は嫌いじゃないが国家としての韓国・北朝鮮は大嫌い。
— ピクシー (日本人でよかった) (@pixie10ole) September 27, 2017
While I don't want to see a war and don't want to see people die, maybe the North Korean military, which is located just across the border, will “pause” those games. Maybe they could reschedule the games another year for a post-Olympics, to give the athletes a chance. I don't hate Koreans, but I detest the South and North Korean governments.
The omission of Japan from the map also refocused the attention of the Japanese Internet on two long-simmering disputes between Japan and South Korea, the naming and ownership of what Japan calls the Takeshima Islands and what South Korea calls Dokdo, located in the waters between Japan and South Korea.
There is also another ongoing dispute between Japan and South Korea over what the body of water commonly referred to as the Sea of Japan should be named. South Korea insists it should be called the ‘East Sea.’
The PyeongChang organizing committee website also wades into these contested waters. As Livedoor news reported,
競技場を説明するページの地図に、島根県の竹島を「DOKDO」（独島）、日本海を「East Sea」（東海）と記載。
On one of the pages on the site, Takeshima in Shimane prefecture is called “DOKDO”, while the Sea of Japan is called the “East Sea.”
For now, with Japan re-added to the map, the controversy has died down, but some Japanese netizens continue to harbor resentment and often outright hatred towards South Korea.
