One week after Hurricane Matthew devastated Haiti, many on social media are suggesting it's time for France to repay its debt to the country.
The Category-4 hurricane struck parts of the Caribbean nation on October 4, 2016, causing Haiti's largest humanitarian crisis since the 2010 earthquake. The directorate of Civil Protection of Haiti have confirmed 473 deaths, 339 injuries and 75 people missing, while many international media reports have put the death toll at more than 1,000 people. A further 1.4 million people are in need of assistance and some bloggers have been sharing links for “organisations that are quietly doing good work in Haiti that does not line the pockets of multinational aid corporations, or continue to fatten the Port au Prince elite.”
In the wake of the disaster, the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs has launched a flash appeal to raise US$119.8 million in emergency funding.
But the impact of the hurricane is also leading many people to ask whether France should provide financial assistance by finally repaying its colonial reparations to Haiti.
As Facebook user Mandy Dalton put it:
The Hurricane and the Earthquake were not the worst disasters to happen to Haiti. The worst disaster was manmade. Haiti is still dealing with the aftermath of a debt that it should have never had to pay.
Leondra Saintil added:
Hurricane hitting Haiti is heartbreaking. You know what would help? France paying the 21 billion $ it owes in reparations. Hmmmmm.
While Haiti is now known as the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere, it was once the most profitable possession of the French Empire. Saint Domingue, as it was then known, traded extensively in coffee, cotton and sugar, among other exports.
Haiti declared independence in 1804, after leading a successful anti-slavery and anti-colonial insurrection, and becoming the first country in modern times to officially abolish slavery. But it paid a heavy price for its freedom — 150 million gold francs, later reduced to 90 million gold francs — to compensate French settlers and slave-owners for their lost plantations.
This was a tremendous sum, and it crippled the country. In fact, it took until 1947 for Haiti to finish paying it off. In 2003, former Haitian president Jean-Bertrand Aristide estimated that the “independence debt”, as it has come to be known, was worth a modern equivalent of about US$21 billion, including interest. Other people have put the figure closer to US$17 billion. In fact, after the devastating hurricane in 2010, 100 artists and scholars signed a petition to try to force France to repay this amount “as reparations for a 200-year-old injustice.” At the time, France dismissed it.
Then in May 2015, the issue again drew international attention after French President Francois Hollande told an audience on the French island of Guadeloupe, “When I go to Haiti, I will, for my part, handle the debt that we have.” His aides later insisted he was referring to the moral debt, rather than a financial obligation. In his subsequent visit to Haiti, Hollande tried to side-step the issue by telling the country, “You’re not asking for aid, you want development.”
This exchange led to an outpouring of articles calling on France to finally compensate Haiti by paying back what it owed.
Since last week's hurricane, many netizens have been re-posting articles from that time, with many saying now is the time to revisit the issue.
Facebook user Sol DjVaselli Duverne put it even more simply, captioning his post with a simple “PAY UP.”
Haiti has been independent for a long time. By now whatever social or economic problems of Haiti are the making of her own government. People like Papa Doc did Haiti a disservice. To demand reparations from France for issues that date to the 19th century is ridiculous.
How about holding the Politicians responsible for a shabby infrastructure that caused the death of so many people? Storms and earthquakes by themselves do not kill, but the bad infrastructure does
That is why the Loma Prieta Earthquake of 1989 killed 63 people while the Earthquakes in Nepal killed over 8 thousand people. This “blame game” does nobody any good, not the Haitians or the French, mismanagement, corruption, ineptitude are tolerated in Haiti by Haitians of Haitians. But the Gall to ask reparations from France while they ignore the wanton corruption at home is racist at best.
“Haiti has been independent for a long time” you really need a history lesson, suggest
you go to a library
I made sure to Google the independence of Haiti before I made my comment. I suggest you do the same.
France certainly does have a historical responsibility to help Haiti as much as it possibly can. Haiti has been hit, time and time again, by extreme weather events, and the level of misery and despair is beyond the pale. As a former French colony, Haiti deserves to be helped as much as is possible. France has a historical opportunity to stand for basic human rights in a former colony and thus demonstrate beyond the shadow of a doubt that “freedom, fraternity and solidarity” are meaningful concepts. Maybe not to the tune of $17 billion, but yes long -term commitment to democracy and human rights in a country that deserves better.