A recent English-language article in UK newspaper the Guardian about Japan has been shared hundreds of times on Japanese social media.
Many Japanese commenters are shocked that, according to the Guardian, Japan is planning to accept few, if any, Syrian refugees.
「日本はISISとの戦いに二億ドル出すと言ってたのにシリア難民を助ける気はない模様」/Japan takes no Syrian refugees yet despite giving $200m to help fight Isis http://t.co/uXEp1qrdtd
— フジヤマガイチ (@gaitifujiyama) septiembre 9, 2015
The typical reaction of Japanese Twitter users was one of shame:
@gaitifujiyama @levinassien 恥ずかしい。
— Tamoto (@mtktmng) September 10, 2015
I am embarrassed.
While other Twitter users argued that Japan has an obligation to help refugees:
@gaitifujiyama @levinassien 難民受入が少ない日本。遠いからと逃げ口上は言えないです。受け入れ許可率も少なすぎます。安保関連法案と繋がる問題として捉えたいですが、法案反対に国民のエネルギーが集中し、申し訳ない。立憲主義・民主主義は、難民も除外しないはず。
— basetsu (@basetsu) September 10, 2015
Japan, the country that accepts very few refugees. Japan evades responsibility by saying the problem is [in a far-off country], but we accept far too few refugees. While it's tempting say Japan has been preoccupied by the Legislation for Peace and Security, and that everyone has focused their energies on opposing these new unconstitutional laws, it's really no excuse at all.
Anyone who supports parliamentary democracy based on a constitution should never ignore the plight of refugees.
Taking to Twitter, entertainer Ryuchi Sato observed:
国外に出たシリア難民400万人超。欧州に着いたのは34万人。受け入れ表明は、ドイツが年間50万人まで対応、フランス2.4万、イギリス2万(今後5年)、アメリカ1万(来年)、オーストラリア1.2万、ベネズエラ2万、ブラジル、アルゼンチン、ウルグアイなども。日本はこれまでに3人。
— 佐藤龍一 (@RyuichiSato) September 10, 2015
More than 4 million Syrians have left their country. About 340,000 have reached Europe. Germany has promised to accept 500,000 refugees; France, 24,000; the UK, 20,000 (over five years); the United States, 10,000 (over the next year); Australia, 12,000; Venezuela, 20,000; Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay and others have also agreed to accept refugees.
How many refugees has Japan accepted so far? A grand total of three.
Traditionally, Japan has accepted very few refugees compared to other member countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. In March 2015, The Economist magazine had already noted:
Last year [2014], the number of refugees, asylum-seekers and internally displaced people topped 50m worldwide for the first time. In Japan there were more asylum applications than at any time since the country signed the UN refugee convention in 1981.
According to the more recent Guardian article currently being circulated on Japanese social media, in 2014 Japan accepted just 11 asylum seekers out of 5,000 applicants.
As well, according to the Guardian article:
Of 60 Syrians already living in Japan who had applied for refugee status, three had been successful and another 30 or so had been given permission to stay long-term for humanitarian reasons.
Hiroaki Ishii, the executive director of the Japan Association for Refugees, was quoted in a Mainichi newspaper interview as calling Japan a “closed country” for refugees:
難民受け入れ:日本は「鎖国」-毎日 http://t.co/gJYTg4wolR 難民支援協会の石井宏明常任理事「これまでのような資金援助だけでは日本は『難民に冷たい国』との印象がさらに強まるだろう。人道目的として受け入れ要件を緩和するような政治決断が求められる」 — 和田浩明/Hiroaki Wada (@spearsden) September 10, 2015
Hirokaki Ishii, executive director of the Japan Association for Refugees says, “Given the financial support to date for refugees one would have to say that Japan is indifferent to refugees. We're calling on the Japanese government to soften its position on humanitarian grounds.”
Others noted how the issue is being portrayed as a faraway problem. Nobuto Nosaka, who, as mayor of Tokyo's Setagaya Ward has his finger on the pulse of what regular people actually think, pointed to that characterization in a tweet linking to a column he authored for Huffington Post Japan:
シリア難民、日本にも申請中だが政府は… http://t.co/mNZu3IonYI 日本では「欧州の難民問題」のように報じられることが多いが、果たして実状はどうなのだろう。この人道の危機にあって、日本および日本人は、対岸の火事ですませてしまってよいのか。 — 保坂展人 (@hosakanobuto) September 8, 2015
Even as Syrians are applying for refuge here, in Japan the issue is being called the “European refugee crisis.” This humanitarian crisis is being treated as someone else's problem.
In another article for the HuffPo, Nosaka argued that Japan must respond in meaningful way to the “calamity” occurring in Syria.
He also noted that Japan's stance on accepting (or, more precisely, refusing) refugees dates back at least to the era of the Vietnam “boat people” of the late 1970s. At that time, according to Nosaka, Japan contributed funding and expertise to help build camps in Indonesia for refugees fleeing Vietnam, and also provided resources for retraining and resettlement in other countries.
However, then as now, Japan was a “closed country” for refugees.
14 comments
WE are not going to cooperate with an American war that will make more refugees.
That is what we should take care of first.
That is our help for war refugees now and ever.
USA is the one who should deal with the mess she created.
American people, you are also someone who should pay for what you do, learn lesson sometimes, there’s NO EXCEPTIONALISM that works.
Look at this photo, we Japanese are not going to join a war with you.
This is a human lettering held in Hiroshima.
There’s NO CHANCE for you to drag us into a WAR AGAIN.
Stop forcing us to have a war!
We are not your SERVANT!
Thanks for the comment. I’m from Canada, not the US.
I call on especially American people because it is THEM who can stop what Washington forces us to do AGAINST our will.
But you are not exception as you are CANADIAN, you are someone who’s also responsible of OUR PLIGHT.
We are not going to join a war with America, while you can do what you can do to help us, because unlike how we are, you are SOMEONE who’s not treated like ANIMAL by Washington.
Being Canadian is not enough for your excuse for what USA is doing on us Japanese.
USA is treating us Japanese local LIKE ANIMALS, this is NOT ACCEPTABLE.
You can’t imagine how it is like, to be treated like ANIMAL.
We are HUMAN BEINGS too.
When was the time that USA flied Osprey over your houses?
I doubt if they did.
When was the time that USA spread Agent Orange over your blue soil?
I doubt if they did, while they did on Okinawa.
When was the time that US troops raped 12 years old local girl on your blue soil?
I doubt if they did.
When was the time that US base captured your local people with no legal basis for protesting against US base?
I doubt if they did.
When was the time that US officers sweared at local people protesting against US base?
I doubt if they did, while they always do it toward Okinawans.
This is how they treat us like.
NOT ACCEPTABLE anymore.
You’re just a Japanese so nobody will listen to you.
Nevin, I flagged some post that is obviously offensive, I hope you are going to do the right thing for it.
I will take it as your bias when you do nothing about it.
The commenter here is using their real name. Anyone who is reading their comments can judge for themselves about the nature of the comments, and the commenter.
I don’t understand what you mean.
I am no English speaker.
To begin with, how do we know if “the name” is real?
Or this poster is Japanese?
Nevin, I’m no English speaker but I’m no that fool.
There’s no chance that this poster is a real local Japanese.
Because no real local Japanese sees me “right winger”.
This poster is not someone local Japanese, most likely “you”.
And we usually get in touch in our language with each other, if we need to do so, not by some foreign language.
I read the former comments of this poster, maybe “he or she” used to be an expat in Japan, but too odd to be local Japanese.
Nevin you don’t need to do this for kicking me out, while what you need to do is just to ban me, or delete my comment, why do you do this?
Canadian, odd people, beyond my comprehension. Odd.
Michiko, you understand nothing. You are a brainwashed Japanese. Maybe you are not “Uyoku” right-wing, but you are definitely a ultra-nationalist Japanese bigot who is not able to take part in an adult discussion (because your school-system is militaristic and you did not learn the skills to think for yourself).
You need to live outside of Japan and try to understand that you have been brainwashed by your Japanese education and media.
Japan has no friends in the world if it repeatedly elects dangerous people like Abe or Ishihara. Nobody wants to play with such dirty people.
Japan needs to have a revolution like France in the 18th century. You must destroy all the evil families that rule your country and start to create a true society which is not dangerous to your neighbours.
And you must create an education system that does not produce nationalist robots like you but people who can think like adults and elect the people who will be able to make Japan a respected country on the world stage.
Japan will always be a ridiculous country if you do not stop your pride.
TomokoHasegawa, I’m not sure what you’re trying to accomplish here, but your comments are not constructive and are abusive. Similar comments will be removed in the future.
用があるならツイッターに来な。
@Michiko70554148
フォローのうえ、DMで、サシで話そうじゃんか。
なんか問題ある?
あのさ、普通は日本人どうしで外国語で話なんかしないよね。
しないよね。
あんたって、変だよねえ。
You’re just a typical right-wing Japanese idiot.
After reading a series of Michiko’s hateful writings on sisqus political blog, I google his twitter account. I see more of the same. The person is stuck on a single thought apparently.
That was “Disqus”, not “Sisqus”