Chinese Authorities Leap to Discredit Detained Citizens’ Rights Activist · Global Voices
Oiwan Lam

Crop from political cartoonist @badiucao's drawing. See full image in text.
Famous citizens’ right activist Wu Gan was arrested on May 19 for protesting outside a court in Jianxi province, where lawyers had gathered to demand documents from an old case that they wished to reopen. On May 27, Wu was transferred to Fujian for criminal detention and charged with “picking quarrels and provoking troubles” as well as defamation.
His arrest and detention — and subsequent state media coverage smearing Wu's character — have sparked fears of a coming crackdown on citizens’ rights activists in China.
Despite having no strong ties to specific citizens’ groups or online platforms, Wu has become a well-known figure in human rights circles in China since 2009. The 42-year-old goes by the nickname “Butcher”. Speaking with the New York Times’ Sinosphere blog, Wu's lawyer, Ge Wenxiu, explained that the name is intended to mock state officials’ use of vulgarity with a sarcastic suggestion that he wants to “slay” for them their corruption and misconduct.
Over the past few days, state-controlled media have covered Wu's arrest with ample bias against his case. On May 25, China Central Television (CCTV) used footage from a security camera outside of Jiangxi People's High Court as evidence of Wu's disorderly conduct. Three days later, communist party newspaper People's Daily depicted Wu as an irresponsible divorcee, troublemaker and scammer whose father and brother were also criminals. The report quoted an anonymous acquaintance of Wu, alleging that his social activism was motivated by personal interest.
Wu was part of the first group of netizens to contest the controversial police investigation of Deng Yujiao, a waitress who stabbed and killed a government official after he attempted to force her to have sex with him. Wu even traveled from Beijing to Hubei to visit Deng and persuade her family to seek help from Beijing lawyers to file an appeal. Eventually, Deng was convicted of “excessive self-defense” but exempt from criminal punishment due to her psychological status. The case was considered a huge success for online activism in China.
Since then, Wu has continued to help ordinary people defend their rights. Recently, he became involved in the case of  the fatal shooting by police of a man at Qing'an train station. He formed a citizen investigation team and demanded that railway police release station surveillance camera footage to the public.
As Wu Gan has helped many petitioning for their rights to be upheld, a number of people spoke out in support of him on different social media platforms. Given that Chinese Twitter-like Weibo is heavily censored, some published their messages on Twitter. Badiucao, a political cartoonist, expressed his support with his drawing:
#巴丢草 漫画 【央视上的屠夫】屠夫@tufuwugan 前脚捅了 #安庆 枪击的马蜂窝，后脚就被党妈惦记上，抓了不算还上 #央视 视频游街。超级低俗的假屠夫叫伟大光荣的真屠夫给拿下了，中国梦何止荒唐？！作图声援屠夫先生！ pic.twitter.com/AxZAVgwZRF
— 巴丢草 (@badiucao) May 25, 2015
Comic on “Butcher on CCTV”: Butcher has one foot stepping into #Qing'an shooting incident, with the Party immediately grabbing his other foot: it not only arrested him, but displayed him on TV. “Super vulgar butcher” [Wu Gan's social media screen name] is butchered by the glorious butcher. The China dream is more than ridiculous. This drawing is to express my support for Mr. Butcher.
Many users were outraged by the media's distortion of Wu's private life. Liushui argued that news outlets’ smears were part of a coordinated propaganda effort:
我是第一次看到，当局动用央视、新华社和人民日报等国家力量，编造事实，围剿一个草根维权者“屠夫吴淦”。当年刘晓波似乎也没享受此等待遇。专制国家常用“媒体审判”滥招，替代哪怕是自己制定的法律，颠倒黑白，抹黑正义。民间正当维权行为，是推动社会进步的力量之一，像吴淦维权者越多越好。
— 刘水 (@liushui1989) May 28, 2015
This is the first time I see the authorities making use of various state powers including CCTV, Xinhua and China Daily [these three media outlets are under the control of different authorities: the communist party, the government and propaganda officials] to fabricate a story to attack grassroots rights activist “Butcher Wu Gan”. Even [political prisoner] Liu Xiaobo did not enjoy this kind of treatment back then. Authoritarian states often use the media to punish people in ways that the law may not. They turn white into black and blacken justice. Civil rights action is a means to improve society. We should have more people like Wu Gan.
Wen Yunchao, a Chinese dissident based in the US, believed that national security authorities were involved:
屠夫被刑拘，新华社、人民日报、中央电视台都第一时间作出报道；江西方面行政拘留期未满转由福建方面进行刑事拘留。同时调动政法及党宣系统，基本可以认定是国安委决策部署，预感不妙。对屠夫的这种运动式精确打击，旨在震慑并瓦解民间维权死嗑群体，其大批判式文宣与反恐式定点清除手法，令人发指。
— 北风（温云超, Yunchao Wen） (@wenyunchao) May 28, 2015
Judging from Butcher's criminal detention, the quick and coordinated report from Xinhua, People's Daily and CCTV, and the cross-provincial coordination between Jiangxi province and Fujian province in handing over Wu Gan for criminal detention, only the State Security Committee can mobilize both the judicial and propaganda authorities at the same time. Something fishy is definitely going on here. Such a crackdown aims to terrify and dissolve the hardcore citizens’ rights activists. The propaganda finger-pointing at an individual with an attempt to eliminate the target is similar to the anti-terrorist [snipers], [such crackdown] is outraging.
Twitter user Beidaijin believed that this latest clampdown would not end with a single case:
黨國能祭出這三大法器 絕對不會僅僅為了屠夫一人，這麼大的鋪墊，預計將有可觀的「後戲」。屠爺是相關「運動」的一部份/一個標籤、引子，接下來或將出現連續的針對性打擊，全國範圍的 “@xddcc: 党国急眼儿了~ RT @avb001:
— 贝带劲 (@beidaijin) May 28, 2015
The fact that the party-state has mobilized the three media organs means that their target is not restricted to Butcher. It is just the opening scene and more spectacles will follow. Butcher is a part / a symbol of the kind of “movement” [that the authorities want to crack down on], he serves as a prelude and there will be more targets singled out.
Some users defended Wu's integrity:
新华社极尽丑化之力抹黑屠夫，无非就是想打压死磕式维权。他们把维护公民基本权利称做“凑热闹”，给他们添麻烦。没错，屠夫就是爱凑热闹，09到现在陆续见过他几次，每次都是他维权的时候 。他太爱管闲事了，前几天还在仔细问我陈云飞家人的情况，他不仅要捐款，还想把陈云飞家的老人也照顾到。
— 上官乱 (@shangguanluan) May 28, 2015
Xinhua tried so hard to smear Butcher in order to crack down on the hardcore rights defenders. They described the civil rights defenders as a “crowd” who cause trouble. Well, Butcher likes to follow the hot issues. I have met him several times since 2009. Every time he was involved in a civil rights action. He is very nosy. He asked me about the situation of Chen Yunfei's family [Chen was arrested in early May under the charge of “inciting subversion” and “provoking troubles”]. He wanted to donate and help out his family.
如今坏人当道，好人只能进监狱。我是新浪微博早期的用户，如今已经不玩了。从屠夫为受难者仗义执言，一直到他退出新浪为徐纯合的事奔走，再到这次被抓。他一路的历程，作为旁观者我看得清清楚楚。老吴就是一个义薄云天的爷们儿，一颗响当当的铜豌豆！ https://t.co/mqXwCR5G1t
— 小悲 (@Zodiac4698) May 28, 2015
Now wicked people have taken control and good people are in jail. I used to be an early Weibo user and have abandoned the platform. Butcher has been speaking out for the victims. He was kicked off Sina Weibo because of Xu Chunhe [the victim of the Qing'an police shooting]. Now he is arrested. I witnessed what he has done in the past few years. Wu is such a righteous guy who has a strong will and can make loud voice!