Kremlin Has Mastered Propaganda, But Not Photoshop: Fake MH17 Photo Lights Up RuNet
Whoever is behind the ‘satellite photo’, their Photoshop skills leave much to be desired. Images mixed by Tetyana Lokot.
A purportedly new satellite image presenting unbeatable ‘proof’ of Ukraine’s fault in the Malaysia Airlines MH17 plane crash has garnered ridicule on the RuNet.
Mikhail Leontyev, editor and host of “Odnako” (However) evening show on Kremlin-owned Channel One TV, dropped the bombshell: an American whistleblower had come forward with a ‘satellite’ image of a ‘Ukrainian fighter jet’ shooting down MH17. The host of Odnako went on to show a letter, allegedly from an MIT aviation expert with 20 years of experience, named George A. Bilt, who purportedly agreed with the Russian government that a Ukrainian fighter jet—not a Buk missile controlled by pro-Russian separatists—had shot down MH17. The photo was presented as proof. The image is not grainy, distorted, or in any way ambiguous—it’s crystal clear, in fact.
The image Russian state TV claims is proof that MH17 was shot down by a Ukrainian fighter jet. Screenshot from 1tv.ru.
The photo shows MH17 a bit north of Donetsk being fired upon by a ‘fighter jet,’ presumably Ukraine’s, with a missile en route. A number of pro-Kremlin bloggers and Russian news outlets immediately shared this news as a smoking gun, claiming that what most in the West had dismissed as a conspiracy was now indisputable. However, as many on the RuNet immediately noticed, this image was just too good to be true.
Russian Twitter user Abu quickly noticed an inconsistency in the source of Mikhail Leontyev’s find, tracing the satellite photo to an older post on a web forum in October:
этому снимку уже месяц – http://t.co/vHn76yANY2 pic.twitter.com/q9sbTnxheH
— Abu (@abunyasha) November 14, 2014
This photo is a month old.
ну и последнее, короч. на снимке Донецк, а связь с самолетом пропала в районе Снежного. и логотип малайзийской авиакомпании не в том месте.
— Abu (@abunyasha) November 14, 2014
Oh, and one last thing. The photo is of Donetsk, and the communication with the plane was lost near Snezhnoye. And the Malaysian airline logo is in the wrong place.
Popular blogger and Moscow municipal deputy Maxim Kats did a Google image search for “Boeing top view,” with the first result looking suspiciously familiar:
Интересно, изображение Боинга они прямо загуглили тоже? Или совпадение? Первая картинка в выдаче «Боинг вид сверху» pic.twitter.com/e5MyH07UWQ
— Максим Кац (@max_katz) November 14, 2014
Interesting, did they also Google a Boeing image like this? Or a coincidence? The first picture in the search results for “Boeing top view”
As detailed on Ilya Varlamov’s popular LiveJournal, a laundry list of other inconsistencies surfaces, the more one examines the photograph, including how the cloud and crop formations of the satellite photo exactly match a patchwork of Yandex and Google Map satellite images from 2012.
As soon as it became clear that this satellite image was not the smoking gun it was billed as, the RuNet decided to have some fun with the photo, sharing outrageous conspiracy theories and critiquing the Photoshop skills of whoever was behind the image.
#версия Боинг сбили фашиствующие инопланетяне… pic.twitter.com/4z25E7UBjb
— Reincarnation. (@TukvaSociopat) November 14, 2014
#version Fascist-minded aliens shot down the Boeing…
Наш фотограф крупным планом запечатлел момент, когда украинский истребитель сбивал малайзийский Боинг pic.twitter.com/5BLglmWMmR
— Lie News (@Lie_News) November 14, 2014
Our photographer captured a close-up of the moment when the Ukrainian fighter jet shot down the Malaysian Boeing.
ПРАВДЫ НЕ СКРЫТЬ! На снимке видно, что крылья истребителя, сбившего Боинг, раскрашены в цвета украинской вышиванки! pic.twitter.com/VfttMMu72i
— Дядюшка Шу (@Shulz) November 14, 2014
YOU CANNOT HIDE THE TRUTH! In the picture, it is apparent that the wings of the fighter jet, which shot down the Boeing, are painted in the colors of Ukrainian embroidery!
It seems most likely that the sudden resurfacing of the MH17 conspiracy theories and ‘incontrovertible proof’ of Ukraine's fault might be Kremlin's reaction to a series of stories on the MH17 crash by crowdsourcing investigative website bellingcat, released earlier this month. Alternatively, it might be a ploy to draw the world's and Russians’ attention from other events in Russia, such as the worsening economic crisis. We may never know who decided it was a good idea to headline a state-run television channel’s news show with a fabricated photograph, but it is certainly far from the first time that the Russian government has taken liberties with photographs or, for that matter, with journalistic objectivity.
This post is part of RuNet Echo, a Global Voices project to interpret the Russian language internet. All Posts · Read more »
92 comments
It was made for G20 summit @ Australia
I also think so, it’s a provocation as an Answer to Tony Abbot and with no respect for the australian victims of MH17. It shows the chilling cruelty of russia.
Wow…. the Ukrainians must be planting tiny fields these days. The wingspan of a MiG is only 11 meters. The fields on reality-based satellite images of Ukraine show the huge fields that Ukraine has had since collectivization…. they are often a kilometer or so across. They’re probably larger, on the average, than American quarter-sections, which are half a mile (800 m) on a side.
And if you take a close look at the “747”, there’s a whole VILLAGE between the front and back wings.
Strange looking 747. Short engines & upper deck.
My mistake. The Malaysian plane is a 777.
Happens. 777 flying most routes previously dominated by 747.
Poor inept PhotoShoppers seemed to have little idea of how things would look from aloft. Planes could look bigger than fields if viewed from above at somewhat lower than orbital altitude, but that defeats the allegation of satellite view. Perhaps the interns were given a project . . .
Panteleimonivka isn’t a village, it’s an “urban-type settlement”. It has nearly 8,000 residents.
http://uk.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9F%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%82%D0%B5%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%B9%D0%BC%D0%BE%D0%BD%D1%96%D0%B2%D0%BA%D0%B0_(%D1%81%D0%BC%D1%82)
Why would Putler give missiles to Russian-Volunteers-On-Holiday in Ukraine in the first place? The rebels are not a professional army and mistakes were bound to be made. Russians are not evil. I know they pray for the souls of the people that they killed on that plane.
The Germans were not too bad, but how many people have been killed and for their support of Hitler.
I’m not sure what your point is?
Люди Европы и мира сейчас на ваші інформаційні смі іде атака тролів коментариев с России, вони хочуть щоб ви вірили не своїм лідерам і Україні, а Росій і Путіну. В Україні зараз справжня інформаційна війна з Росіею, ми тримаемо оброною правдою проти пропаганди і обману. Не реагуйте на них і не вірте.
The people of Europe and the world NOW for your information goes mass media attack trolls komentaryev with Russia, they want you to believe their leaders and not Ukraine and Russia and Putin. In Ukraine is a real information war with Russia, we hold true Defence against propaganda and deception. Do not respond to them and do not believe.