Arrests Made in Man's Fatal Beating Have Not Renewed Faith in Jamaica's Police

Police presence in Jamaica; photo by Jason Lawrence, used under a CC BY 2.0 license.

Police presence in Jamaica. Photo by Jason Lawrence. CC BY 2.0

Three men have been charged in connection with the death of Mario Deane, a young man who was arrested for marijuana possession and was beaten while in police custody, touching off a round of criticism of the island nation's police.

The men were Deane's cellmates and are accused of beating him to death because of a dispute over sleeping accommodations. One of the men is hearing impaired, while another is, according to his family, schizophrenic. Six police officers have also been suspended, pending further investigations into the incident.

Police say they were alerted to a fight in the lock-up and found Deane with multiple injuries; they then took him to the hospital for treatment, but he later died. Deane's family has already signaled its intentions to file a wrongful death lawsuit against the police. 

The case has continued to fuel protests in the streets and online as well as discussions in Jamaica, which has a history of police brutality and other similar forms of violence.

Blogger Annie Paul mentioned, on Facebook, radio station Nationwide's report on reggae star Peter Tosh, who says he was beaten by police in 1972:

Brilliant. Nationwide plays excerpt of Peter Tosh's account of the vicious beating police gave him, showing history of police brutality here. Apparently Herbie Miller [Tosh's then-manager] sent them the clip…v useful to remember how far back police abuse has been going on…and how little anything has changed.

You can listen to the report and Tosh's account of the incident here.

Video-blogger QuitePerry also shared his thoughts in a video titled “I Am Mario Deane”:

Writer Kei Miller sought to provide fuller context to some of the incidents of police brutality that have taken place:

In the last 20 years in Jamaica, at least 200 people have been killed each year by police. This is not an average. 200 is the lowest number killed in any given year. In some years the figure is actually much higher than that.

To put this into another statistical context, let us consider the UK – a country with a population 23 times higher than Jamaica’s. The UK does not report police killings 23 times more than Jamaica’s. Over the last 20 years a total of 1433 people have died after having had some manner of contact with British police. That’s 71 a year. But in fact, only 55 of the 1433 have been police shootings. The others died while in police custody or sometimes as the result of a high speed chase. 2.5 people shot and killed each year by police in Britain. Stop to consider that for a while.

Dennis Chung at Caribbean Journal felt that the case was just another example of the police failing to take responsibility. Their “response was to first deny culpability and then charge two persons, with no apology. It took the ministers of Justice and National Security, the acting commissioner, some politicians, [the Independent Commission of Investigations], and civil society to express outrage and apologise. Still no one from Barnett Street, from what I know, has issued any statement of apology,” he wrote.

Chung added that there can be no meaningful economic development without social justice:

Whenever there is no social justice, it results in lost opportunities and wasted talent. It also results in wasted productive hours, as instead of cleaning up the mess caused by some functionaries of the state, we could be planning how to increase agricultural and other production. 

Many Twitter users felt that Mario Deane's death exposed the problems not only within the police force, but in Jamaican society as a whole:

The rise of social media has made incidents of police brutality harder to sweep under the rug, and there is pressure on the government to provide justice for Mario Deane and to reform the Jamaican constabulary.

Start the conversation

Authors, please log in »


  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.