See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Uzbekistan: ‘National’ Social Network Not Quite a Facebook Clone

Would you ever give up your Facebook account to switch to a “national” social networking platform? Well, this is what the authorities in Uzbekistan apparently hope the country's Internet users will choose to do. They are challenging the popularity of Facebook and the Russian-language social network Odnoklassniki [Classmates] in the country by promoting Youface, a new local platform.

Interestingly, this is not the first attempt of the sort. An Uzbek-language social network service, Muloqot.uz, was set up back in 2011. However, the platform has not become popular, perhaps because people had to provide their cellphone numbers to register on the website. The launching of Youface, therefore, is another attempt by the authorities to get the country's Internet users to prefer a “national” platform over the “foreign” ones.

The new social network has striking similarities with Facebook – in name, but also in interface and functionality.

Home page of youface.uz

The domain name is owned by an Uzbek national named Ayubhon Abdullaev. He has admitted [ru] that the new social network service resembles Facebook “at first sight”. However, according to Abdullaev, the service's design “will be changed” as soon as its Facebook look helps attract more users. He also announced that the goal of Youface is to “boost patriotism among young people in Uzbekistan”. It is not surprising than that the website's welcome page quotes Uzbekistan's President Islam Karimov: “Our children must be stronger, smarter, and happier than we are”.

Some netizens seem to like the idea of having a “national” social network and are quite optimistic about Youface's future. For example, Black_A writes [ru]:

Prajevyov uvidem. Nu zato o nix uje uznala ves MIR! eto vam ne kakoyto MALAkot.uz :D ili SET.uz! etot sayt budet kak VK.ru v Rossiyi. Unas budet YouFace.uz…….. Ya registrirovalsya tam i ya etogo gorda skaju!!

We’ll see. The point is that the whole world now knows about [Youface]. This is not something like [muloqot.uz] or set.uz! This website will be similar to VK.ru in Russia [VK.ru or Vkontakte.ru – the most popular social network in Russia]! And we will have our YouFace.uz…. I have registered there and I am proud to say this!!!

However most Internet users in Uzbekistan have not made up their minds yet about the new social network. Almost two months after its launch, Youface has only slightly over 1,500 registered users (as of July 7, 2012). The majority of Internet users in Uzbekistan seem to care little about the new service. Nevertheless, some netizens have criticized the service for being a Facebook clone.

Hushnud, for examples, tweets [ru]:

youface.uz плохая копия FB очень даже. дизайн детское и вообще…

youface.uz is a bad, very bad copy of Facebook. The design is childish, and everything…

Oybek agrees [ru]:

я вообще в шоке такого плагиата никто не видел, просто нереально стыдно за то что это у нас… http://youface.uz 

I am shocked, nobody has seen such plagiarism before. It is an unbelievable shame that we have this… http://youface.uz 

However, once users register on the service and sign up, they can see that the website has some differences from Facebook. For example, Youface users can see who has viewed their profiles. This option is not available on Facebook, but it is very popular on Odnoklassniki. Youface also allows users to search for new friends not only by name, but also by sex, age, and location, making the website similar to online dating services. The website also has a “Marketplace” where users can post classified ads. Besides, Youface features a “Youmoney” option which does not function yet, but which is supposed to enable users to shop on the website .

Thus, Youface developers hope to attract users from Uzbekistan by providing them with more functionality then either Facebook or Odnoklassniki can offer.

An information security expert who does not want to be identified suggests [ru] that Youface might have been created to help the authorities in controlling the country's Facebook users and “relocating” them to the local social network service. According to the expert, some users might simply not notice that instead of opening a real Facebook page, their internet browsers will be opening Youface. The login and password typed into the website will then be intercepted and used by the authorities to access the Uzbek nationals’ Facebook profiles. Besides, according to the expert, Youface developers might make it completely identical to Facebook and  even copy some of the latter's user databases. In this case, Uzbek users would have access to the clone service rather than the authentic Facebook, without realizing it.

It is impossible to tell now whether these assumptions are true or not. However, Youface's policy states [ru] already now that, “when posting content on the site a user empowers the site administration to copy it […]” and even if a user deletes her or his account, “the site administration has the right to keep archived copies of user's content …”

10 comments

  • Ellery Biddle

    This is fascinating! And a very good post :) I am curious to learn more about the privacy implications of using the service. Do you have to use your real name when you sign up? What other kinds of personal information (if any) are you required to give?

    I would like to point out that the name YouFace was also used as a stand-in for Facebook in a 2010 episode of 30 Rock (a popular TV show in the US) where Alec Baldwin’s character was beginning to learn about social networks.

  • Same thing (the 30 Rock reference) immediately occurred to me when I read this, Ellery!

  • […] According to GlobalVoices, the site was recently set up to “boost patriotism among young people in Uzbekistan.“ […]

  • […] Accordin' 2 GlobalVoices, teh site waz recent set up 2 “boost patriotism among young peepz n Uzbekistan.“ […]

  • Ekaterina

    Thank you, Ellery :)
    The site policy states that one should use a real name, but since only name, date of birth and email is required to sign up, you never know whether a person registered exists in real life.
    I am curions if the platform founder knew about the TV show. Guess, no. He says that he wanted to call it “YourFace”, but then decided that it sounds better without “r” 

  • […] Пишут, что национальная соцсеть могла быть создана с единой целью — собрать всех граждан в одной базе данных и контролировать их оттуда. Youface might have been created to help the authorities in controlling the country’s Facebook users and “relocating” them to the local social network service. […]

  • […] den 21 maj och hade två månader senare bara lyckats attrahera 1500 personer, enligt bloggaren Ekaterina. En expert på it-säkerhet – som föredrar att vara anonym – är orolig för att […]

  • […] Interestingly, Beg Zukhurov's comments about “subversive” and “indecent” Internet users seems to echo the rhetoric used by government officials in neighboring Uzbekistan. On July 10, Uzbekistan's state television denounced social networks like Facebook and Russian-based Odnoklassniki [Classmates] as “dangerous weapons” used by the country's “enemies” to brainwash Uzbek youth. The country's nationals were encouraged to use “domestic” social networks such as the recently launched Youface. […]

  • […] Interestingly, Beg Zukhurov's comments about “subversive” and “indecent” Internet users seems to echo the rhetoric used by government officials in neighboring Uzbekistan. On July 10, Uzbekistan's state television denounced social networks like Facebook and Russian-based Odnoklassniki [Classmates] as “dangerous weapons” used by the country's “enemies” to brainwash Uzbek youth. The country's nationals were encouraged to use “domestic” social networks such as the recently launched Youface. […]

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices
* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site