See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Philippines, China: Scarborough Shoal Dispute Goes Online

Scarborough Shoal located in the South China Sea or West Philippine Sea is being claimed by three countries: China, Philippines, and Taiwan. Tension rose in the past month between the Philippines and China when the governments of the two nations accused each other of illegally occupying the territorial waters near the shoal. It sparked nationalist sentiments in both countries and the ‘word war’ has gone online.

Filipino netizens shared this Google Map of Scarborough Shoal to highlight its proximity to the Philippines

Filipino netizens shared this Google Map of Scarborough Shoal to highlight its proximity to the Philippines

Below are some social media reactions from the Philippines:

@redsohigh: In terms of bullying and intimidation. Wala tayong laban sa China in terms of owning Panatag Shoal. Susme. Isang nuclear lang tayo.

@redsohigh: In terms of bullying and intimidation. We can’t defeat China in terms of owning Panatag Shoal (Philippine name for Scarborough). Gosh. We are an easy nuclear target.

@SoWhatsNews: China has caught all the fish in Panatag Shoal hence the stoppage and the fishing ban. Sweet n Sour Fish Fillet mabenta ngayon sa China.

@SoWhatsNews: China has caught all the fish in Panatag Shoal hence the stoppage and the fishing ban. Sweet n Sour Fish Fillet is selling well today in China.

Perhaps to ease tension, both the Philippines and China have imposed a fishing ban in the contested area.

@roilogolez: It is unpatriotic for a Filipino to publicly express an opinion on the Panatag Shoal stand-off contrary to the government position.

@crystalbrosas: Scarborough Shoal and Spratlys Islands are for the Philippines. MAAWA NAMAN KAYO SA BANSA NAMIN, Kahit may lahi akong Chinese. -_-

@crystalbrosas: Scarborough Shoal and Spratlys Islands are for the Philippines. HAVE MERCY ON OUR COUNTRY. Even if I have Chinese lineage. -_-

Bigger than Scarborough, the Spratly issue is more controversial and potentially more dangerous since 6 countries in the Asia-Pacific are claiming the resource-rich islands.

Miko Lucena: Call it desperate to regain economic strength. With the cost of labor rising they need another source of income, preferably what the world needs, oil.

Roselyne Bairan Cua: Ang laki laki ng china,pinagkaka interesan ang atin maliliit na isla. They should just stay away from our islands and focus on their own problem. Palibasa alam nila wala tayong military warfare. Dinaadaan tayo sa sindak. Takot naman sila sa FB.

Roselyne Bairan Cua China is so big already yet it’s still interested in our small islands. They should just stay away from our islands and focus on their own problem. Maybe they know we don’t have military warfare. They are bullying us. Yet they are afraid of Facebook.

Ed Dalisay: China has a bigger problem at home. Their economy is falling and it is not that rosy as it seems to be. Leaders will always find distraction so that the people will rally behind them. One way is to wedge war against a small nation that they can easily bully. History is littered with this familiar story. This is what Bush did when he declared war against Iraq because he is becoming unpopular at home.

Joseph Corpuz: We may not be strong as China in terms of military but we can be strong economically if only we get our act together, if they don't want our exports then let's look to other countries and we must be self-reliant we can do this.

Scarborough is rich with marine resources. Photo of giant clams confiscated from fishermen in the area. Photo by @karadavid

Scarborough is rich with marine resources. Photo of giant clams confiscated from fishermen in the area. Photo by @karadavid

Rieya Piscano comments on the ongoing ‘cyberwar’ between nationalist netizens of the two countries:

Clearly, the internet has leveled the playing field even in political conflicts like the Scarborough Standoff. It has made both parties bolder in expressing their opinions toward the matter. Some, all in 140 characters. Hacking has also become a showcase of nationalism and political posts of young bloggers underline the new heights reached by cyberactivism. Crazy as it sounds, people would go out of their way to plot maps and photoshop pictures just to prove their point. It is not just a word war. It is a “meme” war and we are all “liking” it.

Hackers who attacked the website of a Philippine university left this message: "We come from China. Huangyan Island is ours"

Hackers who attacked the website of a Philippine university left this message: "We come from China. Huangyan Island is ours"

The president of the University of the Philippines issued this statement after hackers defaced the university website:

Hacking selected websites at the suspected country of the hacker or hackers does not objectively articulate any political issue and only subjectively fulfills a personal desire to “get even”

…we also call on the concerned technology-savvy Filipinos to stop hacking other websites, particularly those from China. Filipinos are more sensible than this, and our expertise is better used in productive endeavors.

Carol P. Araullo advises the Aquino government to resolve the issue without inviting US military intervention:

…would it not be the better part of political wisdom, more so statesmanship, for the Aquino administration to seriously study and issue a rational and sober reply to the points raised by China rather than brandish the Philippines military alliance with the US to act as a counterfoil to China’s military strength and to make up for the Philippines’ military inferiority?

It also serves no purpose to keep whipping up pseudo-patriotic and ultra-nationalist sentiments against China and things Chinese.

8 comments

  • Sy Shaw

    Do you know the Philippine government is one of the BIGGEST LAND GRABBERS in the South China Sea? Philippine has 7 islands, Malaysia has 7, Vietnam has 6, and China has 3. Check out this WIKI map for yourself. Most of the islands are well outside of Philippine’s EEZ. So apparently distance or proximity doesn’t matter as long as you are in control. Now I know why Malaysia and Vietnam stay quiet when Philippine ask for help.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Spratly_Is_since_NalGeoMaps.png

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spratly_Islands_dispute

  • in 1200s, one of the tribe leader went to china and died there on the way back , guess what the purpose of his trip…to gain the permit from chinese emperor to have Lu Song Island under the chinese rule… but it was refused then because chinese did not have interest upon…  but HuangYan Island is different, which was a survey point in 1200s..And yet phenoy had never said a thing until recenly there was claimed oil in south china sea…how pity it is…. just for oil and jump up and down like monkey!

    • Yaiksss

      well present a credible historical document, everyone can make up one. 

      It is funny how the Chinese Government and i mean government implement a fishing ban, and yet sent out the biggest fishing expedition.   Does this mean that they acknowledge that the seas that their plundering is not there’s. 

      Same with the Panatag shoal, 30 fishing boats.   Who do we believe now as conflicting statements.  I hope China make do diligence on their word that to resolve conflicts peacefully by action and not words.

  •  phenoy has more than 7000 island and still wants to grab more by rediscovery of islands which was claimed by others long long time ago…

    • Yaiksss

      Wow, funny how that goes, how big is China how big is the Philippines….your distorted definition of land grabbing is very funny.

      Did you know that Japan also has a maritime dispute, Korea and Vietnam the same.  The stupid 9 dash line is claiming the whole South China Sea, close to the shores of the surrounding countries.  What’s next asking for toll for every ship that pass thru its lane.  You know that if no one step up this will not stop. 

    • Yaiksss

      I think you should also ask yourself with China with land area 9,640,821 km2 (3rd to fourth largest) still wants to occupy areas that are real close to other countries.  The Philippines which only ask for territories that are within the 200 nautical miles does not claim the whole South China Sea.  The Philippines are 7,000 islands, but this is minute compared to the land area of China.  As if the land is not enough the claim is to occupy and take control of the West Philippine Sea (South China).  I think you should think first before you comment as there is more than enough for China and the other countries to share.  This is very rude and greedy.

  • […] the territorial dispute between China and the Philippines over Bajo de Masinloc (also known as Scarborough Shoal or Panatag Shoal) and the Kalayaan Group of Islands (also known as Spratlys). She emphasized that […]

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices
* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site