Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Ethiopia: Outrage Over Abuse of Ethiopian Domestic Worker in Lebanon

Mobile phone video footage that shows an Ethiopian domestic worker being beaten and dragged by force into a car under the gaze of bystanders outside the Ethiopian consulate in Beirut, Lebanon has caused angry reactions amongst Ethiopian netizens.

The video shows her laying on her back on the side of the road surrounded by the perpetrators who are speaking in Arabic. One of them is seen dragging her by the arms and hair. She was resisting while saying in Amharic “I will not go. I will not go.”

Instantly, Ethiopian netizens left hundreds of comments on YouTube. Many netizens shared the controversial video on their Facebook pages, the most frequented social media platform in Ethiopia, which in turn produced hundreds of comments. The silence of the Lebanese onlookers on the side of the road and most importantly the inability of members of the Ethiopian consulate in Lebanon to keep the girl away from her perpetrators has angered many Ethiopians.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=aJeoGYG2Nfc

Most netizens expressed anger at the perpetrators by stereotyping them as Arabs and Muslims.

One of the comments on YouTube from fisu2011 reads:

I want you to watch the video footage of “Barbarism in Lebanon” against defenseless Ethiopian woman. Someone has to be held accountable for this crime sooner or later. Shame on you barbaric Lebanese and Arabs. I hope once Syria is cleansed from Bashar Al Assad Lebanon might be expunged by the Israelites. Ethiopians who watched this video will never forget this brutality and will revenge soon or later.

The exchange of comments even became hostile towards Arabic culture and Muslims. One particular remark reads:

This is nothing compared to what many Arabs do to most emigrant workers…I have personally seen and witnessed some gruesome accounts of abuse and even death that happened to a number of Ethiopian woman, but as an EthiopianI feel for my sisters and as a human being I just can’t help but detest the Arabs and their barbaric culture…call it being racist or ignorant but this is the fact…..they are evil…

Yet, the conversation also included more moderate views from Ethiopians who insisted that Ethiopians must not stereotype people and must start to stand for themselves. For example, mamelo4us says:

I am not an Arab I am Ethiopian like you & I am proud to be a Muslim, if you had a brain you shouldn't give a comment like that blaming all Arabs for what happen to our sister. Cruel, insane & criminals have no faith, race or color they are all over the world & we should fight them as a person not as race, faith or as a society. I know your comment will not reflect as all Ethiopians because we Ethiopians know the difference between one person & a society. They brought the criminal to justice

Ali Mahfouz - the man seen in the video abusing the Ethiopian domestic worker. Photo courtesy of http://www.lbcgroup.tv/.

Ali Mahfouz – the man seen in the video abusing the Ethiopian domestic worker. Photo courtesy of http://www.lbcgroup.tv/.

Mahlet Solomon, a prominent opinion leader, wrote on her Facebook:

I don't want to share the video of the Ethiopian domestic worker being kidnapped in front of the Ethiopian embassy in Lebanon. I don't want to share it because I am TIRED of the trivial question – why do Ethiopians suffer in every part of the world? And because there is nothing I can do about it or I have tried to do where as father(a white American) with the aspiration of giving a better world to his son wages a war on Uganda in the name of bring Joseph Kony to justice with the determination of stopping at nothing.

Being confined by our limitation must stop, it must stop. Our expectation shouldn't also be limited, they should not. And even if they are, we should exceed them yes we should exceed our limitation. We just have to start thinking, THINK!!!”

De Birahan blog contextualized the wide-ranging human right abuse in the country by giving a detailed perspective:

Maids in Ethiopia are mostly women who come to Addis Abeba from the rural to work in urban houses. They live with the people sheltered and fed, and paid a meagre monthly salary for their services. They often do the cooking, cleaning, washing, all houses chores; guard the house at times and also as nannies. Although there exists a symbiotic relationship between the employer and the maid; the intricacies of it shows that it is more of feudalistic and elitist. Some could argue that Ethiopian maids who export themselves to Arab countries face even the worst type of abuse there, so better that they be anyway here. No “Injustice anywhere, is injustice everywhere”, in most middle eastern countries and Ethiopia maids work long hours, seven days a week and month, no or sporadic vacations, no legal recourse in the case of disagreement with their employer. Maids most often maids eat leftovers or she cooks special food poor in quality and content from the rest of the household members for herself, sleeps in a separate building and room from the family (service bet). In most cases teenage maids that come from rural areas to help themselves and poor families are made to go to evening class (if ever allowed). They are forced to sex or raped by the men in the household (husband, son or relatives).

While many Ethiopian domestic workers flock to the Middle East, the Ethiopian government has not taken a leading role in protecting Ethiopian citizens enduring horrendous human right abuse in the region. Social media platforms continue to be a media outlet for Ethiopians to express their views and opinions about human rights abuse of domestic workers.

LBCI identified the man seen in the video, Ali Mahfouz, through his plate number.

Ethiopians organised a social media campaign for justice last year after a CNN journalist, Dan Rivers, revealed the horrifying abuse of Shweya Mullah who was brutally injured after the wife of Gaddafi’s son poured boiling water on her whole body for allegedly failing to keep a crying child quiet.

31 comments

  • […] BEIRUT, Lebanon — The filmed abuse of an Ethiopian domestic workman in Lebanon has drawn widespread defamation and thrown light onto a determined problem of vital and operative conditions of a estimated 200,000 migrants in a country. The video depicts a lady fibbing on a belligerent outward a Ethiopian consulate before a organisation of organisation drag her opposite her will into a car. She is quoted as observant in Amharic “I will not go,” GlobalVoices wrote.  […]

  • Dagnachew

    It is very sad to see such kind of barbaric act in front of ethiopian consulate. Again this shows the consulate does’t have any right to defende those poor girls. I personaly ask the government of Lebanon to bring Ali Mahfouz to justice and again I will also ask my fellow Ethiopians to join hands expose this to the rest of the world.

  • I should be the one Thanking you Fetle …

    I know there is lots of work to be done on the field ..

    At some point you have to change the mentality of people and that is very hard.
    Lebanese claim they are very liberal and open -minded only its just in the surface :S

    and from another hand you also have the issue of enforcement of the law …

    before speaking about that poor ethiopian lady .. I will talk about law failing to protect lebanese themselves
    Can you imagine that Religious men and some deputees put a veto on law protecting women from domestic violence :S

    beside our state is unable to protect its expatriates …
    Whenever a crisis happens or so we are rappatriated via the embassy of france and others …

    So we still have a looooooonggg way to become the democracy we brag about :S

    Once more I apologize for what happened
    But i wish I was able to guarantee it wont happen again :S

    Im sorry :s

  • Looks like the poor lady committed suicide :S

    Im sorry ….

  • Rebecca Smith

    You should read the Saudi news and Dubai One media online. There are literally almost 100’s of reports of maid suicides. Maid dies trying to ‘escape’ by climbing out 5th story window; maid attacks sponsor family for revenge; maid beaten; maid murdered; Lemme see if I can find a link for you to start with. You will also get some really good stories that are SO weird. Witchcraft and sorcerers, people getting arrested for that. Sentences meted out against criminals – a man who raped his own daughter received 5,000 lashes sentence.

    HERE’S ONE OF ETHIOPIAN MAID WHO KILLED THE adult daughter of her sponsor with an AXE the day before her wedding. Said it was revenge.

    http://www.arabtimesonline.com/NewsDetails/tabid/96/smid/414/ArticleID/176315/reftab/69/Default.aspx

    Here’s a nepalese maid who jumped from 7th floor suicide. There are links on the page to many more maid stories.

    http://www.emirates247.com/news/region/maid-jumps-to-death-from-7th-floor-2011-01-12-1.341310

  • Newspapers announced the girl has committed suicide today, March 14, in the psychiatric clinic she was… This is extremely shocking since nobody reasonably understands how it is possible for such thing to happen. Criminal negligence.

  • naizgi

    Sucide is an ancient term for murder cover up. And in lebanon they perfected it.

  • Eli Gaphary

    I am Lebanese and very proud of my heritage. Even before watching this video I always heard of people being mistreated in Lebanon. Sometimes they happen to be Lebanese, not just foreigners.
    I’m so ashamed of the way media tried to conceal this racist’s identity at first, and equally ashamed of the government’s initial reaction to this case.
    Many of the Lebanese are outraged by this. And we are sharing this video on Facebook and other types of social media. We as Lebanese do face racist attacks elsewhere in the world. Racism is a disease that exists in every country,society, culture and creed. We would like to see this man in prison as a lesson to others. We are so ashamed of him and others like him.
    Please don’t feed hatred and fear. And accept our sincere condolences on behalf of the majority of the Lebanese, who happen to be loving and welcoming people. Don’t put us all in one basket. FYI many lebanese are now organizing campaigns and protests for the protection of foreign workers. We will not rest until we abolish this modern form of slavery.

  • deb

    why do you hide the cowards face! Show him for who he truly is. An abuser and a coward! He is lower than a snake. Quit protecting him and his kind! The sooner you show his face the sooner he can be identified and the sooner he can be brought to justice. He is an evil miscreant who deserves similar fate.

  • […] phone video footage that shows Alem Dechasa being beaten and dragged by force into a car under the gaze of bystanders […]

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.