Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Trinidad and Tobago: Debating a State of Emergency

The unexpected declaration of a national state of emergency to deal with a high rate of crime has taken citizens of Trinidad and Tobago by surprise. At a press conference on the evening of Sunday 21 August, Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar announced that “after much deliberation it has been agreed that Government will impose a limited state of emergency in hot spots across the country.” This legal step, which affects a broad range of civil rights, has triggered widespread debate about the roots of violent crime in Trinidad and Tobago and the implications of the government's latest strategy.

The state of emergency requires a presidential proclamation under conditions specified in the Trinidad and Tobago constitution, as noted by KnowTNT.com. It gives the authorities special temporary legal powers to arrest and search citizens without a warrant. It also imposes a curfew on the capital city, Port of Spain, and its immediate suburbs, as well as the major urban centres of San Fernando, Arima and Chaguanas, restricting residents to their homes between 9 pm and 5 am. Other Emergency Powers Regulations [PDF] affect habeas corpus and citizens’ rights to freedom of movement, assembly, association, speech, and privacy.

Over the past decade, the murder rate in Trinidad and Tobago has increased dramatically, fuelled by the rise of criminal gangs, the illegal drug trade, and the widespread availability of illegal guns. Successive crime-prevention plans, heavy investment in surveillance technology, and even the hiring of a Canadian police commissioner have had little effect. In recent days, the country was horrified by a series of murders — 11 in a four-day period. Announcing the state of emergency, Persad-Bissessar said: “The current crime spree dictates that more must be done and stronger action must be deployed now…it must be a response that will hold the current spike in gang activity and crime in general in the shortest possible time.”

Some Trinidadians online welcomed the government's strategy. “Regular readers of this blog will know this is something I called for on many occasions and am strongly in support of,” said blogger Jumbie's Watch. “Many have been calling on the government for firm and decisive action and like it or not, this is it,” noted Plain Talk. On Twitter, @taramjohn declared her “support of the #stateofemergency #lockdown:

Prefer be @ home by 9pm than feel unsafe in d country I live in. #patience

Others questioned the efficacy of a state of emergency, the implications for civil rights, and the possibility of abuse of emergency by the authorities. Twitter user @AsaMarie91 wryly noted:

i think the idea of calling a #stateofemergency in #trinidad is great!……If we were fighting vampires >.<

@tsaboca asked:

What happens if yuh enemies have police friends?

And @fakekamla — a Twitter account satirically impersonating the prime minister — naturally weighed in:

Dengue still killing me. Slept all day and only just got up. Dreamt I declared a state of emergency and confused the shit out of everybody.

The economic effects of the state of emergency, and in particular the curfew, also came under scrutiny. “If this country was a corporation, our share price would be heading south just about now,” remarked @30daysnFebruary via Twitter. “Poor tourism industry,” said @Track7Music. “It was already in shambles and making like what.. $10 a year…. Now its sure to be jus extinct.”

In the hours after the state of emergency was announced, many Trinidadians were bewildered by an absence of reliable official information. The measures were scheduled to take effect at midnight on 22 August, but the Emergency Powers Regulations were not released until several hours later. An inaccurate list of areas under curfew was circulated online and via mobile networks.

As is usually the case in Trinidad and Tobago's social media sphere, the liveliest debate unfolded in the semi-privacy of Facebook, which was also a channel for spreading news and rumours. Facebook user Brendon J. O'Brien posted a note that attracted several dozen responses (quoted with explicit permission from the writer):

I, for one, am left wanting a much more serious explanation for such serious (or at least serious-sounding) measures. Mrs. Persad-Bissessar says that the current rate of crime proves that “government must respond to in the most definitive manner possible.” This would be completely understandable if it were … capable of being fully understood. While crime is a real issue for Trinbagonians, I believe we can all agree that much more still stood to be done within calm reason. This, however, is simply a mad rush to the extreme…. many have already begun to warn friends and family of possible excessive force, and to say that they fear the policeman more than the thief. This will shape how we respond to an elevated state of protective force, and should've been taken into consideration when this plan was coming together…. The end result in the next few days could only be confusion.

On Twitter, Trinidadians quickly adopted the hashtags #stateofemergency and #stateofemergencytt. The curfew regulations — the aspect of the state of the emergency most likely to affect regular citizens — came in for particular attention. Comedian @Buhwamoder wrote:

For everyone who is doubting that this curfue will actually help just remember that you can't get murdered in the daylight.

@AdVerse4490 was more defiant:

Eh…Kamla…I LETTING YUH KNOW, if I feel to leave MY house, I GO LEAVE MY HOUSE. Yuh unders?

@oilandmusic76 pointed out that the regulations were aimed at specific communities considered to be gang “hotspots”:

Now the scary part is that this is a ‘limited state of emergency” in only certain areas. Read:poor/black.

@ _Kavira_ expressed a widely held view:

Doesn't the designation of hotspots mean that crime could potentially migrate to the other areas?

@AltonBertie added:

but i still hvnt heard any viable solutions to crime. how r they gna prevent crime AFTER the #stateOfEmergency

And writer B.C. Pires, who tweets from @ToBCorNotToBC, reacted to a statement by the acting commissioner of police that the media are not considered an “essential service” for the purpose of issuing curfew passes:

Why would anyone think journalists are essential in a state of emergency? You don't want people to find out what you're doing, do you?

If you allowed journalists to cover your police beatings, intimidatory arrests etc, what would be the point of a state of emergency?

One commenter at Trinidad and Tobago News Blog suggested the state of emergency may also have something to do with current negotiations between the government and the main public service union, which have included threats of a general strike:

All to avoid civil unrest due to industrial action, not human rights…. What is really happening? Let us not be emotional but objective. This move will stop the labour movement in their tracks first and foremost before it addresses any criminal elements!

Meanwhile, developments in Trinidad and Tobago attracted attention elsewhere in the Caribbean region, where other nations have struggled to control levels of crime and violence. Writing from St. Vincent and the Grenadines, blogger Abeni questioned the wisdom of the Persad-Bissessar government's actions:

While I agree that escalating violence in the region is cause for great concern this move strikes me as being panicky, ill thought out and silly. It may be that there will be some short term gain but when this limited emergency is lifted I am sure it will be business as usual. So rather than place limited state of emergencies and interfere with people's basic rights Caribbean leaders better sit down and identify what is driving this upsurge of violence in their respective islands.

26 comments

  • Annie Gomes

    It’s long overdue, I say lock them up and throw away the keys. That will be the best thing for T & T. I am afraid to return home on a simple vacation in fear of my life, how sad is that? We are no better than Guyana or Jamaica, shame, shame and shame. Trinidad is my native land but I am ashamed of it. Thumbs up to the Prime Minister, she is doing a great job.

  • cheri

    no need to insult jamaica because of what is going on in t&t. I know jamaica has it’s problems, but everywhere does, insulting jamaicans is not going to fix things in t&t.

  • joao carlos

    The current state of emergency is nothing more than a panic response I have listened to 2 days of parliamentary debates on the topic and still the government has not justified what was the so called crisis. Thatt the state of emergency had averted. And they want to extend the soe to 3 months more! The government has dismantled its crime fighting mechanisms ie sautt,SIA the. Cancellation of the opv’s therefore as a result of this how can we protect our borders from allowing the illegal drugs guns and women from entering the country. Last night I was driving home after curfew hrs from port of spain to central trinidad not a police or soldier in sight. This issue raise more questions than answers. While law enforment amusing themselves. With catching the small fish. Mr big is bring in his biz under the cover of night. The govt has no plan and maybe our PM is going through PMS hence the reason for these erractic actions and descions over the last 15 days in conclusion I urge you all to look @ the writing on the wall and listen to a song by david rudder. On youtube called a madman rant I chose that song because it reflects what is really going right now.

  • […] August 21, parts of Trinidad & Tobago have been under a state of emergency, enacted in response to a recent crime wave. Citizens' rights to freedom of movement, assembly, […]

  • […] state of emergency, ostensibly to deal with the country's rising crime rate. Nicholas Laughlin summed up the general feeling by pointing out that “this legal step, which affects a broad range of civil rights, has […]

  • […] 2011 event, themed “Cultural Reality Imitated in a Mutual Environment”. The focus, inspired by the Trinidad and Tobago's government's imposition of a state of emergency to combat the escalating crime situation, looked at crime “as part of the cumulative […]

  • […] kulturowe naśladowane we wspólnym środowisku”. W czasie spotkania, zainspirowanego ustanowieniem przez władze Trynidadu i Tobago stanu nadzwyczajnego w celu zwalczania nasilających się wykroczeń, przyjrzano się zbrodni jako “części […]

  • […] aparentament per tractar el creixent índex de delinqüència al país. El Nicholas Laughlin va resumir el sentit general per assenyalant que “aquest acte legal, que afecta una àmplia gamma de drets cívils, ha […]

  • […] يبدو في البيئة المشتركة“. الشعار جاء مستلهماً من قرار حكومة ترينيداد وتوباجو فرض حالة الطوارئ بسبب تصاعد معدل الجريمة، والمؤتمر نظر للجريمة على […]

  • […] Price used the first anniversary of the State of Emergency in Trinidad and Tobago -which was declared on Sunday August 21st 2011 and ended on December 5th that same year- to reflect […]

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site