Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Singapore: Swiss national to be caned for train vandalism

On June 25th 2010, Oliver Fricker, 32, was sentenced to three strokes of the cane and five months in prison after he pleaded guilty to breaking into a Singapore train depot last month and vandalism for spraying the words “McKoy Banos” across two carriages (a video of the graffiti has been widely shared in blogs and forums).

He was accompanied at the time by with a man identified as Lloyd Dane Alexander, a Briton, who was in Singapore for just three days, according to the prosecution. Singapore has sought the extradition of Alexander, who it said was last believed to be in Hong Kong.

Legal and analysis blogger, Right Juris, wrote that foreigners should abide by the rules of the country they are in:

While not an advocate of caning, stoning and other forms of violence, I understand that it is necessary at times to protect the people and their property. No one chooses to be a victim of crime, minor or otherwise—-that decision is made by the criminal.

Singaporean socio-political blogger, Kristen Han, denounced the sentence as ‘completely sickening’ and labelled Singapore a ‘Global Torture Hub’ :

It is completely sickening. I can’t believe that we are going to inflict such an archaic and utterly barbaric punishment for such a petty crime that did not even hurt anyone (and almost went undetected). It is so completely overblown – and I’m not saying this because he is a foreigner. It is completely overblown as a punishment for anyone, and it disgusts me that my country would do something like this to a person, and think it NECESSARY.

Singaporean blogger, Roger Poh, called the caning ‘demeaning and barbaric’, and also slammed Singapore's aspirations to be a kinder and caring society:

Caning is demeaning and barbaric, often leaving permanent scars as caning is inflicted on bare buttocks.
Caning has no place in modern, civilised societies.
Singapore from time to time makes stirring declarations that it wants to be a kinder and more gracious society. Unless we abolish caning, this aspiration is merely lip service.

4 comments

  • i do agree with Roger when he said that caning has no place in modern society, isn’t serving prison time enough already?

  • Since his lawyer plans to appel, the second Judge should vacate the 1st order, resentence him to the max., 8 strokes of the cane and 3 yrs in prison!

  • Walter

    Just to point out. My mum used to cane me when I was young, on bare legs or bare hands. Caning was very common 20, 30 years ago in Asian culture, and I know for one that it still actually is, but because now the “caner” is shamed, it’s a lot less publicized.

    FYI, no scars, it hurts like hell, and it makes you feel humiliated. But no “mental scars” and no “permanent scars”. Didn’t feel too “barbaric”. I’m still fine.

    Not to say I’d do the same to my own kids – I have two young boys – but I definitely think any outcry over such treatment is way overblown. Please. Stoning KILLS. Caning… hurts, humiliates, and basically makes you realise you don’t want to do this again. Get the comparisons straight please.

  • […] Water buffaloes were banned in Indonesia rallies. Convicted of vandalism, a Swiss national was caned in […]

Cancel this reply

Join the conversation -> Syafique Shuib

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.