Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan: Initial Coverage of the “Osh Massacre”

On June 10, 2010, local clashes between the ethnic Kyrgyz and Uzbek population in the Kyrgyz part of the Ferghana valley [EN] turned into a full-blown massacre and further exodus of the Kyrgyzstan-based Uzbeks [EN]. It seems that the conflict had been incited by the Kyrgyz organized criminal gangs in order to destabilize the region and might be connected with the revolutionary events in Kyrgyzstan two months earlier. Although it's evident that, even if provoked by the criminals, the conflict has deeper roots.

Refugees on the suburbs of Osh, Source: diesel.elcat.kg

Refugees on the suburbs of Osh, Source: diesel.elcat.kg

Surrounded by mountains, Ferghana valley [EN], a densely populated region in Central Asia, has one of the most complicated ethnic patterns in the world. On the territory similar in size to the state of Pennsylvania live 11 mln people. The borders between the newly-established republics of Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan had been literally drawn on a map by Stalin officials in the Soviet times, leaving more problems than solutions as they left lots of Kyrgyz villages and cities on the Uzbek side and vice versa. Poverty, rural specialization and high level of unemployment determine the overall situation.

Osh [EN], the second largest city in Kyrgyzstan, is an especially complicated case, since a significant part of its population is (was) Uzbek. The difficult relations between Kyrgyz and Uzbek populations were revealed during the Osh riots in 1990 [EN], which happened under similar circumstances and resulted in more than 300 dead and more than 1,000 wounded.

The information on what has happened during the past three days of violence and turmoil is scarce, since there's almost no electricity in the city. However, bloggers manage to send the materials to the web. U.S.-based Yelena Skochilo (aka LJ-user morrire [RUS]), as during the April 2010 Kyrgyzstan revolution [EN], tried to collect all the major news sources. But, she acknowledged, there are too few credible sources of information:

Эмоций просто через край, но я понимаю и разделяю страх беззащитных людей…Что известно точно: пожар в микрорайоне Черемушки и одиночные пожары по городу. Много провокаторов. Жители постоянно слышат выстрелы. Позвольте привести одну цитату, которая отражает общую картину и вы поймете, почему я не хочу вести time line. Я знаю этого человека лично и могу полагаться на его данные.
“… мне позвонил и спросил: “…, значит нам никто не поможет?”. никому не пожелю такого. я чуствовала себя как собака….я их встретила у туберкулезного диспансера. я села за руль и всем кричала. что он кыргыз. нам с трудом удалось его вывезти из этого района.по улице шли около 20 солдат, а за ними шла толпа молодых и не молодых людей кыргызской национальности. я тоже незнаю, что делать. “

Emotions are going overboard, but I understand and share the feeling of defenseless people… What is known for sure: there's a fire in the Cheremushki district and fires all around the city. There are lots of provocateurs. People constantly hear shots. Let me bring one citation, which reflects the overall picture and you'll understand why I don't want to write a timeline. I know the author in person and I can rely on his data.
“… he called me and asked: “…so, no one is going to help us?” I wouldn't wish this to anyone. I felt myself like a dog….I met them near the tuberculosis clinic. I took the driving wheel and shouted to everyone that he's a Kyrgyz. With difficulties we managed to get him out of the district. On the street there were about 20 soldiers and behind them a crowd of young and not so young people of the Kyrgyz ethnicity. I don't know what to do.”

NewEurasia.net became the major English-language source providing pictures [EN], videos and the latest news on the development of the events. Mil.wms.kg posted pictures [RUS]. Kyrgyzstan-based blogger sherboto posted pictures [RUS] of the events. Kyrgyz official press-agency Akipress.org and Kloop.kg provided their time lines of the events (available here [RUS] and here [RUS]). Forum users at diesel.elcat.kg provided photos of the crowds of refugees [RUS].

On June 13, the conflict went online [EN], with emerging pro-Kyrgyz and pro-Uzbek accounts. (At the same time, there are significantly fewer Uzbek websites due to strict anti-internet regulations in the country [EN]). Several Kyrgyz websites went down. Registan.net, where the events were being discussed, also went down, probably due to the Digg-effect. Clearly Uzbek-biased Youtube user saveosh presented a 6-minute Google Maps video [EN]. Although being a valuable source of information, the video presents a version far from neutral.

Twitter tags #Osh, #Uzbeks, #JA (for Jalalabad, the second city where the clashes also took place) and #freekg were used to group tweets on the event.

8 comments

  • Artur

    It is unbelievable. There are two strongest political players in the world – USA and Russia having their military bases in Kyrgyzstan – and they do nothing to stop these irreversible clashes. How to save these people when they no longer feel responsible for stopping the massacre just outside their \interests\?

    • Luk

      Artur, there’s nothin strange in US ‘n Russia behaviour. No one would send their soldier to fight 4 people in another country without a (financial) reason. The massacre in Osh shows us, how week the central asia states are.

      but I understand ur human reaction

  • amy

    I know how strange this comment is going to sound however, I’m going to give it a try. My daughter is in the Peace Corp and near Bishkek. She has loved and nurtured a puppy for the past 2 years. he weighs 7 lbs. and has been such a survivor. His name is Oliver and I would love to send a pic. My daughter is going to be evacuated and if he is left behind, it will be sure death for him. Do you know of anyone that may be near Bishkek and if I pay for all of the transport, get him back to the US? He would need to be picked up and crated. Please contact me @ amy@amydelaneyvoice.com

  • […] Alexey Sidorenko on Global Voices […]

  • […] divides separate us today. It is heart wrenching to read the accounts this week of ethnic violence in Kyrgyzstan. While working to improve student achievement remains an important goal in our […]

  • […] specjalne jednostki KGB. Więcej o obecnej sytuacji w Kirgistanie można dowiedzieć się z artykułu Alexeya Sidorenko (Alex jest naszym redakcyjnym kolegą – webmasterem strony Eastbook.eu), który zamieścił […]

  • […] reported, on June 10, clashes between the ethnic Kyrgyz and Uzbek population in the southern Kyrgyzstan have […]

  • […] degree that saying a given person is Kyrgyz or Uzbek makes them so, as this chilling account from a blogger on Global Voices shows: … he called me and asked: “…so, no one is going to help us?” I wouldn’t wish […]

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.