Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Turkey: Can Turkish-Israeli relations be rebuilt?

As the world watched the events that happened on board the Turkish-led “Gaza Freedom Flotilla” it was also witnessing the deterioration of political relations between the governments of Turkey and Israel. Anger at the Israeli government is palpable in Turkey, and returning activists are being greeted by officials among hero fan-fare. As we evaluate the repercussions of these events within Turkey, the question must be asked: Can Turkish-Israeli relations be rebuilt?

An Extension of Turkish Foreign Policy

Israeli flags were burned in Istanbul, tens of thousands of Israeli tourists cancelled Turkish holiday reservations and a lawyer attempted to punch an Israeli cyclist off his bike today, as relations between the erstwhile allies plunged to depths not seen in decades.

writes James in Turkey. Turkish public sentiment and support of the people of Gaza currently runs high as noted in this tweet from freelance journalist Fredericke Geerdink:

flag seller #üsküdar used to sell only turkish flags, with or without portrait of atatürk. now he sells palestinian flags too. #turkey

It is important to note that the Gaza Freedom Flotilla was not sponsored by the Turkish Government, but the attack of the flotilla has now become an issue of national importance. Istanbul Calling explains this relation between the citizen-led flotilla and its effect on Turkish foreign policy:

Clearly, this rupture between Turkey and Israel has been long coming. As I've written before, Turkey has, for the last few years, pegged its relations with Israel to what happens on the Palestinian front (or, more specifically, on the Gaza front). Although technically not a bilateral issue between the two countries, the situation in Gaza has, in many ways, become the issue that defines the current relations between Israel and Turkey. In that sense, although the Gaza aid flotilla was organized by a Turkish NGO (the Islamist IHH) and was not sponsored by the Turkish government, it acted as a proxy for Turkish policy.

In fact a variety of Turkish bloggers and tweeters have asked the Turkish government to physically intervene by sending in the Turkish navy to protect the flotilla, such as in this tweet by Talk Turkey:

Why not Turkey send the Turkish Navy to protect the remaining ships traveling toward Gaza right now…

Questioning of Intentions

There have been significant reactions to the perceived lack of justification for Israeli aggression towards the flotilla. According to the Istanbullian:

There was no justification for the use of firearms against them. Especially on international waters… Facing knives and slingshots don't justify shooting on civilians, killing even sleeping people. Israeli forces should have waited until those ships are in Gaza waters. Then they should have forced the ships to reroute without boarding them. What Israel has done is definitely against international law and Turkey can easily win a case in international courts.

Idilx notes the following on Twitter:

Well then I guess #Israel set a precedent here. We are now allowed to shoot onto anything that we believe is smuggling arms. #flotilla

She adds:

Oooo an icecream van.. BANG BANG. Oooo a 4 year old with a bulge in his pants.. HE MUST HAVE A GUN.. bang! Idjits. #Gaza #Flotilla #Israil

Some Twitterers have questioned the reactions (and possible future reactions) from the Turkish government to the flotilla incident, from Talk Turkey:

Turkey to declare war against Israel? … Not far fetched … All of this is part of a bigger ‘script’

And this one from fgeerdink:

turkish friend: ‘erdogan just orchestred this whole #flotilla thing to increase his popularity again’ he's serious #conspiracytheory #turkey

In any case, the deterioration of relations also raises questions of safety, from Idilx:

Is #Turkey becoming a dangerous place for Jewish Turks? It seems that racists are everywhere and their idiocy is endless. So easily fueled.

Time will only tell what will happen between Turkey and Israel. The last word in this post goes to the blogger and columnist The White Path as he describes the differences in Turkish philosophy and Israeli philosophy:

When I asked that question to an Israeli hawk some years ago, I received a very revealing response: “Might,” he said, “makes right.” Well, that might be a popular belief in Tel Aviv and Occupied Jerusalem, but not here in Istanbul. In fact our creed tells us that the exact opposite is true: Right, sooner or later, makes might.
The hundreds of heroes who sailed to Gaza last weekend had this faith in their hearts. Here in Turkey, 70 million more stand by them. We mourn for our fallen, but also know that they did not die in vain. Their sacrifice unveiled to the world not just the suffering of the innocents in the Gaza ghetto, but also the brutality of the rogue state that imposes it.
Read my lips: This spirit is really not going to die. We Turks will continue to stand for what is right, regardless of Israel's might. None of her lobbying, bullying or killing is going to change that.

7 comments

  • Many Israelis have cancelled their flight plans to Turkey + the majority of flights between Israel and Turkey have been suspended. The deterioration of the relationship between the countries is truly worrisome.
    Thanks for the report!

  • […] Turkish-led flotilla which attempted to break the blockade of Gaza has strained Turkish-Israeli relations, while gaining […]

  • lior

    Is Democratic Turkey on the way to becoming an Islamic republic?

    Turning a democracy into dictatorship – a to do list

    1.Enforce the national feelings of the nation; make use of the nation’s history, religion, culture and all that increases the nation’ self esteem
    2.Find a common threat or a common enemy, threatening the morality or the dignity or the well being of the nation.
    3.Position yourself as the strong leader who is guarding the interests and the dignity of the nation, that is currently at peril
    4.Prepare the ground for the case where controlled must be seized for the benefit of the nation. This can be done by inserting people in key positions (e.g. the army, General Security Service, police force, judiciary…) or changing pivotal rules hindering the ability to protect the democracy
    5.Create a big incident, floating the danger and stand boldly against it, while protecting the nation’s pride, honor and sacred interests. At the time of elections, you will be granted power and the aims to proceed with the transformation.

    For example, at 1933 Nazi went into power establishing the Nazi Germany.
    1.The Nazi political platform emphasized the desire to resurrect the mighty historical past of the medieval holy roman empire, and regain the trampled German dignity from the end of WWI
    2.The common enemy was the Jewish people and its devious plan to rule the world, especially the goal being Germany’s national subversion
    3.The Nazis promised strong, authoritarian government in lieu of effete parliamentary republicanism, restored national pride (principally by repudiating the Versailles Treaty), and racial cleansing, all in name of national unity and solidarity, rather than the partisan divisions of democracy, and the social class divisiveness of Marxism.
    4.this transition has taken several years (1933-1939), but at the end, all of Germany, starting from key positions until the regular people, were at the control of the party
    5.The Reichstag fire was an arson attack on the Reichstag building in Berlin on 27 February 1933 just prior to the elections. The event is seen as pivotal in the establishment of Nazi Germany. The fire was used as evidence by the Nazis that the Communists were beginning a plot against the German government

    Another, more recent example, is the Islamic revolution in Iran, where religion is the base of the revolution.

    One must learn history in order not to follow it again…

  • […] 공격에 각성하여 터키와 팔레스타인 양 국에서 가자 자유함대(플로틸라, Flotilla) 사건 를 지지하는 것을 보고, […]

  • […] Një Flotë anijesh të vogla Turke e  cila u përpoq ta thej bllokadën e Gazës ka tensionuar marrëdhëniet Turko-Izraelite, e në  ndërkohë Turqia po  fiton më shumë respekt në botën Arabe. Një bloger në Gaza ka vendosur për të treguar vlerësimin e tij për qëndrimin e Turqisë në një mënyrë praktike – duke filluar një fushatë për të blerë mallra turke. […]

  • Jenna Major

    It’s not worth the deep discount to support the Turkish economy that
    supports the Turkish government that increasingly stabs Israel in the
    back. Attorney San Antonio

  • […] there is an increase of support for both Turkey and Palestine in the wake of the Israeli raid on the Gaza Freedom Flotilla, Kurdish bloggers caution against […]

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site