Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Nigeria: A debate on pedophilia, Sharia law, and the ‘two’ Nigerias

Ahmad Sani Yerima. Source: Wikimedia commons

The headline is tabloid-esque: Nigerian senator marries  13-year-old girl. Like so much of the recent news from Nigeria, it seems more worthy of a Nollywood script than the political landscape of Africa's most populous country. And, also like so much of the news from Nigeria, the lurid drama making the rounds of international headlines is only the tip of a complex political iceberg.

The details of the story are as follows: Ahmad Sani Yerima, senator and former governor of Zamfara State in Northern Nigeria, was accused several weeks ago of marrying a 13-year old Egyptian girl. More details quickly emerged – Yerima reportedly paid the girl's parents US$100,000 in dowry, the girl's father was Yerima's cab driver, the marriage had to be performed in Nigeria to avoid legal repercussions in Egypt. Bloggers, activists, lawyers and medical professionals protested vehemently as the story developed. Women's rights organizations feared for the girl's health, saying she would be exposed to vesicovaginal fistula (VVF). Human rights groups pointed to the incident as a case of child trafficking.

In an era when the “clash of civilizations” has captured the public imagination and terrorism dominates the international agenda, it can be difficult to disentangle the personal from the political. Yerima has long been controversial for straddling this divide: he was among the leaders that re-introduced Sharia law in Northern Nigeria, and in 2006 came under fire for marrying a 15-year-old girl, whom he divorced two years later. Nigeria's population is roughly divided between a Muslim-majority North and a Christian-majority South, a balance which has been strained by several incidents in the past few months. Yerima's marriage has played into this divide, he justifies the union as being sanctioned by Islam. “I don't care about the issue of age since I have not violated any rule as far as Islam is concerned” he told the BBC – a provocative claim in Nigeria's already charged atmosphere.

Expressing the sentiments of many bloggers, Adeola wrote that religion should not be pulled into what is essentially a question of children's rights:

Let us not hide under any form or religion or culture to deprive children from living or leading their lives normally.

Akin, too, saw religion as a distraction from the real issue:

Should Islam suffer a battering because one man had to satisfy his lust for young flesh [?]

Yerima's actions function, albeit unintentionally, as a sort of activism for his particular interpretation of Islam. Many Nigerian politicians are unwilling to confront the cleavage between the northern and southern parts of the country, despite evidence of increasing tension. In what was widely seen as a gaffe, Ayogu Eze, spokesman for the Senate, initially said the Yerima affair was a private one. But the public thought otherwise and, whether Yerima intended it or no, the union has certainly gotten Nigerians discussing the implementation of Sharia law in Northern Nigeria.

Writing in This Day, Funke Aboyade responded:

Did you think you could, as you had done for eight years in your fiefdom in Zamfara imposing your peculiar brand of the Shari'a on your impoverished citizenry, transport same to the national arena without sanction? Well, here's some news for you, Senator: you've breached a law, a law you swore to uphold. And you will be sanctioned in accordance with that law.

Sokari wrote:

Women Empowerment and Legal Aid [WELA] is demanding that the Federal Government arrest and prosecute Yerima for trafficking but not for forced marriage and rape. Why – because Yerima married the young girl under Sharia law and the age of consent in Northern Nigeria remains 13. This is so typical on all levels. No one has the guts to come out name the man and his crimes and challenge a law, religious or otherwise, which violates the rights of children as agreed by all international and African human rights legislation.

A country with two major religions, three major ethnic groups and more than 500 indigenous languages, Nigeria presents an interesting case study in multiculturalism. But, as in other hybrid societies, integrating diverse cultures under one legal code is often a difficult task. Nine of Nigeria's 36 states, including the senator's own Zamfara state, follow Sharia law which puts the age of consent at 13. But in Abuja, where the marriage was carried out, 13 falls far below the age of consent. Adding to the confusion is the fact that the Federal Government has ratified the Child Rights Convention as well as other child protection treaties which would seemingly override state law and place the legal age of consent at 18. It is in this context that Yerima used Islam to justify the legality  marriage.  Speaking to the BBC, he said:

I consider God's law and that of His prophet above any other law. I will not respect any law that contradicts that and whoever wants to sanction me for that is free.

Funke Aboyade had a caustic reply:

Really? Why then, Senator, are you in the Senate? Did you or did you not swear to uphold the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria?

Sokari concluded:

The two issues are the rights of children and secondly the fact that at this moment there are two Nigeria’s – the northern Sharia states and the rest of the country and the former is increasingly removing itself from the Federal structure and picking and choosing which Federal and international laws it will uphold and those it will ignore.

Since the news broke, an investigation into the matter has been launched by the Senate. But Boma Tai-Osagbemi was critical:

Nothing will ever come out of the ‘investigation'…. I suspect this man will still be untouched and unscathed!”

Whether the investigation will yield any results remains to be seen. Whatever the outcome, the incident stands to set an important precedent, at the very least reigniting the the debate on federalism in Nigeria.

13 comments

  • jerry

    \god has no religion\… mahatma gandhi.

  • […] Ahmad Sani Yerima dismissing the controversy about his marriage to a 13-year old Egyptian girl. (Source) Law, Politics, Religion Africa, human rights, Nigeria, pedophilia, […]

  • may

    if he says it was the law of his religion that prompt him to do dat sacriilagious act then his religion is shameless and ridiculous,this particular religion claims they are one of the most faithful,but they are one of the most corrupt,bizzare and insane and most wicked poeple on earth.i use to be an islamic so am talking out of experience,that man should be hanged to death just as he has participated in hanging other poor innocent victims in the north who tried to express their feelings and tried to live a life of democracy

    • Sadia

      I am saddened that your experience has caused you to hold such bitterness towards muslims but it is entirely unjustified to label all the followers of a religion as “the most corrupt, bizzare and insane and most wicked people on earth”. There is no doubt that this man is severely violating this child’s rights on many levels. He is claiming to do so under the banner of Islam. Let it first be stated that Islam is very far from a monolithic entity where every single muslim supports this kind of action. I am willing to bet that a large majority of muslims would condemn this as a horrendous act of child abuse.

      Firstly, Islam states that the unforced consent of both the male and the female is required in a marriage. Secondly that every muslim follows the law of the land in which he/she lives: in this case the city where Yerima got married, the age of consent is 18. Thirdly, he clearly took advantage of an impoverished family of his driver and bought the child for $100 000. In Islam, the mehr, or dowry is not paid to the parents but is paid to the wife for her safety and financial independence. These are just some of the arguments against branding this as an act sanctioned by Islam.

  • Lesley Agams

    Has Yerima’s alleged marriage become a litmus test for the status of Sharia law in Nigeria? A constitutional challenge? Why have moderate Islamic clerics not spoken out? What does this say about the interpretation of Islam in Nigeria? And how does that effect me as a non Muslim living in Abuja a supposedly secular city? As a free citizen in a democracy? I fear for MY freedom under what seems to me a gradual but deliberate spread of conservative values under the guise of some else’s ‘religious freedom’.

    • Those are all important questions, things this “marriage” have made me wonder about as well. I’m curious to know whether Yerima intended his marriage as a challenge to secularism, or if he himself is surprised by the outcry that has resulted. In any case, I just hope that the various investigations into the affair yield some results.

  • gie

    Religion plays an important role in society but in male kingdom, sex rules primarily and it doesn’t have a choice – be the woman is 80 or less than 13. Robust men especially those who are taking herbal supplements, prefer younger partners due to libido. We cannot blame those who can afford to pay expensive dowries. Blame the parents who made the consent, the girl, who is under pressure of parental consent. Sex and money played an important role in this issue. No matter what the law says… the girl is under the power of parental choice.

  • What is being done in Nigeria?

    There is a polarized debate also happening on Kabissa on this case – I am concerned that to all appearances in the blogosphere nothing is being done in Nigeria, and people around the world are outraged and lashing out against the perception of non-action (and non-concern!) of Nigerians participating in the Kabissa debate. It’s not constructive and I’d be grateful for input on how to steward the discussion.

    Here’s the post on Kabissa:

    Petition: Senator Yerima marriage to 13yr old child | Kabissa http://bit.ly/cYfC09

    Cheers,

    Tobias

  • Warren Pugh

    Akin, you say ‘one man’?? Thats tragic. Even we dumb Americans know better than that. WASP

  • […] wurde Ahmad Sani Yerima, Senator und ehemaliger Gouverneur von Zamfara in Nordnigeria, beschuldigt ein 13-jähriges ägyptisches Mädchen geheiratet zu haben. Yerima zahlte den Eltern des Mädchens Berichten zufolge 100.000 US-Dollar Brautgeld. […]

  • […] 2010, Ahmad Sani Yerima, senator and former governor of Zamfara State in Northern Nigeria, was accused of marrying a 13-year old Egyptian girl. Yerima reportedly paid the girl’s parents 100,000 US dollars in dowry. […]

  • […] 2010 blev Ahmad Sani Yerima, senator och före detta guvernör i Zamfara-staten i norra Nigera, anklagad för att ha gift sig med en 13-årig egyptisk flicka. Yerima ska ha betalat 100 000 amerikanska dollar i hemgift till flickans […]

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site