Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Armenia-Turkey: Response to U.S. Genocide Resolution

armenia_genocide_memorial

Tsitsernakaberd Genocide Memorial, Yerevan, Republic of Armenia © Onnik Krikorian 2008

Following last week's non-binding resolution narrowly passed by a congressional Foreign Affairs Committee urging the US government to recognize the 1915 massacre and deportation of Armenians in the Ottoman Empire as Genocide, reaction in the blogosphere appears to be muted, including from those Armenian sites which have covered the issue for years.

Nevertheless, what does exist is mostly negative or neutral — although not necessarily reflective of comments or posts, and even no reaction at all, on closed networking sites such as Facebook. Typical of most comments made there, Life in the Armenian Diaspora sums up that reaction.

Armenians around the world are celebrating again…. […]

[…]

Again, the White House wasn't able to stop this. Turkey wasn't able to stop it with their threats about relations, borders, protocols etc. I said it two years ago and I'll say it again now. EMPTY THREATS – CALL THEIR BLUFF! Turkey can not afford to lose the U.S. as an ally. They recalled their ambassador then and they recalled him now. BIG DEAL!

turkish flag

Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) activists burn the Turkish flag, Yerevan, Republic of Armenia © Onnik Krikorian 2008

However, and in sharp contrast with previous years when similar resolutions were passed, other alternative voices are making their voices heard. Ianyan, for example, is uncertain as to what next this all means for her as an ethnic Armenian living abroad.

Right after the vote, Turkey recalled its Ambassador, Namik Tan, back for consultations, Armenian publications swiftly posted the news, status updates and tweets exploded with joy and disappointment on both sides and the Obama administration, who had urged the committee to vote against the resolution, said it will seek to block the bill from coming into fruition.

[…]

As for me, for a moment, I was shocked and surprised, although I probably shouldn’t have been. A similar resolution passed through the same committee in 2007 and was later successfully blocked from ever amounting to anything.

[…]

While we sit in free countries, in our warm houses and flashy cars in our garages, many in Armenia are still suffering from economic turmoil and poverty . There is corruption and discrimination and much more that we, thousands of miles away, have the good fortune to not see. Most diaspora Armenians have never even met a Turk, nor do they want to. […]

Do I need the U.S. government to recognize the genocide? Maybe, but I don’t feel any less Armenian, I don’t feel like something is missing if they don’t. My feelings could very well be the result of it not being recognized for so long, who knows.

[…]

The answer still is, for me, “I don’t know.”

armenian_turkey_border

Armenian-Turkish border, Khor Virap, Ararat Region, Republic of Armenia © Onnik Krikorian 2005

Another Armenian blog, Global Chaos, however, is more critical, especially in light of a more pressing issue facing Armenia – the threat of renewed conflict with neighboring Azerbaijan over the disputed territory of Nagorno Karabakh.

Yes, they made a full circle and we are seeing the whole Armenian Genocide Resolution circus played out all over again. No, I'm not happy with what happened yesterday. I'm very concerned, and I don't think it's going to have ANY positive outcome for Armenia. On the contrary, it might, and I'm afraid, it will only make things worse.

[…]

American-Armenians are all upbeat about it. They learned well how to play this game called “American politics” and they want to stay politically relevant, especially this year, when the mid-term elections might turn out to be unusually interesting. […] But where's Armenia in this equation?

[…]

There is evidently a disconnect between the Diaspora, which, quite understandably, clings to the Genocide problem as a basis for its identity, and the Armenian state, which is striving to survive, attain stability, and establish itself as a significant player on the international arena. […]

[…]

Perhaps it's high time the Armenian government stops relying on the Armenian-American lobby to do both advocacy and public diplomacy in the US on its behalf? […] Yes, it is very commendable. But, it is also detrimental for Armenia, since the foreign policy of one of the most influential countries in the world toward it is being dominated by an issue the significance of which many, on both sides, don't even understand anymore.

Again, I am not saying that the Genocide should be neglected or forgotten. What I'm saying is that the focus should switch, since with the resolution of the Karabakh problem might just open a leeway for more constructive and reconciliatory dialogue on the Genocide as well. If the Diaspora lets Armenia be, that is…

The blog also raises concerns that such a resolution will increase the level of nationalism in Turkey, something that seems borne out by one Turkish blog, Talk Turkey.

Do the Armenians really think that some soiling-their-pants Congressmen care about the Armenians’ plight? Was this part of a ploy, a plan of pushing Turkey off-track and into radicalism, alienating the ‘model’ integration of secularism and Muslim-ness, and thereby prove to the ‘world’ that a moderate Islam doesn't exist?

[…] I am now definitely not in a reconciliatory mood any longer. In fact, I say ‘let the games begin!’

memorial

Tsitsernakaberd Genocide Memorial, Yerevan, Republic of Armenia © Onnik Krikorian 2008

5 comments

  • John Vesikar

    It’s great to see that there is so much going on in the world that after only a few days this news is dropping out of the limelight.

    Where is the belief of the Bible by Armenian’s who want to push judgement on another instead of letting God decide it when it comes time. There is no one from the Ottoman time that is barely alive in Turkey, how can they be held accountable. There is surely other motives for this recognition and it’s likely to do with money and greed or God forbid, land claim or compensation for land lost which I think is a sick motive for follow on generations to even comtemplate.

    Remember this;

    (Ezekiel 18:20) – \The person who sins will die. The son will not bear the punishment for the father’s iniquity, nor will the father bear the punishment for the son’s iniquity; the righteousness of the righteous will be upon himself, and the wickedness of the wicked will be upon himself.\

    • vetiver

      What unmitigated bollox. Whatever the motivations for seeking general acknowledgement of this trajedy [and i utterly reject your insinuations in that regard], the truth should not be denied.

      The truth is that it happened, and it’s TURKEY that is the entity with the interests deeply vested in denying it.

      If you’re so excited about the games beginning, where is your righteous ‘wait until judgement day [preferably so far in the future nobody will care] saintliness now?

      You think it’s so long ago it doesn’t count anymore? Think again. Whatever the fallout, whatever the fringe benefits, the truth has to be known AND acknowledged. National pathologies breed further wars, genocides. Truth is the way ahead to healing.

  • The formal recognition of genocide will not help either side.

  • Alex

    First of all the formal recognition is required. Otherwise it is betrayal even of memory of more than million innocent people who were slaughtered ruthlessly for just being Armenians in Ottoman Turkey. Yes, hundred years had passed almost. So what? The truth should not be affirmed any more and permission could be granted for denial of real genocide as if nothing happened? I am not talking about consequences here. Taking responsibility is an entirely different story. But recognize the facts of real genocides instead of profaning the meaning of the word with regard to cases that have nothing to do with it.

  • […] course, with another Genocide resolution under consideration in the U.S. Congress, politics did briefly rear its head, but otherwise all three countries would soon be concentrated […]

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site