Japan: Law Banning Cell Phones for Kids Passed in Ishikawa

Ever since Ishikawa prefecture (500 km/315 miles north of Tokyo) passed the first of a kind regulation in the nation to limit cell phone usage for kids and tweens on June 29th, the blogosphere has been buzzing with what's appropriate and what's not for kids and cell phones. The “Ishikawa Children Comprehensive Act” [ja, pdf] Article 33 reads “Guardians must try not to let their students who are in elementary, middle, and specially supported schools have cell phones except in case of disaster prevention, crime prevention and any other special purposes.” The law goes into effect on January 1st, 2010.

Chuei at Mainichi Blog doubts the effectiveness of this regulation.



I bet no parents would think of canceling the children’s cell phone contracts because of this. Why only regulate cell phones when you can e-mail and surf the web on either cell phones or computers? It’s hard to believe that the law is after the phone calling feature of the cell phones.

I don’t expect much effects of this law because there is no particular punishments or fines just like the rule obligating the installment of the fire alarms in homes. Perhaps, this law can be used in the future in cases such as when incidents involving cell phones and elementary and middle school students happen in which the prefectural government can excuse itself, (i.e. no responsibilities for the school).

Usagi Inu at Manya Hompo suggests prepaid phones will solve all the problems.


I think the answer is to give a prepaid phone without Internet access. Since you can’t go over the limited usage on those phones, it prevents over usage.

However, the time has changed for parents to be paying for cell phones for children during a recession. When I was a child, there were no cell phones. I had to look for a payphone with change if I needed to contact my parents. Well, nowadays it’s hard to locate payphones so it may be inevitable to give cell phones to kids.

Mobile advocate member #1 of SATT which provides educational materials including online learning says he is disappointed with the law.


If you ban to have a cell phone itself, it kills an opportunity to attempt things like incorporating cell phones in the public education curriculum.

He adds the lawmakers should have focused on the possibility rather than limits.


Because cell phones are so popular in Japan and the technology, including data communication, is state-of-the-art in the world, I wish they would have focused on a possibility of “what we could do with it,” rather than “llimiting it.”

This father of two sons, Kimme can’t understand why kids need cell phones so early.


My oldest son got a cell phone for the first time when he got into college. We gave his younger brother a prepaid phone, but his plan doesn't have anything fancy like Internet capability. I believe both sons can buy any cell phone plan they want if they are going to work a part-time job and pay the bill by themselves.

However, while in elementary and middle schools there is absolutely no need. Even before this kind of a law passed, we had no intention of giving cell phones to kids so young in my family.

I guess though the fact that such law got enacted means enough kids are given cell phones of their own.

I don’t understand what it means to have a cell phone for crime prevention purposes. Well, if they’re lost, a cell phone may help. Maybe it can help if a child is kidnapped. Or perhaps to let me know they’ll be home at 10 p.m. after a “cram school” (tutoring schools).

But I think the society is wrong if a child has to carry a cell phone for crime prevention purposes.

Conversely, don’t you think it’s a much bigger risk being exposed by giving a cell phone to elementary and middle school kids?


Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »


  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.