Puerto Rico: The Battle Over Public Lands

residentes-1
Residents of Villas del Sol – photo by José Antonio Rosario republished with permission of Prensa Comunitaria.

Recently, the Puerto Rican government issued an order to remove 200 families from the Villas del Sol community in Toa Baja, under the premise that they illegally occupied lands that are prone to flooding. Police forces tear-gassed and assaulted members of the community, most of them immigrants from the Dominican Republic.

macanas
Police forces entering the community – photo by José Antonio Rosario republished with permission of Prensa Comunitaria.

This past week, the government cut their water and electricity supply. The families are resisting the eviction order stating that they have lived there for years, built their houses and their community, and are being pushed out without warning. In Puerto Rico, for many years, people from disadvantaged socioeconomic backgrounds have occupied public lands to build their homes because the government's existing social policies and programs have done little to curtail poverty and provide an adequate affordable housing stock.

The controversy has provoked impassioned debate in the Puerto Rican blogosphere. In her blog Poder, Espacio y Ambiente (ES), the law professor and expert on environmental issues, Erika Fontánez, condemned the Police aggression (ES):

La realidad es que por ser dominicanos, muchas de estas familias han tenido que soportar por todos estos años la discriminación, violencia e intimidación de la policía y de funcionarios de vivienda y hoy fue el más reciente episodio, justificado públicamente por el hecho de que no son propietarios. No son propietarios, cierto, pero acaso eso los descualifica de su dignidad humana, acaso el no serlo les priva de sus derechos civiles, de la dignidad y respeto. ¿No merecen, por no ser propietarios, un trato humano?

The truth is that because they are Dominican, most of these families have had to put up all these years with discrimination, violence and intimidation from the Police and Housing officials. Today was the most recent episode, publicly justified as reasonable because they do not own the properties they reside in. They are not owners, true, but does this mean they do not have human dignity? Does not being home owners disqualify them of their civil rights, of dignity and respect? Do they not deserve, even if they are not home owners, to be treated as humans?

pistola
“Pistola” – photo by José Antonio Rosario republished with permission of Prensa Comunitaria.

Fontánez also questioned (ES) why the government applies different standards to the developers who construct in equally dangerous or illegal terrains:

Y es que para los ciudadanos la implantación de la ley por medios violentos en este caso carece de legitimidad cuando ven que se aplica selectivamente contra un sector que está irrumpiendo el ordenamiento porque carece de un derecho básico y se le vuelca contra sí toda la violencia y el poder del estado, mientras otros irrumpen la ley para el lujo de casas de verano y permanecen impunes.

In this case, to enforce the law through violent means has no legitimacy for citizens when they see that it is applied selectively against one sector that violates the judicial order because they lack basic rights and are subject to violence and the power of the state, while others violate the law to have luxurious summer houses, but they remain unpunished.

Michael Castro, author of the blog Poder 5 (ES), says:

Aquí hay un dilema entre lo justo y lo legal. Ellos están violando la ley pero no por eso es justo que se les tire a la calle y se les deje desamparados sin un techo.

There is a dilemma here between what is fair and what is legal. They are violating the law, but that does not mean it is fair to throw them on the streets and leave them without a roof over their heads.

nene-1
Residents and police – photo by José Antonio Rosario republished with permission of Prensa Comunitaria.

In El blog de Sheila Vélez (ES), the author, who is a lawyer, states:

Se trata de un derecho humano fundamental: el derecho a una vivienda adecuada.  Ciertamente las estructuras  que conforman la comunidad Villa del Sol distan de ser “viviendas adecuadas”.  El suelo: inundable, las paredes: frágiles, los techos: de zinc y sin anclajes,  agua potable y electricidad…En Puerto Rico existe un problema histórico de acceso a vivienda adecuada  para amplios sectores de nuestra sociedad.   Sobre todo en un sistema económico que privilegia la propiedad privada de la tierra y la vivienda.   Y donde el concepto de vivienda  aceptado socialmente se relaciona a una estructura unifamiliar, terrera y privada.

This is about a basic human right: the right to adequate housing. The structures in Villas del Sol are very far from being ‘adequate houses.’ The soil: prone to flooding; the walls: fragile; the roofs: made of zinc and makeshift; no running water or electricity…In Puerto Rico there is a long history of problems of access to adequate housing for ample sectors of society. In an economic system that privileges private property and housing, and where the socially accepted concept of housing is a single family, single story structure that is privately owned.

Villas del Sol is the second community that has captured space in the blogosphere this summer. In June, the governor of Puerto Rico, Luis Fortuño, signed a law that dismantled an innovative community project of collective land ownership called Fideicomiso de Tierras del Caño Martín Peña. The doctoral student in Planning and Development, Deepak Lamba-Nieves, who also participated in the creation of the project, explained in his blog Trans(actions): Trans(acciones) (ES):

El Fideicomiso de Tierras del Caño Martín Peña, orquestado por el Proyecto Enlace y el Grupo de 8 comunidades aledañas al cuerpo de agua, es un proyecto ejemplar que le sigue la pista no a las misiones de Hugo Chávez ni a la Reforma Urbana de Cuba, sino a iniciativas similares en los Estados Unidos que han logrado mantener un caudal de vivienda asequible para los pobres y las familias de escasos recursos.

The Caño Martín Peña Land Trust organized by the Proyecto Enlace and the Group of 8 communities residing alongside the body of water is an exemplary project that follows the tradition, not of Hugo Chavez’ misiones or the Reforma Urbana in Cuba, but of similar initiatives in the United States that have been able to maintain an adequate stock of affordable housing for the poor and low-income families.
This post was also translated by the author.

27 comments

  • Gracias Sofía. Realmente la cita es parte de un post muy largo y profundo sobre el Fideicomiso. Tal vez así sola está fuera de contexto. Te invito a que leas el artículo completo. Gracias, nuevamente.

  • Ramon

    You failed to mention that this people are not Puerto Rican, this people are Illegal from Santo Domingo. If we don’t stand up and do something we will end up like Guam were the Philipinos run the land. The land in puerto Rico belongs to the Puerto Rican and the Puearto Rican only. this Dominican come to the mainland and said they are Puerto Rican and people and immigration believe them because they know very little and have the wrong idea about Puerto Rican. I live in Tijuana Mexico and when I cross the border the costume agent give me a hard time because they expect Puerto Rican to be black and I’m not. My sister came to visit me in Tijuana and we were crossing the border to San Diego and the border agent did not believe she was Puerto Rican because she has light hair and is light skin.

    • carlos mclean

      ramon please don’t forget that you are now considered. Part of U S i am a irishman come to this country to be a part and to creat jobs or people but the powers to be are not letting me i am sad for puerto rico because one of my very close friends in viet-nam was from here and had great respect for each other. Don’t be so bitter just try and help your country with pease and the so called law.

  • […] by displacing hundreds of families from public lands.   Firuzeh Shokooh-Valle has published an excellent piece in Global Voices, that offers some insights on what has transpired. The lead paragraph reads: […]

  • […] estado a la expectativa de cualquier intento gubernamental de desalojarlos, como puede leerse en este resumen (en inglés) (vean también la traducción al español).  (Y a muchos de nosotros, esos intentos de […]

  • […] Puerto Rico.”  There is also a pending eviction order to remove 200 families from the Villas del Sol community in Toa Baja. The government dismantled the innovative collective land ownership project  […]

  • […] the last months hostility has grown between the government and different civil society groups: eviction orders in socially and economically disadvantaged communities, police brutality, and the dismantlement of […]

  • […] mesi è cresciuto il disaccordo tra il governo e diversi gruppi della società civile [sp]: gli ordini di sfratto [in] in comunità socialmente ed economicamente disagiate, le brutalità della polizia, e lo […]

  • […] Rico, please see previous posts “A Crisis with Many Names”, “Such is Life”, “The Battle over Public Lands,” and “Ready for the National Strike”. The people at the nonprofit Center for the New […]

  • carlos mclean

    i am so sad for the people every where. People have to live but being in a country in illegal ways is against the law and i guess people just say i sit on the land so it mine.It is not that way in any country so why do they think they have the right to do it here in puerto rico. One bib thing i have seen since i moved here (and i am a puerto rican at heart and irishman) the police do not do there job and the police on beaches just ride around looking at girls and will not investagate someone being stolen from. I seen this first hand. Also i have respect for police but no more because i was at crash boat beach a few police were having fun diving on tax dollars. I made a comment i feel safe and the one police man said these are the ones you have to be afraid of. That kind of makes me scared now of police in puerto rico. I am a retired police man also and that is no way to speak to people. Now i think police are more corrupt than the normal person. I see police watch people throw trash out when there is trach can with-in 10 ft and police watching them and not doing a dare thing about it. If it was me i would getting a heavy fine and treated like a terrorist. This country needs to learn alot and i am most likley shutting down my business here and leaving. I did come to make a few jobs but if i am treated like that by police i am afraid they will steal from me and get away with it. This country needs to reorganize and start treating people like people who bring alot of money into here. I am sure alot agree with me

  • carlos mclean

    one more thing when i was in china the police there were military like in there ways i think that is so bad to be control;ed by the government for there own means. I see puerto rico going down the tubes

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.