Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Macedonia: Student Protest Ends in Violence

“Don't Rape Skopje” banner. Photo by Harald Schenker

Recently, the Macedonian government decided to build an Orthodox church with public financing on the main square of Skopje, a decision that the citizens of the city disapproved of. In spite of numerous online campaigns and discussions, a group of students – “First Arhi (Architect) Brigade” – decided to organize a protest called “The First Architectonical Rebellion” against the building of the church in Skopje. They set up a Facebook group [mkd] to post their demands. The blog skopje2803 posted a translation of their demands:

1. We demand an official position of the Faculty of Architecture [at the University of] Skopje on developments concerning the city’s public spaces in the interest of society.

2. We demand a professional debate before every key venture for building projects.

3. We demand transparent competitions, announcements, and urbanistic surveys, as well as commissions with representatives and consultants from Macedonia and abroad, NON-PARTY bodies that will decide about such buildings. The final decision must be sanctioned through a referendum, as practiced in European cities in such cases. Until then, a moratorium for construction must be in place!

4. We demand of politicians to – instead of investing in kitsch architecture, instead of building artificial villages for developing rural tourism, instead of drawing up new urbanistic plans, instead of building on extremely inappropriate parcels – to focus public funding on the maintenance of the authenticity and originality of the old buildings that already exist but decay due to neglect.

5. We ask that the citizens wake up, for once think with their own heads, and become actors in the building in their and their city’s future instead of remaining merely passive observers.

Soon after the news for the protest circled the internet, many posts were created to call the citizens to a counter-protest, to support the building of the church. One day before the protest the blog “Jadi Burekpublished [mkd] a call for a counter-protest:

Tomorrow at 12 pm, on the square of Skopje, probably a group of gays and atheists will gather and try to spread rubbish under the hidden motive of caring for the architecture of the city, and against the church. Because of that, tomorrow me and my family are going on a counter-protest one hour earlier, at 11 am, and will give our support to the construction of the church!

Similar texts were published on many other blogs.

The protest was scheduled for 12 pm on March 28, 2009, but, before it started, the counter-protesters gathered to support the building of the church. When the two groups met on the square of Skopje, the event turned from peaceful to violent, involving fights between the two groups:

Many bloggers that were at the protest wrote about the incident.

The blogger Harald Schenker from Vision! Come on… posted a full report:

[…] The protest was countered by a mass of up to 1500 church goers, mobilized from all over the country, who gathered to stop the protest from happening. The “spontaneous” and thus not registered counter-protest featured church flags, printed banners, a priest and a lot of people, who have no connection whatsoever to urban Skopje, but who were bussed in from rural areas to fight the Anti-Christ. A large number of expensively produced flyers flooded the city centre – clear indications of a logistically well organized movement. They were in majority, so the actual manifestation remained marginal and actually was about to retreat, when a group of violent hooligans appeared out of nowhere. […] The heated up hooligans attacked individual participants in the protest, using the only intellectual arguments accessible to them – fists and legs. It is almost a miracle that there were only few injuries. […]

All this was happening under the eyes of a stunningly passive police force, which was obviously not able to cope with the events. So they did the obvious – they turned against the protesters. These are now under investigation for not having provided adequate security to their manifestation. No, this is not some sick joke. It is true. […]

The blog Kanalizacija wrote this [mkd]:

Today, a herd of 1000 [Hunzas] didn’t allow us to protest peacefully against the building of the church on the square. They had flags with crosses, icons and posters on which was written “We want temple” and some prayers. Among them there were members of [VMRO-DPMNE], who I know personally.

The people from the Architectonical Faculty, who I joined, were coming from the riverside from the park side. When we arrived at the square the mass started walking towards us, and were whistling and yelling “Uaaa” and “Go to Bakoyanni” [referring to Greek foreign minister Dora Bakoyannis].

If we didn’t escape there was going to be blood! […]

According to the mainstream media, the protests had political background, with the students led by the daughter of the chief of campaign headquarters of SDSM presidential candidate, and on the other side the counter-protesters, who were activists of VMRO-DPMNE.

The Macedonian blogosphere is constantly buzzing about the incident, and almost on every blog post there is a heated debate.

15 comments

  • Peter

    Macedonia should concentrate in building factories for the people to work instead spending the finances on something does not improve peoples lives. Spent money on tourism to get moving and get foreign money into the economy.

  • Jerzy Celichowski

    It’s interesting to see a trend of building large, centrally located and often publicly funded churches all around Eastern Europe. Think of the Belgrade St. Sava church, the church of Christ the Saviour in Moscow, the mosque in the Kremlin in Kazan or the plans for a Church of Divine Providence in Poland, to be co-funded with the state budget, just to give a few examples. All illustrate a growing influence of the dominant/traditional churches over the state.

  • Prof. Francis Wilson

    What the Slav-dominated Skopje administration is trying to do is to use the sweat and blood-soaked tax payer dinars of the Albanian, Moslem and Turkish minorities to propagate a false Macedonian identity using the schismatic Macedonian Orthodox Church as a pillar of its ill thought out propaganda. How can the self-created Macedonian Church and its anti-Christ Archbishop be legitimised without a huge Cathedral? Instead of this waste, let Skopje celebrate the great Slavic roots of its people by returning to the mainstream Orthodox faith and abandoning grandiose and sinful ideas of a false Cathedral at a time when more than a third of the population are unemployed. As a Christian, I find these plans obscene and I’m sure the Moslems and other religious minorities of Skopje feel the same way.

    • Ivan Jovevski

      Prof. Wilson,

      Sometimes it is better to stay silent than to be ridiculous… Please remember this for your future “lectures”.

  • Maja Smilevska

    Professor. Francis Wilson, I resent your attempt to exploit the weaknesses of a young democracy so you can voice your own fascist ideas.

    I am a Macedonian from Macedonia.

    Where are you come from?

  • Peter

    Francis Wilson,how big was the money envelope from the Greeks to make such a absurd comment? Sir, you are not fitt to teach history,because you know none. I did tell you this on another occasion. I feel sorry for those students you attempt to teach.Your teaching is fabricated,you need to read Barnals “Black Athena”. Please, if in fact you are a professor,teach your students true history and not falsified. You see,professors the likes of you are fabricating the whole history and people like your financial supporters are using this kind of history to committ further robery of history that does not belong to them. Shame on you for identifying yourself as a historian.You are not worth a peni!

  • […] decision to use public funds for building a new church in Skopje. “The counter-protest” turned violent, and the police failed to prevent the pro-government mob from thrashing a number of students. In […]

  • […] Here’s my latest Global Voices celebrity profile – this time Elena Ignatova who covers Macedonia on Global Voices, is in charge of Global Voices in Macedonian, and works for the Metamorphosis Foundation, which seeks to seeks to enhance the use of information in Macedonian government and society. Among the posts we mention in the interview are: Macedonia: Use Facebook If You Want to Flirt With Politicians, The Balkans: “Whose Is This Song?”, and Macedonia: Student Protest Ends in Violence. […]

  • […] order to comment on the events of beating up student protesters on a Skopje square a few months […]

  • […] a commento del pestaggio di studenti che protestavano in una piazza di Skopje [in] avvenuto alcuni mesi […]

  • […] skomentowac wydarzenia związane z  pobiciem protestujących studentów na placu w Skopje kilka miesięcy […]

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site