Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Israel: Mourning Mumbai

Israel continues to stand by the victims and survivors of the terror in Mumbai. Awash with deep sympathies, the blogosphere's sentiments speak for themselves in mourning the loss of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg, along with six other Israelis.

Reactions fell into three predominant camps with bloggers asking the questions:

  • What should our response to terrorism and tragedy be?
  • Why were the Jews targeted in this instance?
  • What good can come of this?

Here are their responses.

The Jewish Response to Terrorism and Tragedy–

Holtzbergs, Z\"L (2)

Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg (may their memories be a blessing). Photo sourced from Chabad.org

Rabbi Yonah of Jewlicious writes:

“I am heartbroken. The Jewish world weeps over the brutal murders of Jews, Indians, and others in Mumbai. News of the tragedy spread around the globe in minutes. We are all truly connected.

The response to the tragedy cannot be depression, but hard work. The way for us to avenge the blood of the murdered is to erect pillars of loving kindness and charity.”

Rav Eliyahu of A Dwelling Place for G-D in the Lower Worlds in an entry entitled “The Torah Response to Terrorism” echoes Rabbi Yonah, saying:

“The world is faced with terror all around it – now so, perhaps – more than ever. How should we react? What is the Torah response to terrorism?! …The response is a clear one. Continue to grow! Continue to do good. Do even more good!”

Leiv Esther joins the consensus on the Jewish response to tragedy:

“It is always hard to hear of Jews being hurt in any way. The Jewish response to any difficulty is to increase in our efforts to bring unity amongst Jews and goodness and kindness to the world.”

On an entry entitled “Muslims Mourn Mumbai Massacre,” Daniel Lubetsky points out that for the first time, Islamic nations have publicly condemned this terrorist act. In his Peaceworks blog, he posts:

“…a sample (by no means exhaustive) compilation of some of the Arab and Muslim nations and organizations across the world – from Saudi Arabia to the Arab League – who condemned the tragic and barbaric terrorist acts in Mumbai. Everyone can always do better, but the below can be shared whenever you are asked “Why are Muslims not condemning terrorism?”

Even blogs devoted to unrelated themes join in. Israeli Kitchen blogs:

“A candle for the victims of the Mumbai massacre. May G-d comfort their families and avenge their spilled blood.”

Jew in India (sourced from Chabad.org)
A Jewish man saying prayers in India. Photo sourced from Chabad.org

Why Jews Were Targeted

In a post analyzing why Jews (who were by coincidence also Israeli) were specifically targeted, Israellycool establishes a thesis that the terrorists’ goal is to “establish a global Islamic Caliphate and impose Sharia law on societies currently based on Judeo-Christian principles.” He writes:

“It is no coincidence that the terrorists target Jews. Evil will always target Jews because we represent G-d in the world. It was true with the Nazis, and it is true with Islamic terrorism, the new Nazism. We have the task to be a light unto the nations, and even when though we may not always be completely successful, we have not done such a bad job. Especially when you look at the amazing work performed by a Jewish organization such as Chabad.”

In conclusion, he proposes a worldwide war on terrorism by ordinary people asking us to support Israel and all global democracies and promote the message that those who support terrorism will never able to live as free people, self-ruling people in their own state.

Treppenwitz's David Bogner concurs with Israellycool and expands on his argument that Jews were specifically hunted down and killed in the Mumbai massacres. Bogner explains:

“Mumbai is a city of over 18 million people, yet there are only about five thousand Jews living there. And of those, only a few dozen are identifiably Jewish outside of the synagogue.

Heck, the entire country of India – with a staggering population of over 1.1 billion people – has only about 15 thousand Jews! I'm not so good at math, but I think that if you try to express the Jewish population as a percentage of the overall Indian population, you're going to end up with a lot of zeros to the right of the decimal point.

So isn't it weird that nobody seems to be talking about how statistically odd it is that this Muslim terror group sought out and attacked an unremarkable home containing one of India's only identifiably orthodox Jewish families.

Apparently the breaking news from Mumbai has demonstrated anew that targeting Jews is not unusual… even when just finding Jews in India to attack is harder than finding Samoans in Iceland. ”

A Rediff News report quotes the doctors’ reactions to the Jewish hostages murders in a story entitled, “Doctors Shocked at Hostages’ Torture,” writing:

“Of all the bodies, the Israeli victims bore the maximum torture marks. It was clear that they were killed on the 26th itself. It was obvious that they were tied up and tortured before they were killed. It was so bad that I do not want to go over the details even in my head again,” he said.

Corroborating the doctors’ claims about torture was the information that the Intelligence Bureau had about the terror plan. “During his interrogation, Ajmal Kamal said they were specifically asked to target the foreigners, especially the Israelis,” an IB source said.”

Jameel of The Muqata expresses his anger at Israel for their criticism of Indian security's slow response.

“Hypocrisy rules in Israel today as IDF [Israel Defense Forces] soldier Gilad Shalit remains a hostage in Gaza — a terrorist state created by Israel, and Israel's only stated way of freeing him, is the release of hundreds of murderous terrorists…

Yet my anger at Israel is displaced only by my sorrow and condolences for the families of the Jews murdered in Mumbai this past week.”

Chabad House sign in Hebrew (sourced from Chabad.org) Indian Chabad House sign in Hebrew and English. Photo sourced from Chabad.org

Where Do We Go From Here?–

In our blackest moments, we ask ourselves, “Where do we go from here? What good can come of this?” There is no one answer– we must grieve and learn from it in our own ways– but Israeli bloggers have some suggestions.

Of like minds, both This is Israel and Jewlicious’ CK post entries headed, “We Are All Chabad” and “We Are All Chabadniks,” commenting on how events such as these unite us as a worldwide Jewish family.

Yael of Aliyah! Step-By-Step reflects that for the first time since she was a child, the terror in Mumbai stirred her to fully celebrate Shabbat, the Jewish Sabbath:

“It just really felt to me like the right thing to do, the best way to honour their memory and all the other lives lost, criminally lost. In large part because by celebrating Shabbat as a Jew I was carrying on one of the very things the terrorists were fighting to wipe out. By celebrating Shabbat, which is symbolically in essence the celebration of the miracle of life and love and goodness and commitment for a better future, it is absolute defiance and rejection and maybe a tiny countering of the evil that so obviously exists in this world.”

And in “A Light In To the Darkness,” Israellycool reminds us that: “When the world was witness to the worst of humanity, it was also witness to the best,” citing the rescue of the Holtzberg's two-year old son by his Indian nanny, Sandra Samuel, who saved him at the last possible moment.

(Samuel returned with the family to Israel today, where the Israeli government is considering bestowing upon her the title of “Righteous Gentile,” one of the nation's highest awards that is given to those who risk their own lives to save Jewish ones.)

xxx
Indian-Israeli unity flag. Photo sourced from Facebook's Israel Condolence Book for the Terror Victims of India.

How We Can Help–

So how can we help? Chabad has established the Chabad of Mumbai Relief Fund to aid with the reconstruction of the Chabad center there and help support the Holtzberg's young child. The Jewish Agency of Israel will also help the families of those lost through the Fund for the Victims of Terror.

Let us remember the names of those who perished in the Chabad House last week and they shall represent our mourning for all the victims of Mumbai. May their memories serve as a blessing and a lesson to us all.

(Alternate spellings may be due to the transliteration of the names from Hebrew to English. Further names are pending release.)

Lastly, in a section of their website called, “What Can I Do?” Chabad urges us to honor the memories of those lost by committing to do mitzvot (good deeds) in their name. Over 950 have been pledged so far.

Further Reading–

This article is a continuation of “Israel: Sending Help and Sympathy to Mumbai” and is part of Global Voices Online's ongoing coverage of the Terror in Mumbai.

7 comments

  • Chris

    First of all I would like to offer my deepest condolences to all the Jewish victims of the Mumbai massacre. Being an Indian myself, I was particularly angry at seeing Jews being targeted in Mumbai, a cosmopolitan city. My heart weeps for the Jews and ALSO for the other 180 odd people that were massacred, including Indians and other foreign nationals. Being an Indian, I identify with the struggle of the Jewish state and its struggle against Islamic terrorism. We are also victims. So please help us to help you. Most Indians love Israel and will always stand by Israel, and your country did so when we went through the Kargil War in 1999. However, I do have a message for some of the people here. It seems like they have ‘conveniently’ ignored the fact that 180 ‘other’ people have died in India. Including many many Indians and others, including Americans, British, Chinese, e.t.c. So please do not leave them out when you are talking about his massacre as we were the victims of this as much as you were.
    God Bless India and God Bless Israel.

  • Chris, what a beautiful comment. Thank you for posting it.

    I’m sorry if you think that I didn’t emphasize the scale of the tragedy fully enough for all involved and affected. For a nation of only 6 million people with a brutal history of violence against us, we take every loss personally and feel it deeply. As I had hoped to convey in this article and my previous one (linked above), Israelis are identifying closely with Indians and sending help as we are able.

    Global Voices has been actively reporting on the incident from all over the world, but most particularly from India. A link to the full coverage is here (and linked above): http://globalvoicesonline.org/specialcoverage/mumbai-india-blasts-2008/.

    In solidarity & friendship,

    ~ Maya

  • Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg were in India providing solace and a place of peace for all Jewish people. These terrorist animals were in India to provide death and suffering. I ask you, who are the true believers in their faith?

  • Chris

    Maya, I only hope that we(Indians) will now value the life of our citizen and much as the state of Israel does.
    My family, including me were absolutely saddened at the images of Baby Moshe crying at his parents funeral. It is amazing though, that the perpertrators of this cowardly act will now roam freely in Pakistan and enjoy full state patronage. Where is the justics?

  • esther

    We are saddened that the Jewish families held hostage could not be saved we were hoping against hope but they were killed by the terrorists. My heart goes out to little Moshe his tears brought tears to our eyes. He will always remain in our prayers. His nanny was really brave she saved his life. The terrorists have no religion they are just demons and have lost all human feelings. They have killed one and all whether it was a Jew a Muslim a Hindu hardly mattered to them they were blood thirsty plunderers who came and killed blindly. No religion teaches violence it is how a person interprets religion and makes it suit his purpose. These terrorists have done the same thing used religion to commit dastardly acts. We pray that may such people see light and reform themselves and make this world a peaceful place to live in.

  • Syed Abdullah

    Dear Friends.
    It is all very much disappointed whenever a person dies, killed without any reason.His or her childeren have to cry on the bodies of their beloved. Please do not hate anyone whether they are jews, hindues, muslim,christians.
    This world need again Gandhi, Martin Luthar king, Tolstoy,Rumi to make this world again. The person who kills anyone has no religion. Please understand that now the religion is the escape goat. Muslims killing jews, jews killing muslims, hindu- muslims, all is not religion its all politics. war of resources, controls, these wars are not to make the whole world as muslim or whole world as jews. Or hindues would like to kill all muslims. This is just politics and propaganda war. Please all of us understand it. When we see a little jewish baby crying we cry . When we see a hindu father crying over the murder of his son we should cry. When we see mulsim women are crying we should cry. We are not here to impose our beleifs on others. Let everyone live his/her life as it suits. Hatred will generate more hatred as Budhha says. please, we should not be toys in the hands of politicians. We need back our Gandhi, MLK, Rumi to rebuild this world.

    Hope my message will reach as a message for peace and its not new.

  • rahul singh

    i love israel.india and israel are best friends

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.