Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Thailand/Cambodia: Conflict over Preah Vihear Temple (Part II)

Who owns the historic Preah Vihear Temple – Cambodia or Thailand? Both countries are asserting ownership rights over the temple which led to a border clash last week. Several soldiers were killed and wounded during the fighting.

Both countries have since then agreed to talk. But the problem is far from resolved. Thailand is prepared to evacuate its citizens from Cambodia. Villagers on the Cambodian side of the disputed territory are fleeing. Their livelihoods have been affected. Thai companies in Cambodia are worried too.

What is the root of the conflict? It is definitely more than just a desire to own four square kilometers of land. Protest actions against Thailand’s government are still continuing. Is the Preah Vihear controversy a tactic to “divert attention (of Thai citizens) in times of troubles”?

Many of Thailand’s problems today are blamed on ousted Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra. What is his role in the Preah Vihear issue? Apparently, he has business interests in Cambodia. PAD's Facts Info reports:

“Former Thai Prime Minister and business tycoon Thaksin Shinawatra has recently signed an official deal with Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen to allegedly develop the Cambodia’s south-western maritime province of Koh Kong. Thaksin wants to secure very convenient Cambodian-based facilities to prepare his political power comeback in Thailand. The current tension between Cambodia and Thailand about Preah Vihear temple is in part due to false assurances given by Thaksin to Hun Sen in the past about border delineation.”

The writer also adds that the Preah Vihear dispute will affect future discussions on other border issues between Thailand and Cambodia:

“But neither of the countries can afford to lose any of this land. This is not only because the area carries with it the issue of territorial sovereignty, which no modern state can bear to lose, but also because the final fate of the area could signify the future of other overlapping areas still to be demarcated, particularly those in the sea.”

The Preah Vihear fighting may also be about a struggle for the oil and gas reserves in the Gulf of Thailand. Brendan Brady and Thet Sambath explain:

“Thailand and Cambodia both assert claims over some 27,000 square kilometres of disputed maritime territory in the Gulf of Thailand that is believed to contain significant amounts of oil and gas reserves.

“The expanse of water known as the Overlapping Claims Area has been the source of a contentious, decades-old dispute with Thailand but has gained a new imperative amidst the current border crisis.

“Since the border dispute erupted, suspicions have intensified that by asserting control over Preah Vihear, Cambodia is angling to improve its claims over the disputed offshore block.”

Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen is also using the Preah Vihear issue to ask for more military funds. And the renewed conflict between the two countries fits into Hun Sen’s “development objectives” for Preah Vihear.

What are the reactions of several Thailand-based bloggers? Gnarly Kitty reacts:

“WTF? A war? Over a land? In 21st Century? Two guys were killed already. That's it. We're reverting.”

A mosaic through my eyes, a foreign student, observes:

“Thai nationalists are burning over the border with Cambodia. Thailand is doing what it can to prevent a ‘loss of face’ to Cambodia.”

Chinesethai leaves a comment in the blog of Thailand Crisis. The reader criticizes the Thai army:

“I think army leadership is also important. You can see that each conflict involves not only gunfire but also information war. While the Cambodian officials give numerous interviews almost on an hourly basis to foreign presses, we rarely hear anything from the Thai army. All we learn is from the media.”

The Nation's State blames “dangerous racist nationalism”:

“Nationalism is a poison. It might not have always been so as nations across Southeast Asia fought off the yoke of colonial oppression by harnessing the power of nationalism.

“But it is a poison now that has reached such critical mass in Thailand that issues like the border conflict over Preah Vihear with Cambodia and the festering southern insurgency are perpetuated by Thai nationalism.

“Essentially, close minded nationalists have prevented rational discourse on what Thailand is and who it represents to such an extent that the ability of the country to deal with conflict – like Phreah Vihear and the southern Insurgency – in a rational way is severely challenged.”

The blogger also mentions the strengths and limitation of international law to resolve the conflict:

“What remains as a salient indicator of adherence to international law is that Thailand, with its vastly larger and technologically superior army, has not simply annexed the temple during this latest confrontation. There are certainly other mitigating factors, such as trade and tourism disruptions, that might make Cambodia and Thailand reluctant to engage in armed conflict yet international law’s calming influence and dispute mechanisms are not just working to ease the conflict but defining the very parameters of the argument. The true test though will not only be to see if armed conflict can be avoided but will be to see a lasting resolution that will prevent future conflict between the two sovereign nations.”

24 comments

  • Jeyjomnou

    Talking about who own the 900 years old Preah Vihea Temple, you ought to start from who built the Temple? and who owned the all Temples including Ankor Watt? In the Ankor Era the Khmer Empire had the Vast land. And every body was living together, but the Notorious one started war against its own kind acting like a crocodile. And until todays they are still ambitious invading the othes.

  • Bayon

    It is very clear that Thai opposition uses Preah Vihear to gain credit among ignorant compatriots in helping them overthrowing the ruling democratically elected government. In return, the government applying the same tactic by heating up border situation near Preah Vihear with Cambodia to divert protestors’s attention which can finally ease their internal issues. Preah Vihear or Cambodia being the victim by both Thai political factions. Thaksin is also part of the game but logically analysis shown that he was ousted not because his investment deal with Cambodia.
    No matter who will win in Thailand, Cambodia remains as a victim. In such situation this country, Cambodia, has to think twice. It won’t be able to benefit anything from this game but the right approach will only help to minimize the impact.
    We will see what will happen next.

    Prum Jorie

  • Chris

    I agree the builder should have rights to it. If Cambodian build the Temple they have intellectual/ownership rights. Then again “pure blood” Thai has numerous similarity to Cambodians cultural, food clothing and physical appearance etc, more than to Lao whom they claim to share common ancestry. So, would that implies Cambodian and Thai share same ancestry and at some point in time deviates some what; thus have same claim to the Temple..lol just a though. AS far as the land goes that’s another story.

  • Sweetly

    It is known that Thailand has a lot of trouble with its neighbours or OTHERWISE. It means that Thailand has been invaded or OTHERWISE. This thing shurely does not end with just Cambodia. The ASEAN or International Community shall see the issue in a broader perspective. If one could look into the historical and political roots of the conflict, one shall be able to get to know Thailand better and better. Because to get to know this country is not as easy as listening to what it has to say. Especially now when different Thais speak different languages.

  • Adisak

    It is true that Thailand has created a lot of troubles to its neighbor countries. It is also known that Thailand has invested a good amount of fund to its education system which is very good. But to inject poison such as modified history for Thai innocent younger generation is a very dangerous game. I agree that different Thais speak different stories even at its government level, which makes Thai people to get confused. The current tension between Cambodia and Thailand about Preah Vihear temple has led some Thai people to turn their back to their Cambodian friends because of the falls information that is broadcasted by the Thai government. Is that healthy? Do the Thais want its young generation to be equipped with wrong stories and anger rather than knowing where originally they came from?

  • […] Who owns the historic Preah Vihear Temple – Cambodia or Thailand? Both countries are asserting ownership rights over the temple which led to a border clash last week. Several soldiers were killed and wounded during the fighting. Both countries have since then agreed to talk. But the problem is far from resolved. [link] […]

  • westerner

    I read a lot of books on history.I know a bit about the history of Cambodia and Thailand.They have very similar culture.All I can say about this Subject who own the ancient Temple.Go to the Library or go online and read for yourself and see.When your reading it,understand the facts first then you can judge for yourself.

  • What languages are written on prasats that scattered all over Southeast Asia? Were they written in Pali, Sanskrit, Khmer or Thai? Obviously Thai did not exist then. Why do the Thais claim a temple that has khmer’s ancient scriptures on?

  • […] recounts the way in which the Thai forced him to go back to Cambodia at Preah Vihear, the site of the current border dispute between the two countries. The Cambodian side of the border was studded with land mines. Listen […]

  • […] border conflictbetween Cambodia and Thailand also sparked comments of Thaksin’s being the link and motivated […]

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site