Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Georgia, Russia: The War's Virtual Dimension

See Global Voices special coverage page on the South Ossetia crisis.

Like most other contemporary conflicts, the ongoing one in Georgia and South Ossetia has had a virtual dimension from its very start. Below are two bloggers’ reflections on the wars raging outside the actual conflict zones.

LJ user basya – Ksenia Basilashvili, journalist with Radio Echo of Moscow and daughter of Russian actor Oleg Basilashviliwrote this (RUS) about her family's origin and the coverage of the war by Russian and Western TV channels:

[…] When I hear [the word “Tskhinval“], I always think about my family's roots, about this faraway land – what should I call it? And I imagine the soil warmed up by the sun, a hot [lavash flatbread] right out of the oven, red pungent homemade wine… I think of how my humble grandfather packed and left for Moscow, and how he received education there and ended up heading the [College of Communications]. […]

I'm watching [the Russian state-owned RTR‘s Vesti news show and Channel 1]. The dead, the injured, refugees, ruined buildings, pale children and old people in the basements.

I'm watching BBC and CNN – the dead, the injured, refugees, ruined buildings, pale children and old people in the basements.

Death and misery.

There is no difference between the pictures. Only [the former] are showing Tskhinval, and [the latter] are showing [Gori], [the former] are presenting this slaughter of civilians as “the aggression of Georgia against South Ossetia,” while [the latter are presenting it as] “the aggression of Russia against Georgia.” It's as if the TV channels have taken position in the trenches and know for sure what's going on. As if they know who the enemy, the devil, is. For us it's Georgia, for them it's Russia. And the truth is somewhere near…

Would be good to mix CNN and Vesti in one glass, it would make a great news channel, with the views of two, three, four sides [of the conflict].

I don't want to discuss here why they were at one point giving out [Russian passports to South Ossetians], who was the first one to start it all, who gave the orders, who is guilty. Who are the good ones and the bad ones.

Now it does not matter at all anymore. Because while the political and informational wars are taking place, over there – in South Ossetia, in Georgia – people are dying and suffering. […]

Here's one of the comments (RUS) to this post:

homo_loquens:

Ksenia, please tell me, have you spent more than five minutes watching CNN and BBC? Haven't you seen a BBC interview with [Russia's foreign affairs minister Sergei Lavrov] and a CNN interview with [Vitaly Churkin, Russia's ambassador to the UN], and regular live reports from Moscow on the position of [PM Vladimir Putin and president Dmitry Medvedev] on both channels? […] Because you are not the first one of those who seem normal and bright to me, who are writing this, and I'm already beginning to wonder if I'm perhaps hallucinating – or do I have some different CNN and BBC broadcasting at my home?

LJ user pepsikolka – Samira Kuznetsova, a resident of [Poti], whose other posts have been featured on Global Voices here and herewrote this (RUS) about her recent experience at the Russian-language social networking portal, Odnoklassniki.ru (“Classmates”):

There used to be a nice, peaceful, kind group at Odnoklassniki.ru site, [devoted to the city of Poti]. Tengo and I were posting lots of pictures there, and others weren't lazy, too. We interacted, joked, shared memories of the past. There was not a single day that I didn't write something in this group.

We were united by our city. Some people still live in it, for others it's the city of their childhood, where they spent their happiest years […].

I was taking a special pleasure in [photographing] a window on the third floor of the “jeans house,” the so-called Pentagon neighborhood, a willow tree on the Rioni river and the old swimming pool in our school's courtyard.

Adult people were happy as kids.

- Here, here I used to walk with my girlfriend.
– And here we used to go fishing.
– And on this bench we played lotto.
– Oy, here's my window, I used to sit for hours in front of it, waiting for mama to return from work.
– Samira, take a picture of this and that.
– Oy, the Pioneers’ House and a puddle as big as 20 years years ago.

Now there is war at this forum. A wall of misunderstanding, reproaches, accusations, abuse, and people are deserting it like refugees. Today, an acquaintance of mine has written me to say that she's leaving the group. As if there was no love and nostalgia yesterday. Today it's a battlefield.

[…]

My former neighbor is screaming that we are NATO's servants. And she hates us for that.

And she used to teach me to play the piano. […]

10 comments

  • Dar

    Thank you, Ksenia, for writing your account of what’s happening. In USA we only see what the BBC shows us, and it is good to hear your view in order to have an accurate understanding of the terror there. My hope is that the suffering will end soon, but when government wants they can fool the people with half-truths in order to pursue their goals, which is usually money or power.

  • Maconald

    This is the worse form of communication. Blaming people as “NATO member”, “Russian”, “American puppet” is nothing helping the humanitarian crisis.

    Respect each other for the right to hold their conscience. USA is not retarded nation and so do Russia.

    But I still insist in truth: Where is the genocide in Tskhinvali? How Tskhinvali is razed? The is humanitarian crisis but there is no genocide.

    http://www.alertnet.org/thenews/newsdesk/LD435290.htm

  • […] at the end of the day, as as “The Wars virtual dimension” said: while the political and informational wars are taking place, over there – in South […]

  • It is hard for me to realize what started this whole mess. Supposedly the Georgians invaded South Ossentia. However, I don’t know if it is true. Was this an accusation by the Russian government or are there real facts?

    If this was a real invasion, then Russia had the right to protect its loyalists in South Ossentia.

    Mind you, I am not in love with Russia’s democratization of its nation. This is a return to totalitarianism of some type. However, we can’t overlook a country’s right to protect its people in a disputed land.

    Please help me understand what really happened. I am afraid that living in America, I might only get the pro-democratic viewpoint. Thanks. P.L.

  • excuse me, de-democratization.

  • Maconald

    Phil L,

    It is hard to tell who is invading who. South Ossetia has killed Georgian peacekeepers before the war. South Ossetia is killing Georgian civilian before the war. Georgian is also kill South Ossetia solider/terrorist (depends on you stance) before the war.

  • AnnaM

    Phil L, I also found interesting an article posted on http://inthefield.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/13/russian-might-dampens-georgian-ambitions/
    Well written and unbiased, I was very surprised finding it on CNN.
    Some comments are worth to read also.

  • GEORGIAN TERRITORIES
    BOMBED BY RUSSIAN JETS
    (PHOTOS)

    http://www.georgia.inf.ge/

  • RBG

    Russia-vs-Georgia – new website.
    There is a voting and a lot of comments about war in South Osetia

    http://www.russia-vs-georgia.com/

  • Dena Liles

    I understand that their are a lot of people with Russian citizenship in South Ossetia which is part of Georgia. They want to break away from Georgia, but is this not a Georgian problem within itself? Russia should not be involved anymore than the US should be involved in Iraq’s different groups. By-the-way I don’t and have never supported Bush in the war with Iraq!

    And no if you don’t have a computer, your in the dark in this world. Why do you think the military action started on 8-8-08 because Russia knew the Olympics would have the world’s attention. Now we have a innocents killed, a humanitarian worsening crises. And for what? To bolster the Russian ego.

    I’m German American; I certainly don’t expect Germany to come to my aid here in the United States. Diplomatically that would be okay, but not militarily. If Russia wants to save people with Russian passports, then negotiate with the Georgian government for their freedom and take them into Russia and help them there.

    Did the Russian’s look at everybody’s passports before they fired? Now we have another humanitarian crisis in this world. I have to admit that this makes no sense to me, but maybe that’s because it is “senseless!”

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site