Free Speech Roundup: Indonesia, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Yemen

In this roundup: (1) Indonesia blocks YouTube over “Fitna” the movie. (2) Saudi Arabia: Fouad Alfarhan's blog and Freefouad blocked. (3) Slide blocked in Turkey. (4) Yemen blocks Maktoob blogging platform.

1. Indonesia blocks YouTube over “Fitna” the movie

The Indonesian government has ordered the country’s internet service providers to block YouTube for publishing the 15-minute anti-Muslim film “Fitna”, made by Dutch MP Geert Wilders, leader of the anti-immigration Freedom Party (PVV). Some of the country's ISPs followed the block order, but “Fitna” could still be viewed through other providers.

“A letter was sent to Internet providers asking them to block any site or blog posting the film Fitna (…) Not only YouTube has uploaded the film, so it is up to the ISPs’ discretion to block these sites,” a Communications and Information Ministry Official is quoted as saying.

Earlier this week, Indonesia had threatened to block YouTube unless the video-sharing web site removed the aforementioned movie.

2. Saudi Arabia: Fouad Alfarhan's blog and Freefouad blocked

The blog of the detained Saudi blogger Fouad Alfarhan was blocked today in Saudi Arabia, along with the Free Fouad website, which is dedicated to Alfarhan's case, and the pro-reformist blog Freedoms. Users trying to access these blogs from Saudi Arabia were met with a notice saying “Blocked URL. Dear User, Sorry, the requested page is unavailable. If you believe the requested page should not be blocked please click here. For more information about internet service in Saudi Arabia, please click here:“.

Alfarhan’s blog blocked

115 days after his arrest, on 10 December 2007, Fouad Alfarhan remains jailed for unspecified “violation of non-security regulations.” On March 11th, 2008, Alfarhan's nine-year old daughter, Raghad, released a YouTube video message for her father saying: “Daddy I miss you. When are you coming back home?”

3. Slide blocked in Turkey

Silde A Turkish court banned access to Slide, the maker of social networking widgets, for “harboring pictures and articles that are considered to be insulting to Ataturk.”

In a note to Slide users in Turkey, Slide announced that it has contacted the Turkish government in the hope of resolving the issue via that route:

If you use Slide in Turkey, you've probably noticed that you are no longer able to access the Slide website or our applications (you may not even be able to access this post). The Turkish government has accused Slide of “harboring pictures and articles that are considered to be insulting to Ataturk,” founder of the republic.

We have contacted the government of Turkey in an effort to resolve this situation and will keep you updated on any changes. In the meantime, we're trying our best to enable Turkish citizens to access our website and applications again.

According to Slide statistics, Slide widgets are being viewed by more than 143 million unique viewers every month in more than 200 countries on websites like Facebook, MySpace, Hi5, Orkut, and Blogger.

4. Yemen blocks Maktoob blogging platform

Yemen blocks Maktoobblog, one of the most popular Arab blogging platform, was recently blocked in Yemen, cutting off Yemeni Internet users from the more than 46,960 blogs the service hosts. According to MaktoobBlog, there are currently 1,226 Yemeni blogs hosted by the service. All of them disappeared from the Yemeni Internet.

On the pan-Arabic Al Hayat newspaper, Mr. Yasser Al-Eimad, from the Public Telecommunication Corporation, denied that was blocked. But the OpenNet Initiative testing confirmed yesterday, after technical investigation, that the blog hosting service was blocked by Yemennet ISP, a service of the government's Public Telecommunication Corporation (PTC):

ONI technical investigation verified that the service has been blocked by Yemennet, Yemen’s government-run ISP. Access is blocked to the entire domain, effectively to every blog hosted by the service. Interestingly, users who attempt to access the site receive a network error message instead of the standard blockpage, which is served when users attempt to access sexual content.

This significant blocking is expected to hinder Internet users in Yemen from blogging and reading blogs because is home of one of the largest blogging communities in the Middle East and North Africa.


  • Kaw

    Another issue that deserves attention in Yemen is the blocking of

    The admin of the site wrote the following:
    “This week, the government’s Minister of Information threatened to file lawsuits against news websites on the justification of ‘inciting hatred’ or ‘harming national interests’ and the other usual excused they often use to prosecute journalists. The threat is even more severe for websites because the government would use the penal code instead of the press law. This means that website owners could get up to death penalties.”

    More here:

  • Tarek Ali

    In fact, I feel quite enthusiastic of the detaining campaign conducted by the Saudi-Arabian government on bloggers. That means that the intellectual people (bloggers) are harassing the dictating regime which has been long disguising itself under the mantel of Islam. The question, I have been asking myself is that what Islam they have been enforcing on people? Is this Islam to seize other’s way of thinking? Is this Islam to deprive people of expressing viewpoints? Is this Islam to take state decisions without consulting the mass of people? Is this Islam to capture people only that they say their opinions frankly? Is this Islam to ban other’s ideology even if it is different from you? Finally, I could come up with satisfactory answer that is our Arabic presidents are our curse. And this is not an outcome of only few years or even decades but it is a result of many centuries in which the Islam was used as a tool to maintain iron grip on the mass of people. Our Islam was quite manipulated in such a way that it controls people’s minds. That has resulted in changing our set of mind to be only sheep that listen and obey, that go wherever the leader goes. Then, I would be more than honoured to be any one else other than that incapable Muslim. We have wonderful religion but it should be re-contextualised from new and be far from any political interests. All my prayers to you, AlFarahan. God bless you.

  • Pazu

    I’m surprised that you don’t even mention China.

  • @ am Pazu

    China has been covered by our Chinese language editor John kennedy, here and here.

  • […] Beitrag erschien zuerst auf Global Voices. Die Übersetzung erfolgte durch Malgorzata Porzezynska, Teil des “Project Lingua“. […]

  • […] Saudi Authorities have banned Fouad’s blog. Free Fouad sites. Just like they would ban any lowlife porn […]

  • […] ein deutsches Medienblog, Readers Edition, hat etwas zum Thema, übersetzt von einem Beitrag in Global Voices […]

  • Its no surprise that the Dictator Saleh of Yemen has cut off internet services. Freedom of information and knowledge are a dictators worse enemy.
    But yet two american administrations have helped to keep this creep in power.

  • We try and keep track of some of this on our blog Broadcasters of Tomorrow. As journalism students we admire everyone’s attempts to express themselves in intelligent and thoughful ways.
    Internet filters and blocks won’t do much to stop people from expressing themselves. The strong and resourceful voices manage to be heard.

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »


  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.