Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Arabeyes: Sad for Bhutto

News of the murder of former Pakistani Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto was received with shock across the Middle East.

Bahrain:

From Bahrain, blogger Mahmood Al Yousif sends his condolences to the people of Pakistan.

“My condolences to the Pakistani people for her loss and its barbaric method. When all that is left is the law of force and terrorism to get your point of view across, you have already lost the cause. Peace-loving human beings should be unequivocal in their condemnation of terrorist acts. Because if things are left as they are, and violence is simply condoned, then we can rest assured that we and those we love will soon be in the cross-fire,” he writes.

Saudi Arabia:

Saudi blogger Rasheed Abou-Alsamh was also saddened by Bhutto's loss. He wrote:

I was shocked and saddened. I had always been a supporter of Benazir and of the whole Bhutto family. To me they, and the Pakistani People’s Party that Benazir’s father the late Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto founded in 1967, represented progressive and secular ideals that would help propel Pakistan from the ranks of dysfunctional Third World countries to that of developing nations that were successful such as Brazil and Malaysia.

The blogger and journalist then links to an interview he conducted with Bhutto's brother, Murtaza, who was also assassinated in Pakistan.

Qatar:

In Qatar, Abdulrahman Warsame links between the brutality of her murder and the violent situation in Pakistan. He explains:

The barbaric nature of her murder shows how deeply violent Pakistan has become; the government blames Alqaeda and Taliban, that was expected!. But it couldn't have been the government; this was a huge blow to Parvez Musharraf who wanted the elections to go ahead peacefully, to gain some legitimacy, and Bhutto was the most suitable candidate to rebuild his image in the West. But now that she's gone, he's stuck with his arch-rival Nawaz Sharif.

No one knows how things will turn out in Pakistan after the elections now that the government has decided not to postpone them, but the political turmoil is set to continue as long as Musharraf is in control.

UAE:

Seabee, who lives in Dubai, finds Bhutto's murder pointless. He writes:

On reflection I suppose it really wasn't a surprise that Benazir Bhutto was murdered. In fact she talked of the danger herself several times recently.

Plus the ‘collateral damage’ of others killed and injured as a result of the attack on her. And make no mistake, there will be even more deaths in the coming days and weeks as a result of this.

What an appalling comment on where we are as human beings. Tens of thousands of years of evolution and we're mentally still in the Stone Age, brainless, the worst animals on the planet.

Israel:

For Israeli Nissim Dahan, who lives in the US, Bhutto's murder reminded him of “the sense of hopelessness that permeates much of the world.” He further continues:

I am not a student of Pakistan’s history. And I have been made to understand, of late, that in the past, Mrs. Bhutto represented a mixed bag with respect to the aspirations of her people. Yes, there are persistent charges of corruption, and accusations that she supported the Taliban. But I can’t believe that her legacy will be defined only by her negatives.

There are several things to consider when we seek to judge her. She was a woman who defied the odds and was twice elected to lead a country that was not predisposed to elect her. Yes, she was driven out on charges of corruption, but, and this should not be underestimated, she chose to come back home. She was not naïve. She knew she faced a grave threat to her personal safety, a point that was driven home when she just arrived. And yet she chose to come back to compete in the political arena. Could blind ambition, alone, explain that? I think not. There must have been some noble aspiration on her part that compelled her to take the risk. Perhaps she learned from past mistakes and wanted to set things right? We can only guess.

4 comments

  • Fasih Ali Khan

    I Thank You All as a Pakistani on behalf of my people for the condolances you have forwarded to us. I personally being opponant of Benazir Bhutto’s policies still felt deep sorrow on the way she was murdered, and believe every person in the world who knew her felt the same. Now we can Only pray that God Almighty bless her soul and forgive her sins and grant patience to her childern.
    I Thank You All Again. God Bless.

  • Sharjeel Ahsan

    Benazir Bhutto’s assassination is highly condemnable and I am very sad on this. But I am even more concerned on how Pakistan is being targeted these days by these suicide bombers. I am not sure from where on earth all these suicide bombers have arrived. I am not sure how these extremist bombers are being brain washed to do so. Of course their actions are not remotely associated with Islam’s teachings, it is a real shame to associate the name of the most peaceful religion ‘Islam’ with the acts of these extremists and terrorists. I don’t know why Government is not launching any campaign to teach or preach people living in tribal areas about how much these suicide acts of killing innocent people are against the basic Islamic teachings.

  • ibrahim andu

    Hello, this is response to the israeli who said ‘Could blind ambition, alone explain that? i.e her determination to rule her people,being elected as PM twice, and I tell you it certainly can. It’s easy to seesshtivated by power and maybe some more wealth. And in a country such as Pakistan,a woman desiring to rule seems unjust and imposing on the people of Pakistan, as it is an Islamic country, where there are available religious texts opposing such. Yet she didn’t care. And that is what bothers me the most. People with such attitude toward relgion. And I’m notsaying there are saints, I am saying you don’t bash religion in the face in the name of development which to people is westernisation and it is not. It is simply econnomic development where there is alot of output. And what with her scarf that never covered her hair completely? And her son trying hold a signifant party position? Yeah Yeah, PAKISTAN! MY PAKISTAN!. Given she was killed by people with wrong views.

  • jaanewaqas

    I spent the last 3 months in Pakistan, and all I understood was that zardari, also known as mr. 10%, has been a fraudulent, dirty person, been in prison (?), had a case filed against him in some european country, and in fact it is HE who is responsible for the death of Benazir, as he was for the death of her brother, years before her. I don’t see democracy in the bhutto rule… her son, with no experience, no knowledge, or understanding, no sympathy with the people of Pakistan was appointed as leader of the political party that won the elections, possibly out of pity for the death of Benazir. What did she do for the women of pakistan? they are still swallowed by their miserable lives, poverty, illiteracy. what did she do for the economy? or for education of the nation’s children as a whole? All i see is pollution, poverty, and a constant fear for one’s safety. The night I left Pakistan, there were gunshots across an area of Karachi, my husband was in the midst of it. Allegedly, PPP is attempting to put the MQM party against the Afghani refugees, in order to increase its strong hold. What’s going on? Divide and Conquer? or just plain destruction?

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site