Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

UAE: Justice for Alex

While sexual abuse and rape cases are usually brushed under the carpet in Arab countries and hidden from the prying eyes of local and global media, a recent case to grab the international headlines is making its way back to the UAE blogosphere.
It is the unsettling story of a 15-year-old French boy, Alexandre Robert, who was kidnapped and gang raped in Dubai. What is more alarming is that one of the three suspected rapists tested positive for the deadly HIV Aids virus in 2003.

The UAE Community Blog linked to the story and published excerpts from it, generating criticism from readers.

“Dubai looks good on the outside but still living in the dark ages on the inside.
Westerners should stay out of there until they modernize their justice system. That poor boy was brutalized and the doctor acted like a savage, too. What most people don't know is that to those dark age Muslims, kafir (infidel), like women, are fair game,” comments reader Criminals in Dubai.

Another reader, who signed off as Anonymous, shrugged off the case, saying justice would not be met. He writes:

If there was such thing as justice, then alcoholics and drug dealers should be the 1st ones in line to be executed for causing alot more trouble on the streets and night clubs.
– Indians/Asians will be the 1st target followed by east Europeans/Africans then comes the other trash (White/Local etc…)
This case will be dismissed like any other, why even bother to post this story while we all know nothing's gonna happen.

Another anonymous reader sends a wake up call for Dubai, saying:

Wake up Dubai, if the UAE want to be on the top or the best in everything; it should start with the basics first (education, health, justice)…then it may consider building the highest towers and the biggest malls.

On the other hand, Bahraini blogger Ammaro said the case shouldn't be used to tarnish Dubai's reputation.

“As much as it is a horrible act,this incident should not be used as a stereotype or a generality to describe Dubai, because the local culture is very respectfull and descent. However, people are very angry at this incident,including me and something should be done to those criminals.Don't forget UAE is still concidered one of the safest places in the world,” he said.

Rosh echoes similar sentiments. He writes:

“It's very unfortunate this has happened. Please don't confuse Dubai or UAE with actions of 3 perverts.
All said , it is amongst the safest places on earth – and whatever people say of human rights – safety is it's most valued commodity. It's not perfect however, it's much better than many places and have miles to go to achieve equality, transparency and justice for all (which I personally don't think exist in any nation today, in it's truest form)
I pray the 15yr old does not develop HIV. Please say a prayer for him, and let justice take it's course.”

Alexandre's mother is also taking her son's struggle online and has launched a site dedicated for the case, in English and French.

In her introduction to the site, Veronique Robert, writes:

I dedicate this website to all the children of the world whose wounds were never recognized, their words never heard and their suffering never known.
I dedicate this web site to all the mothers of the world even the ones of my son's aggressors.
To all the Pakistani, Filipino, and Indian mothers who were expelled from Dubai to their countries of origin with their little children, wounded in their hearts, flesh and minds.
This web site is open to all the mothers of the world united in the same Combat.
Tears have no identity, no religion. We must unite so when tears run, it will no longer be in loneliness but in front of the whole world’s eyes , with many hands to wipe them.

Ms Robert also calls upon the authorities in Dubai to immediately implement the following procedures to protect children caught up in similar situations:

We therefore request from the authorities of Dubai the creation of:
* Reception facilities within the police force for minors victims of rape, be they boys or girls.
* Recognition of their status of victims
* The immediate taking of precautionary measures, after a rape, against all types of infectious illness and sexually transmissible diseases (AIDS, Hepatitis, MST) with adequate means such as trithérapy, etc…
* Psychological Follow-up for as long as it is needed.

Otherwise, she is encouraging readers to boycott Dubai.

Until these elementary measures have become law in the super rich
Emirate of Dubai, we kindly request you to join the support group called www. boycottdubai.com
With your determination and your support, the children victims of rape shall learn again to live a normal life, restructuring themselves physically and morally. Hopefully to smile at life again,” notes Ms Robert.

The site's support page has had more than 4,300 comments on it so far.

The case is currently being heard in a Dubai court, where Alexandre testified earlier today.

4 comments

  • […] a nightmare, when three men kidnapped and raped him before leaving his body behind a local hotel. Fifteen-year-old Alexandre Robert recently testified against two of the three Emirati men that raped… The third suspect is expected to be tried in juvenile courts. His mother, V’eronique Robert has […]

  • anonymous

    How can the Emirates stop being homophobic hypocritcal perverts, if their own ruling royal family sexually assaults people and tries to get away with it?

    Read below!!!!! (from Guardian UK)
    _________________________________________
    UAE sheikh to stand trial for ‘sexually motivated’ assault

    David Pallister
    Wednesday October 31, 2007
    Guardian Unlimited

    The brother of the ruler of the United Arab Emirates, one of the richest men in the world, is to stand trial in Switzerland for an alleged assault on an Italian-American businessman in the bar of an exclusive Geneva hotel.
    Swiss prosecutor Daniel Zappelli has confirmed that 37-year-old Sheikh Falah bin Zayed bin Sultan al-Nahyan will be tried on charges of assaulting Silvano Orsi with a belt in the La Reserve hotel four years ago.

    Article continues

    ——————————————————————————–

    ——————————————————————————–
    Mr Orsi, 39, claims that he was repeatedly attacked after refusing homosexual advances from the sheikh and has since been unable to work because of his injuries. The sheikh, in evidence to a pre-trial closed hearing last year, claimed that he merely had a 30-second scuffle after he was accused of being gay.
    The case will be heard before a three-man tribunal that can impose a sentence of up to two years in prison.

    Mr Orsi, of Rochester, New York, says he was having a late evening drink with a Saudi friend when the sheikh sent over an unsolicited bottle of champagne. It remained unopened on the table and a few minutes later, according to Mr Orsi, the shiekh came over and accosted him. When he resisted, the sheikh attacked him and beat him savagely his belt.

    Despite the sheikh’s bodyguards trying to intervene Mr Orsi says the assault continued as he retreated to the reservation desk. He says he sustained a herniated disc, nerve damage in his right leg and post-traumatic stress disorder. Before he left the hotel, Mr Orsi says, the Emirate’s consul in Geneva arrived at the hotel and offered him €13,000 to keep quiet.

    At the hearing last year Sheik Fallah admitted that he was annoyed when Mr Orsi refused the champagne but confronted him “after I was called gay,” according to a transcript obtained by The Associated Press.

    The sheik said he and Mr Orsi grabbed and shook each other violently for about 30 seconds before his bodyguards intervened. He said he took off his belt because Mr Orsi was “bigger than me” and “I was just at the very point of striking him with my belt but we were separated”.

  • Usman Sani Bello

    I must say my prayers and sympathy goes to Alex, for what he went through. I am glad that the Government of Dubai have taken actions in bringing the criminals to justice. I really hope that the world would give this nation a chance to see to it that justice is done. However, I am most disappointed with the fact that the mother of the innocent young man wants to sue the ruling family of Dubai, I think it is baseless. It wouldnt make any sense for anyone visiting the USA to sue the preseident of the country if they were treated badly in any way.

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.