Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Ecuador: Immigrant Girl Attacked on Barcelona Train

A 16-year-old Ecuadoran immigrant was sitting alone on the train in Barcelona, when a Spanish citizen who was talking on his phone, proceeded to repeatedly strike the girl for no apparent reason. The images were caught on camera inside the train and brought swift reactions of disgust by bloggers in Ecuador and abroad, as well as caused others to pause and reflect on the status of immigrants in Spain.Christian Espinoza of Cobertura Digital [ES] is saddened by the images, but realizes that the attacker is not representative of all in Spain.

En casa, se nos iban lágrimas de las iras al ver estas imágenes mientras recordábamos el esmero que por naturaleza pone cada ecuatoriano cuando recibimos a cualquier extranjero. Claro, obviamente no son todos como Sergi en España ni en Europa y eso también se refleja en los comentarios de solidaridad en el video y medios locales (en Vanguardia.es hay más de 900 comentarios ante esta verguenza), pero esperamos que esos, los que no son todos, ojalá puedan hacer algo más que ver cómo muere esta noticia.

At home, we cry with anger to see those images, while we remember the care that each Ecuadoran takes when a foreigner visits our own country. Obviously, not all are like Sergi (the attacker) in Spain or Europe and that is also reflected in the messages of solidarity that were written in the comments of the video and in local press (in Vanguardia.es there are more than 900 comments that are against the shameful act), but we hope that they can do something so more than just see the incident goes away.

Andrej Nicolás Hillebrand, a Spanish resident, of Sly Nation [ES] provides a link to the video of the attack and also comes out against the attacker.:

Hay personas que no deberían andar sueltas por el mundo. No puede ser que un hombre adulto pegue a una niña porque le viene en gana, porque la apariencia de ésta no le gusta, porque la supone extranjera. Me da asco ver actos de este tipo, me da asco que una chica, tenga que soportar abusos, golpes y vejaciones como esta por parte de un descerebrado que se cree en el derecho de pegar e insultar a quien cree extraño. Yo diría que esta chica tiene mucho más derecho a estar donde está que un sujeto violento que se debe sentir muy hombretón golpeando a una pobre niña, ese si que no debería de estar aquí, por becerro.

There are people in this world that shouldn't be allowed to be let loose. It can't be that an adult man hits a girl because he felt like it, because he didn't like the way she looked, or because she might have been a foreigner. I am sickened to see this type of incident. I am sickened to see a girl have to withstand abuse and attacks by a mindless person that thinks he has the right to hit and insult someone who he thinks is a foreigner. I would say that this girl has much more of a right to be there than a violent guy that feels macho by hitting a poor girl. He's the one that shouldn't be there.

In the video, another passenger looks the other way and does not react to the unprovoked attack. Gabby Corsales is puzzled by the bystander's inaction [ES]:

Es increíble que ante estas circunstancias no hagamos nada, había otra persona en el metro, era un hombre que si podía ayudar a la menor, pero como muchos dicen, debió estar asustado y se quedo impávido. Las disculpas del agresor no bastan, se deben toman sanciones drásticas contra estos casos de racismo y xenofobia que se viven en España y en muchos otros países.

It is incredible that under these circumstances, that we do not do anything. There was another person on the metro, it was a man that could have helped the minor, but as many have said, he was probably scared and remained helpless. The apologies from the attacker is not enough, there should be drastic punishments against these cases of racism and xenophobia that takes place in Spain and other countries.

Bloggers were quick to react, as was President Rafael Correa. However, Cambiemos Ecuador [ES] doesn't buy the president's concern for the young girl.

Hace pocos dias en Espana, un ciudadano espanol agredio de manera cobarde a una compatriota, cuyo unico pecado era querer mejores dias y poder trabajar en paz. Nuestro querido presidente salio cual madre a socorrer a esta muchacha, a su familia, hizo promesas y hasta amenazo al gobierno Espanol. Que valentia la de nuestro lider, casi hasta parecia de verdad, solo le faltaron las lagrimas y podriamos nominarlo a un OSCAR.

A few days ago in Spain, a Spanish citizen cowardly attacked a fellow Ecuadoran, whose only sin was to want better days and work in peace. Our dear president ran out to save this young girl and her family by making promises including threatening the Spanish government. Our leader is brave, almost as much as to appear real, all that was lacking were tears and he could have been nominated for an OSCAR.

The plight of immigrants in Spain is often a topic of conversation among bloggers. Some like Uhr of Autentico Ecuatoriano [ES] writes that the majority of his countrymen and women are there looking for better opportunities and stands in solidarity with those:

YO estoy con el ser humano (sea español o ecuatoriano) que sabe vivir en paz con los demás a su alrededor, que es trabajador y responsable, que sabe respetar y respetarse y que no comete semejantes actos de barbarie, que solo demuestran una vez más la podredumbre en la que vivimos.

I stand with the individuals (whether he/she is Spanish or Ecuadoran) that knows how to live in peace with those around them, that are hard workers and responsible, that knows how to command respect and show respect, that does not commit acts of savagery that only shows the poor conditions in which we live.

In another post, Uhr implores his fellow Ecuadorans in Spain to respect the local customs of their new homeland, without justifying the treatment by some Spanish citizens.

5 comments

  • jim cowan

    There was a time when Spanish males tested themselves by fighting in the bull-ring. Now it seems one at least has to settle for striking little girls. Throw a cushion at him ! Or something heavier.

  • Aaron

    I wos in fear when I saw the video.But hey Im glad it was taped and published to let the world know.To let people know this is our world today when a nation can crush another liek the US and do as they wish.After 911,after irak after so many things.Apparently there is ignorance in europe about its own history of prejudice seen after the world war2.Im a homosexual and I comprehend these vile acts.Its time the world woke up about how they treat people of latinamerica when I see reports full of hatred in US tely about immigrants,and research concentration camps for them there.How horrid that latinamericas ancestry spain does this…being akin in blood.What can we expect to tell our children about history and humanity.That such a sexist,racist,clasists vile act occurs.Latinamerica needs to be respected and loved as a part of this world..its people and its culture I find the act as vile and horrid.

  • […] los de España: – Girl from Ecuador attacked on train in Barcelona, apparently for racist reasons ( Global Voices , […]

  • kari

    pienso que lo que sucedio en el metro, en España, es obiamente grave, y, personalmente, me siento indignada, no presisamente por el comportamiento del español contra la joven sino por la reaccion de ella ante el agresor, yo se que ella no tenia muchas formas de defenderse pero me molesta que no haya ni siquiera tratado de hacer algo al respecto

  • Xavier

    me parece excelente la reaccion de sr presidente Correa su reaccion ante esa humillacion de esta chica ecuatoriana, pero nosotros en ECUADOR ya estamos acostumbrados a ver como hijos o parientes de familias adineradas en Quito y Guayaquil atropellan con autos a gente del pueblo y no van a las carceles no tinene ningun tipo de sancion hasta cuando sera el aguante del sufrido ecuador

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site