- Global Voices - https://globalvoices.org -

Gandhi and YouTube has India talking

Categories: South Asia, India, Arts & Culture, Freedom of Speech, Governance, Humor, Media & Journalism

A YouTube clip of Mahatma Gandhi doing a pole dance by Gautam Prashad, a New York-based comedian/clown/yoga teacher of Indian origin created quite a bit of wave on the other side of the continent. The Indian Government was not amused by Prashad's modern day interpretation of Gandhi (India's Father of the Nation) and had the video clip banned in India. Google had to remove the clip. Plus a couple of Indian channels that showed the video clip have been asked to apologize. The original offender in the Indian Government's eye: Gautam Prashad has also apologized.

For the past year Google has had its fair share of challenges in India. First, it was Orkut, and now Google Video. How did Indian bloggers react to this Google video clip of Gandhi? The bloggers reaction covers the whole spectrum from free speech to  don't watch to strong disapproval to let us move on, shall we?

Pooja Nair [1] is not amused with Prashad's video clip. Her strong disapproval dissolves into some career advice for Prashad. She writes:

I feel sorry for him. I don't mean to mock him. I am genuinely concerned for the chap. I think he should shift careers. Maybe he'll do better as a pizza delivery guy or a taxi driver.

Shivam Vij [2] has this to say about the video clip: don't watch it if it offends you. Shivam's  post also has a response from Prashad, the creator of the Gandhi clip, who says that he used this clip as a marketing tool.

Amit Verma [3] wonders if this whole episode:

Free speech is becoming more and more endangered in this country.

Great Bong [4], who thinks the video clip was in poor taste has this to say about the Indian government's reaction to the video clip:

Coming back to the main point, the biggest loser in this glorious spectacle is the Indian government, which consistently insists on behaving like the typical crackpot Islamic state in obsessively frothing at the mouth in response to any perceived insult. In its infinite wisdom, it has served show-causes to the Indian channels which carried the news and called for the video to be taken down failing which a ban would be placed on Youtube.

Pass the roti on the left hand side [5]  gives an overview of the entire episode (the YouTube does not seem to work) and says that it is time to move on.