Close

Support Global Voices

To stay independent, free, and sustainable, our community needs the help of friends and readers like you.

Donate now »

See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

India: Bloggers react to the bomb blasts in Mumbai

Mumbai was hit by serial blasts today. Commuters in trains on one of the railway lines (Western Railway) were killed by bombs that went off in seven different trains. The blasts occured around 1825 hrs, which is the peak hour for commute in Mumbai, as office goers leave South Mumbai to go back home to the suburbs. Estimates suggest that the body count is around 180 as of now.

Within minutes, the Mumbai Help blog came alive with messages, comments and offers to help. The blog started last year to cope with the floods, and started to fill the information and communiation gap. This particular post asks readers to provide phone numbers of people they want to check on, or inform. Metroblogging Mumbai has been doing updates on the issue. This is an open thread on the blog.

Amit at India Uncut has a post with frequent updates as the situation changes. With the mainstream media reporting with the trademark cluelessness, More on Mumbai by Jayesh. Blogpourri comments on the smugness of a particular mainstream media news channel. NowPublic features images taken by a citizen journalist, Dharmesh Thakkar. Pajamas Media collates links from mainsteam media and blogs. At Indian Writing there is this dedication to the particular intimacy that can be formed on public transport:

To “train friendship”. To every kind of friendship. To remember those whom the city has lost, and to honour their memories by holding together and never letting the violence win.

Gaurav Sabnis grieves for the city and its people.

It's been a tough day for the city, and the tragedy has a slightly personal note for me too. I am fortunate that neither me nor any of my acquaintances were victims today. But Western Line is “my” line. I have regularly travelled on those very tracks. The idea that almost 200 people were killed along the very familiar landscape which is a part of my life chills me, angers me and saddens me.

Contrapuntal asks why Bombay? and looks forward, hoping that there is no backlash.

Why Bombay? Why always Bombay? Because it's big and successful, so if you can make a splash there you're sure to hit the big time. (Why does anyone go to Bombay?) Please please let there not be a backlash. I'm incoherent. I'm not trying to write an article ok? The trains, soft spot, so horrifyingly easy. It's a miracle it hadn't happened before. And now what? How do you screen every single person who gets into a Bombay train?

Waking up twice on the assumptions that are made in times like these. Ultrabrown has notes on the terror attack and screenshots of the coverage. The Renegade of Junk on right-wing bloggers in the US indulging in their standard fare.

Many right wing bloggers in the US are somehow trying to link these bomb blasts with their own domestic selfish pro-Bush agenda, as bongopondit pointed out in the comments. The rest are engaging in highly clueless analysis of the events. For example Captain Ed of Captain's Quarters.

Scout on being outside India at a time like this and watching the news on television.

People here feel sad about us Indians. They can't imagine a life where bombs go undetected and terrorism is something they talk about in political science classes. But for us, it is a part of life – inevitable. But being away from India puts things into sharp perspective for me, I see it both ways and it hurts that much more.

Dhoomketu on the blasts and what he learnt today. On the Ganga Mail reflects on the city.

That's the thing about Bombay: you don't have to go to the city to see it. Those into Hindi movies have grown up in it without even setting foot on it. That's why it hurts even a Bihari or a Bengali when tragedy strikes far-off Bombay. It is the surrogate hometown of every Hindi movie-watcher.

Dilip goes to one of the stations which was hit, and writes about a car that is forced to take in passengers. A flickr set called Black Bombay has been created to collect images from the blast sites.

Lame politicians as usual and please, no one talk about God. Suketu Mehta discusses the blasts in the city online at the Washington Post.

28 comments

  • Vishal

    Hello world,

    I’m from India and I’m shocked by what has happened at Mumbai same as it happened in Madrid and in NY in recent past…

    One striking thing that grabbed my attention… that no one else has thought of it till now…. In NY, it happened on 11/7 and in Mumbai, it has took place on 7/11 ! Is there any hidden message in this? Are there the same people behind the Mumbai attack as they were in NY attack? Are they trying to send us any message or make us all remember the 11/7 incident or their very brutality aganinst humanity and poor innocent people? At the end, I admit my heart truly breaks seeing all poor innocent people dying in such a manner in London, Madrid, NY and now in Mumbai… Does anyone knows when it will end OR more innocent people still have to wait for their turn to get killed brutally in this way?

    Are all world leaders just concerned about keeping their economies on track? Is there no value of human soul and humanity truly? Who is going to end all this?

  • India must send a signal to the terrorists by wholeheartedly joining the American war on terror in response to the bombings today. Like the UK and Japan, India must stand with the free democratic world in committing blood and treasure to combat this evil.

  • Neha, you are doing a wonderful job. You make us proud.

  • Kuch Batay….
    kuch ankahi batay reh gaye
    Kuch adhuray lamhay reh gaye
    Aray yaar woh khayalat hi adhuray reh gaye
    Chodo kya ‘rang’egay basanti’ ko
    jub haalat hi haath say reh gaye

    Aaj hi tou usko milna tha
    ha bhayee aaj hi ki mulaquat tay huee thee
    Do saal say ek doosray ko train mai dekhtay thay
    Ek din hosla kur kay baat kur hi li
    woh mulaquaat bhi adhuri reh gayee

    Bus jaldi college khatam kur lu
    phir ma baap kay liye woh gadi looga
    kuch aisa hi soch raha tha ki
    soch soch mai hi reh gayee

    “Mujhay tumhari shakal hi nahi dekhni”
    Esa kyu keh kur nikli aaj woh
    Pyaar say jaati tou aacha hota
    Zindagi bhur dil pur uskay yahi baat reh gayee

    Aray yaar 8 mahinay hogaye
    bus ek mahina reh gaya
    Phir mai usko pet pay leta kur khela karuga
    woh khilanay valay haath hi na reh gaye

  • […] 炼结:India: Bloggers react to the bomb blasts in Mumbai 作者:Neha Viswanathan 翻译:Portnoy 孟买今天遭遇多起炸弹攻击。搭乘火车通勤的人们在一条轨道上(西部轨道)被炸弹夺走了生命,七辆不同的火车同时发生爆炸。爆炸发生时间大约是下午六点25分,正好是孟买通勤的尖峰时段,下班的人潮正离开南孟买,准备回到郊区。估计目前约有180具尸体。  […]

  • […] The bad news: hierarchy is precisely what we wanted to avoid. The unattainable pot of gold was equal voice by every voice … and in that we failed. The good news is that increased organization, articulation of roles, and transparent policy will ensure our longterm existence in the 21st century media market. When bombs hit Bombay and when missiles strike Beirut, our understanding of those events won’t be bottlenecked by the understanding of a few dozen reporters. We will hear directly from those who ride the trains, those who tell their stories and their histories as the missiles come down. […]

  • rustom jamasji

    Do Pass This On To Indians and Pakistanis All over the world

    To,

    1) Members of the L.eT,and various jehadi organisations.Though you operate under the banner and name of God , you all are fooling yourselves that you have anything to do with Him. Infact you are not even soldiers, you are all cowards! hiding your faces. All you did and do was to keep your brethern and women under fear in Afghanistan, Pakistan and countries where women do not have the guts to fight your guns and your cowardly , un manly acts,– possing to be fighters of God is the most hypocratical thing ever suggested.
    2)Leaders of Kasmhmiri politics and Kashmiri’s who want seperation from India , you do not have a right to break a country just because you are born in it. Just as we mumbaikars , delhiites etc cannot ask for a seperate state , you also cannot stretch your freedom to break India.If you like Pakistan then go to it. Mirwaish sheikh and Huryat leaders , if you did in any Islamic country what you do in India due to our tolerance you would have regreted being born. Anyway no amount of bomb blasts will scare us in giving you any part of India, infact we vow never to be scared in being blackmailed by your cowardly acts. Stop now or you may just have to face the wrath of a comon Mumbaiker!
    3)President Musharaf , your offer to help India or any other country in capturing Islamic terrorist is a bad joke! You must be the ONLY General whose Army hides behind the viels of Islam and hizbuls mujahideens. Your Army never did and never will have the guts to face a open war against India or any other country. It makes us common mumbaikers feel pity for you as a general and your army.

    4)Dear Pakistani citizen , we have no haterd against you but feel our duty to warn you that if your country persists the way it is , before India falls, the mulah will stop your daughters, wifes and sisters from studying and make you husbands , sons compulsarily dorn a beard ! Wake up and protect yourselves from the anti India mania! before you hand your next generation to the taliban

    5) Indian politician especially the young Harward returns, ,like the young Deora. Gandhi’s and Pilot and Abdullah , wake up or your respect in our eyes will be the same as a begger on the streets

    Please make Mulayam singh the Chief of R.A.W as he has already completed investigations and given S.I.M.I a clean chit ,while the actual investigating agencies sweat it out !

  • The signals emanating from the ‘powers-that-be’ indicate that the bomb blasts that took place today are likely to have an adverse impact on the ‘confidence building measures’ between India and Pakistan that have been on a fast track in the recent past.

    I suppose that is what those who orchestrated the serial attacks sought to achieve and those who have been working hard on the peace process must feel somewhat like the members of a cricket team chasing a big total and having lost a crucial wicket.

  • Sarit

    I think the closest thing to justice that victims of Bombay Train blasts will get is a sympathy speech from our Prime minister, who isn’t man enough to be any country’s prime minister…besides he is simply a puppet. The one who call shots in India is too busy celebrating her country’s World Cup Victory.

  • Hi-

    My opinions are stated on my blog – http://gandhi.wordpress.com/

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices!

Submitted addresses will be confirmed by email, and used only to keep you up to date about Global Voices and our mission. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Newsletter powered by Mailchimp (Privacy Policy and Terms).

* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site