See all those languages up there? We translate Global Voices stories to make the world's citizen media available to everyone.

Learn more about Lingua Translation  »

Central America on C.A.F.T.A.

Several high profile op-ed's have recently been published concerning next week's House vote on the Central America Free Trade Agreement and the North American blogosphere has been quick to respond. What about Central Americans’ opinions you ask?

Victor Rivera, on the bilingual blog, Enlace Noticias from El Salvador, quotes World Bank estimates on CAFTA and tries to weigh out the costs and benefits for all players. Focusing on El Salvador, then then writes:

Our countries are at a commercial disadvantage, this is clear. We have more natural resources than we have manual labor and what we export best are actual Salvadoreans, whose remittances are day by day the most important sector in El Salvador. And this, ladies and gentleman, is the only political explanation of why we should support CAFTA … so that our fellow Salvadoreans working in the U.S. aren't sent back and are able to keep pushing El Salvador ahead.

cafta

“Farm Family Marching Against CAFTA” by Shannon Howard of
www.EsperanzaEnAccion.org

Dean Córnito from Costa Rica is more straight-forward in his support of C.A.F.T.A. as well as his disgust for former Costa Rican president Rodrigo Carazo who recently visited the U.S. on an anti-CAFTA lobbying trip organized by OXFAM. He is especially frustrated by Carazo's claim at the Carnegie Endowment that 75% of Costa Ricans were opposed to CAFTA without naming a source. Córnito, on the other hand, links to three surveys which all seem to disagree with Carazo's claim.

A March and April poll by the Institute of Social Studies in Population at the National University of Costa Rica found that 41% were in favor of CAFTA, 38% against, and 21% indifferent or undecided.

cafta protestOn June 8th, the Costa Rican newspaper, Al Día published their results which found that 44.3% of Costa Ricans were in favor of CAFTA while 26.7% were against the agreement.

Finally, a poll carried out by Unimer for La Nacion found in May that if a nation-wide referendum was held on CAFTA, 49% would vote in support while 46% would vote against it.

Another Costa Rican blog, the news star, reacts to the recent push by the Citizen Action Party (PAC) to renegotiate CAFTA so it would include open migration like that of the EU:

Are these people stupid or what? How could it occur to them to ask for something of this magnitude, when they know that CAFTA is not going to be renegotiated and much less that the United States would permit a migratory clause of this nature.

And finally Salvadoreños alrededor del Mundo, a new blog for Salvadoreans living outside the country, uses one of its first posts to promote the benefits of CAFTA:

With the approval of CAFTA en the senate of the United States, a new page of hope is opened in the Central American region. The benefits go towards the attraction of investment and consequently a greater number of exports.

Special thanks to Global Voices reader Iria Puyosa who provided several of the links and the idea for the post.

2 comments

  • Spanish-speakers (unfortunately my blog is in Spanish only): I have made a more conscientious and in-depth analysis of CAFTA than that which was cited above, which you can find at:

    Part 1

    Part 2

    Thanks,

    Dean CóRnito

  • Rocio

    You might also want to check http://www.porcostarica.org, a costarrican organization in favor of the CAFTA. Carazo definitively does not represent the Costa Ricans feelings on the CAFTA.

Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Receive great stories from around the world directly in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the best of Global Voices
* = required field
Email Frequency



No thanks, show me the site